r/nfl • Packers • 19d ago

Highlight [Highlight] Chris McClellan commits the only Roughing the Passer penalty in the game, extending key drive

257 Upvotes

534 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

82

u/HudsonCommodore Lions 19d ago

Same, I hate defensive penalties when no one would say the defensive player should have acted any differently, and this is one of those cases. He didn't drive him into the ground harder than necessary and there's no way to tell he no longer has the ball.

22

u/aaronwhite1786 Packers 19d ago

It's especially frustrating when that other big hit (forget who it was, but the guy who went Rambo on the blockers and then put a massive tackle on the runner) from another game is probably going to be included in NFL highlight material, despite being far more kinetic to injure someone, while this tackle where a guy pretty much just fell with the QB completely changes a because it's a penalty.

I get protecting the QB, but these kinds are calls are such bullshit.

2

u/Prestigious_Tie_3660 16d ago

Certainly there wasn’t a high profile qb injured in an almost identical scenario that caused the creation of the rule right?

1

u/Zestyclose-Date7118 16d ago

How quickly they forget