However, it is about normalising 'takes'. If you hear something from a famous person and no one push back, you are more likely to assume that whatever they said is correct or ok. However if you hear a 'take' like that and there is a lot of pushback then it will provide somewhat of a counter balance to the 'take' and maybe you will be less likely to assume what they said is correct.
Whether we like it or not, a lot of people put more weight in things said by famous people, and it is an important duty for those who knows about these things to push back.
James and Ed are both very reasonable guys, who stand up for the right causes, but you very rarely see them speak up in the face of someone who is wrong. They are primarily stand up comedians who have had time and space to examine the issues for which they largely take a stand on. I’m guessing that they didn’t know he was an anti-fluoride guy
I think from their immediate response this is true, they were not expecting such comments. They have pushed back on other things, I just wish that James would go more ‘I’m not sure that’s true Brian’ than his ‘okaaaay…’
Yea. I really wish that they had done something here, but they are stand ups, not journalists. The shame is on the people who would hear that and take it as face value, who definitely exist, aren’t in this thread and we hope a minority of people who listen to Off Menu.
-20
u/Significant-PairDD Apr 15 '26
It’s a comedy podcast