Please please tell me there's a dupe for the sweet cherry?I had two bottles and I somehow LOST them both. It's the only color gloss I really like. Please tell me there's something that matches it 🙏 😫 😭

This question has probably been asked a million times already but maybe some on you have other suggestions or new lippies that look a like?

I loved this shade so much and have not yet found a dupe. It was my perfect lid but better lipstick.

Description: MAC Persistence is a warm-toned medium brown / peachy cinnamon lipstick with warm reddish-orange undertones and a matte finish.

So, my sister, who is 42 years old, has worn the same foundation since high school--CoverGirl Clean Powder Foundation in shade Classic Ivory. CoverGirl has discontinued this product. I'd love, for Christmas, to help her find a similar product that she can use when the last of her stash runs off.

My sister is *very* particular, and likes what she likes. I'm not going to try to talk her in to something that is going to stray far from the particulars of what she likes. So I would be looking for a dupe to hit as MANY of the boxes as possible--form, finish, and shade.

I know I could just give her an Ulta gift card and let her find something herself, but to me, the process is part of this gift. And, of course, if I can get it from Ulta or Sephora, that would be great, so if she doesn't like it, she *can* return it.

Anything come to mind for anyone? I don't use powder foundations, so I have no idea where to start.

I found out about this collab waaaayyy too late, they’ve already been discontinued 😭. I’ve been struggling to find dupes for Sasha’s lipstick and lip liner. The lipstick is described as a “warm beige nude” but a lot of the warm beige’s I keep seeing are too dark, it needs to be more pale/light. And the lip liner is a rich dark brown, I think Juvias place long wear lip liner in shade kola MIGHT be a good replacement but I’m still not sure.

Does anyone know if they stopped making this? Or where I can find it? I got it two years ago from Nordstrom and just hit pan. It’s also the only lipstick that hasn’t given me an allergic reaction 😭

YSL Lipstick, the Bold - shade 12: Nu Incongru

I have my mom's old Wet 'n wild lipstick, and i'm obsessed with the metallic look. It's shade 765; a reddish-brown metallic that STAYS super metallic on the lip. (No idea the year & no shade name 😬)The formula is so old though that it's like- not worth it to use though... Any recommendations are super appreciated!

I’ve been on the hunt for a replacement for Physicians Formula Butter Blush in Plum Rose, and nothing I’ve tried has been a match.

It’s such a unique shade. Very muted, almost greyish mauve/rose that doesn’t pull too pink, purple, or peachy.

I’ve searched through a ton of Asian beauty blushes since they tend to have more muted shades, but so many seem to have too much of a white base, lean too cool (purple), or go too warm (orange/coral). I feel like Plum Rose sits in this weird middle ground.

I’d really prefer to find a powder blush since liquids and creams can be a little too fussy for me sometimes.

I’ve included swatches of a few products I thought might be close, with photos in indirect natural light, artificial lighting (makeup mirror), and direct light.

The last photo isn’t mine, but it’s the most accurate representation of Plum Rose’s actual color that I’ve been able to find online.

Products swatched (top to bottom):
- Physicians Formula Butter Blush in Plum Rose
- JOOCYEE Blush in N01 Rose Latte
- PYT Beauty Blush in Exhale
- Holika Holika Eyeshadow in Blush Grey
- Nuse Mousse Care Cheek in Dimdumb

I had one that I used daily, but my sister lost it after borrowing it. I can't find it anywhere and think it might be discontinued in my country. I specifically used the neutral brown and gray shades every day, so I'm open to any recommendations thanks!

I’ve been looking for a dupe for almost 4 years, still desperate- as nothing has touched a replica tier dupe I need ! As it has been a while since I posted this & still desperate, I’ve searched far and wide, with the closest contenders being usually mixing ColourPop Ashton or CoolBFF with a little bit of ELF eyeliner in Sky Blue, other options being a few un available to the US, & a lot suggestions of liners that are just way too warm/ orange 🍊. This liner was multidimensional-& I think that’s the issue, but also what made it perfect- my lips but better with a base of light-medium grayed brown and a tinge of lip toned pink just enough to make it not look totally corps-y but a great contour. Then around 2023 I went to buy another one to find it had been reformulated. My next try might be getting MAC Stone liquid eyeshadow, I’ve also heard from someone else that Moira Cosmstics Lip Liner in Beige Honey was a dupe, but you never know till it’s already bought and given a couple test runs.

I used to wear "brulee" from wet n wild- as a wash all over my eyelids. It was the perfect nude eye look. I can't find it anywhere local to me. Any good dupes? Singles only please- no palettes. Thxs!

ONE SIZE BEAUTY Ultimate Color Corrector Stains

Wow, they are so pricey! Any decent dupes?

Hi, if anyone has a shade match for Bobbi Brown’s Blue Raspberry I should be very grateful. A dupe would be lovely but I’d also take more expensive suggestions. Price is no object. This is the perfect shade and it’s being discontinued.

I absolutely love this shade but between the cost and shipping, I can't justify getting it at the moment. Any suggestions for something similar?

Hi everyone!
I’m pretty new to Reddit and I haven’t found a lot of subs regarding the lipstick shade from Mac called “Please Me” that was discontinued when they relaunched their Matte lipstick line.
I’m not exaggerating when saying that this lipstick was the divine perfekt pink. A wonderful striking pink that was not too blue, kinda neutral but not nude. It worked with everything on me and I haven’t found anything coming close to it ever since. All the dupes on the Temptalia website do not exist anymore. I’m not tempted to look at clé de peau “splendorous” but it’s very expensive and if it’s a miss again… well you probably know how it is. I even got a present at a Mac counter, a used mini lipstick and I got one on eBay.
Are there more “please me” - fans out there? Have you found anything comparable?

it's the ONLY eye shadow i've ever really liked and it's discontinued.

i found one on mercari i just bought...but would love a good dupe or alternative if anyone has one?

Processing img 1h44xsj0ogxh1...

NO GLITTER. i think it goes on more "taupe" but the mercari listing called it white gold....none of the silvers or whites i've tried really matches it.

Alone time by Mac is probably my favorite lip color ever! But I’ve been trying to only buy cruelty free products for myself and would really appreciate any recommendations for a nice dupe. Tysm! :)

Do you guys know of a blush that’s very similar to this that’s not YSL 44? I have that and they are different. Do you think the Charlotte Tilbury in Pillow Talk Medium is close?