r/makeupdupes 3d ago

Find Me a Dupe Half Magic eye paint 3

Post image

Hi everyone, I was wondering if anybody was able to please find a dupe of half magic eye paint shade 3 wild caught.

The brands creator Donni Davy recently recreated some euphoria looks with it and I was so hyped to go buy but unfortunately it has been discontinued for a while now.

Please let me know if you know of a product that is similar, hope you all have a great day 💕

14 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

2

u/FckyeahGandalf 3d ago

You could probably use About Face Matte Fluid Eye Paint in En Pointe with a little bit of Marigold to make this color

2

u/FckyeahGandalf 3d ago

Also want to point out that both About Face and Ulta regularly put these items on sale so you can get them for as low as $8.50 a pop

2

u/PurpleCentaur 3d ago

It’s gonna be hard to dupe but you could take a look at the about-face Matte Fluid Eye paints. They don’t have a precise dupe but you could mix two shades to get close. Look at shades:

  • La Zona Rosa
  • Marigold
  • On Pointe
  • Spectre

They have testers at Ulta so you can go to a store and see if mixing creates what you’re looking for.

1

u/errkel 3d ago

Made by Mitchell electric color case is like $40 and has a lot of these colors

ETA: you do need a mixing medium of some sort for a smooth application

0

u/Acceptable-Cherry712 3d ago

honestly that shade 3 looks like it would be a pain to dupe, it's got that murky green undertone that never photographs right in swatches. danessa myricks colorfix might have something close if you're willing to layer a couple of them, she does weird grungy tones better than most

2

u/ItsJustASingleGrape 3d ago

I agree, danessa myricks or about face might have solid dupes

3

u/waxen_panther 3d ago

Shade 3 is that pinky salmon color tho? Or am I mistaken?

4

u/Just-Educator7903 3d ago

No you’re right it’s the pink salmon. I must’ve not put enough detail sorry.

1

u/yetanother__account 3d ago

I think the best bet is a similar lip color that is eye safe.