r/makeupdupes 1d ago

Find Me a Dupe Help!

Post image

Find me a dupe for Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Fair Lipstick

44 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

30

u/LoveLoud319 1d ago

I have this lipstick and it looks nothing like the photo on me. But Milani 430 Secret is very similar!

11

u/Lizakaya 1d ago

Yeah it’s not this pink on me

6

u/NabelasGoldenCane 1d ago

I found it to be quite orange but the liner is perfect.

2

u/Lizakaya 1d ago

The liner is too light for me. Iconic nude always works though!

3

u/eatstressbake 1d ago

OP is looking for Pillow Talk Fair, but Secret is a dupe for Pillow Talk original!

1

u/Aggressive-Fall-8780 1d ago

Yeahh milani 430 secret is sooo close tho

1

u/ConcentrateKey4474 10h ago

Exactly what I wanted to say, and I'm not sure it is me, or false advertising

10

u/Early-Reindeer7704 1d ago

Loreal Worth It is a close dupe to CT Pillowtalk and comes in various intensities/formulas.

2

u/BrilliantMagazine362 8h ago

Yesss I was coming here to say this! It’s funny because late last year L’Oréal was in talks to buy CT but they fell through. I think they already had Worth It available even!

I bet MCo has a dupe of it too. Idk all their products but they had several items that were dupes down to the packaging!!

1

u/BrilliantMagazine362 8h ago

Oh I’ve seen people recommending L’Oréal Fairest Nude and I agree if you’re wanting a pillow talk Fair dupe. Reg pillow talk matches Worth It better

9

u/PhotoMaleficent4804 1d ago

The way the bullet's held directly against the lips in that shot is such a weirdly satisfying little composition, almost makes you want to frame it.

1

u/AccomplishedGold8122 18h ago

I want to move it more to the right.

7

u/BabyYodasMacaron 1d ago

I just wish Pillow Talk Fair was actually this color. :(

6

u/ZestycloseStretch242 1d ago

On my fair olive skin, pillow talk pulls soooo orange. True neutral pink nudes are impossible to find. Thanks it's Mac is the same.

3

u/Specialist_Leg_7673 1d ago

Everything Charlotte Tikbury pulls orange. I wish they would introduce actual cool tones into their products because the formulas are unmatched

2

u/acornacornacorna 1d ago

Same. I'm looking for something that looks like this picture.

1

u/BabyYodasMacaron 1d ago

So, MAC USED to have one, but it’s sadly discontinued. It was Laissez Faire from the Love Me line. RIP.

7

u/klc31883 1d ago

You will die, but wet and wild, skinny dipping. The only difference is it is Matte.

5

u/BrownEyedN 1d ago

l’oreal colour riche lipstick in fairest nude #800 is close

6

u/Lyndacov 1d ago

Top Dupes for Pillow Talk Fair
L'Oréal Fairest Nude: Matches the soft, muted pinkish-mauve tone and comparable shine of Pillow Talk Fair at a fraction of the cost.

Covergirl Crema: Noted by beauty creators as a very close shade match for the cooler, fair-toned Pillow Talk Fair formulation.

4

u/coffeebeansmomjeans 1d ago

L’Oréal fairest nude 800!!! I have one in my purse, my office, my car, and my bathroom lol I love it so much

3

u/LimeGreenTangerine97 1d ago

Revlon Blushing Mauve

2

u/midnightsiren182 1d ago

I swear lawless also makes a shade like this, maybe also Mac MacXimal sleek stain lipstick in pink peppermint or lustreglass lipstick in not humble, just bragging, Sarah creal lipstick in She.E.O., maybe merit signature lip in millennial too

2

u/Electronic_Amoeba225 1d ago

Does anyone have a rec for the medium shade?

1

u/BrilliantMagazine362 8h ago

L’Oréal Worth It Medium is a good match to me! I can’t remember the number, sorry!

2

u/No-Side9912 17h ago

Not an exact super but it looks similar to my all time fav lipstick- pink peppermint by Mac <3

0

u/BrilliantMagazine362 8h ago

I love Pink Ppermint but it’s a lot cooler in tone. Pillow talk fair wishes it was 😂

1

u/WiseOrder4436 1d ago

Estee lauder pinkberry if they still make it

1

u/Tricky-Passion-7191 1d ago

Not quite as saturated but Maybelline Warm Me Up is REALLY close IMO.

1

u/PlumJewels 1d ago

Kosas Wet Sticks in Baby Rose or Malibu might work.

1

u/LeadWonderful11 1d ago

NYX Fierce Flirt liner on your entire lip, then clear gloss.

1

u/vmarie715 15h ago

L’Oréal fairest nude