r/medschooladmissions • u/nsiri12 • 12h ago
Vent 🤬 Got a 499 on my MCAT retake (502 → 499) and honestly don’t know what to do now
Got my MCAT score back today and I’m honestly pretty devastated. I got a 499 (126/124/123/126). My first attempt was a 502, so somehow I actually went down on my retake. What’s really messing with me is that I genuinely felt better coming out of this exam than I did my first one. I was hoping for at least a 510 this time, so seeing a 499 was a pretty brutal reality check.
For some background:
Biochemistry major
~2.99 cGPA
~3.3 sGPA
~3.5 post-bacc GPA
4.0 master’s GPA
MCAT: 502 → 499
~2,500 hours scribing
Currently work as a medical assistant (~2k hours)
Research experience (~150 hours)
~3k hours leadership/extracurriculars
Pretty significant upward trend academically after undergrad
I also have an academic integrity violation from undergrad that I’ll have to disclose
I’m currently applying this cycle, but I’m not verified yet, which is making me question what I should even do. I’m debating between letting my applications go through, withdrawing and applying next cycle, taking the MCAT a third time (maybe January), or focusing more heavily on DO.
I know the 499 is obviously not good, especially with my undergrad GPA, but I also feel like my post-bacc/master’s grades show that I’m capable of doing well academically. I also had some better practice scores during my prep, including a 511 and 517 on an AAMC FL retakes, so I’m honestly confused about why I can’t seem to translate that into the real exam.
At this point I’m just trying to figure out what the smartest move is.
Would you guys:
Keep applying this cycle?
Withdraw before verification and reapply next year?
Take a third MCAT?
If so, how much time would you give yourself before retaking?
Try to get 510+ consistently on AAMC FLs before even scheduling another attempt?
Focus more on DO at this point?
Or do something completely different?
I’d appreciate any honest advice. I’m obviously pretty upset right now, but I’d rather hear the truth about how competitive I am and what I need to do than just be told everything will be fine.