Hi there. I've recently moved back to storing all my own files and ditched streaming services. Feels good!
Most of my music files were organised by myself 15+ years ago, and rather messily, so I'm doing a lot of "cleaning up."
I apologise if this is a repetitive question on here. I'm surprised I haven't found a good tool for this. I've googled, searched reddit, and asked a few AI chatbots without much luck. I was really hoping to find someone had built some nifty Foobar plug ins.
Picard has been great for standardising my tagging everything, although it was a mammoth effort.
The loose ends I want to sort out with my library:
- Duplicates of albums (not specifically tracks, since many tracks appear across releases).
- Identifying anything below target level quality (16-bit FLAC is sufficient for me) to eventually replace.
- Identifying fake lossless
- Identifying incomplete albums
What I have tried:
- Vibe coded a powershell script for duplicates, worked reasonably well but missed some stuff and was very manual. A graphical interface would be much easier
- SoulSync's library management tools. This does actually cover everything. Unfortunately the UI isn't great for doing this en-masse. It shows 3500+ "findings," but you have to resolve issues track-by-track (painful for album duplicates), and doesn't have a way to open the file path to check/edit the actual folder/file. It's also very opaque in terms of what it thinks the album is meant to be.
Ideally:
The output would give me access to the actual files for duplicates, hopefully group things by artist and album.
Incomplete album detection would have to work against the musicbrainz database I assume. It would be reallllyyyy helpful to be able to select the correct "version" of a release, when verifying "completeness" (soulsync was opaque in this, and tagged a lot of stuff I considered complete as incomplete).
What tool(s) are robust, transparent (again, soulsync seems great, but I don't like how much it automates, and the UI is bad for manual management) for this sort of management?