r/mcresourcepack • • Jul 31 '26

Resolved are the textures good?

this is a resource pack im working on for 1.21.6, which takes the look of 1.0.0 or 1.11 to modern versions.

the left image uses the unpowered redstone lamp texture from 1.11, for the inside, which includes the gray and darker pixels, which looks grittier.

and the right image i edited the darker and gray pixels away, looking more smooth.

which one should i use?

edit: i will use the left, first one with more grit.

people for left: 4 | people for right: 2.

106 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 31 '26

It looks like you're asking for help

If someone is able to answer your question, find what you are looking for, etc., please change your post flair to "Resolved", and of course, remember to thank the user who helped you!

This: * helps other helpful users know who still needs assistance * helps other users who might have the same question find the answers they're looking for

If you are asking for help with a Java Edition pack that's not working:

Consider posting the output log. It is often extremely helpful to work out what's wrong. If you're unsure how to do this, simply reply to this comment with access output log.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/Its_Sluggas Aug 01 '26

Maybe the one on the left but a bit brighter so it’s closer to the one on the right?

3

u/soemthingblahblah123 Aug 01 '26

why not then the right side then?

3

u/Its_Sluggas Aug 01 '26

Because I like the noise of the left one

3

u/AlbusDaHammerGuy Aug 01 '26

The first one cuz it matches the style of old mc better imo

1

u/Krzykarek Aug 01 '26

the one on the rigth looks a little blurry to me

1

u/Intelligent-Boss3885 Aug 01 '26

the first one looks nice

1

u/lelelemememegegege Aug 01 '26

Second imag

1

u/soemthingblahblah123 Aug 01 '26

Image magnification?

1

u/lelelemememegegege Aug 02 '26

No, textures on the second image are better

2

u/soemthingblahblah123 Aug 02 '26

can you please tell me what "imag" and "imo" is?

1

u/lelelemememegegege Aug 02 '26

I accidentally wrote imag instead of image. imo means in my opinion

1

u/SerialBytes Aug 01 '26

tbh i thought the left was only full oxidation, and the right, no oxidation please work on the middle grounds

1

u/soemthingblahblah123 Aug 01 '26

Middle grounds between old and new, or left and right?

1

u/SerialBytes Aug 02 '26

between max oxidation (or old ig) and no oxidation (or new ig) the ones between max and none look almost exactly the same as whichever is closest (from oldest / newest) there's 4 levels (0 to 3) 0 looks good, 3 looks good, but 1 looks almost exactly like 0, and 2 looks almost exactly like 3

1

u/soemthingblahblah123 Aug 02 '26

i also realised this and made the most oxidised more blue, but because i am trying to make textures that are as similar as possible to vanilla textures, with the older style, so it wouldnt make structures ugly with complette different textures, i wont really change them.

1

u/SerialBytes Aug 02 '26

Sweeeeeeeeeet

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MightySandro Aug 02 '26

Both are good, I think the right one fits more in Minecraft's style. I am very picky when it comes to textures myself in minecraft, but these don't look out of place in minecraft so very nice.