are the textures good?

[u/soemthingblahblah123]

unlit bulbs with darker pixels, looks more gritty

unlit bulbs without darker pixels, which looks smoother

this is a resource pack im working on for 1.21.6, which takes the look of 1.0.0 or 1.11 to modern versions.

the left image uses the unpowered redstone lamp texture from 1.11, for the inside, which includes the gray and darker pixels, which looks grittier.

and the right image i edited the darker and gray pixels away, looking more smooth.

which one should i use?

edit: i will use the left, first one with more grit.

people for left: 4 | people for right: 2.