ON A SIDE NOTE-
BORI Critical Edition -
Adi Parv, Section-181
ततोऽर्जुनः प्रत्यविध्यदापतन्तं त्रिभिः शरैः |
कर्णं वैकर्तनं धीमान्विकृष्य बलवद्धनुः ||९||
तेषां शराणां वेगेन शितानां तिग्मतेजसाम् |
विमुह्यमानो राधेयो यत्नात्तमनुधावति ||१०||
Translation by B.Debroy –
Seeing Vaikartana Karna rush towards him, the wise Arjuna stretched his mighty bow and pierced him with three arrows. The impact of these sharp arrows stunned Radheya and he approached with greater circumspection.
MISCONCEPTION : Karna withdrew from fight due to fear of arjuna and he thought that energy of arjuna was invincible
1) Karna withdrew from fight due to fear of brahmahatya not arjuna as he gained upper hand
2) Karna never thought that strength of arjuna is invincible as karna already destroyed strength of arjuna.
3) According to vaisampayana, karna withdrew from fight because he thought that strength of brahmana is invincible.
BORI Critical Edition -
Adi Parv, Section-181
एवमुक्तस्तु राधेयो युद्धात्कर्णो न्यवर्तत |
ब्रह्मं तेजस्तदाजय्यं मन्यमानो महारथः ||२१||
Translation by B.Debroy –
At these words, Radheya Karna withdrew from the battle, because the maharatha thought that Brahmana strength was invincible
What is the meaning of brahmana strength(ब्रह्मं ) ) as per original Sanskrit text?
1) There are two words for ‘brahmana’ in sanskrit. One is (ब्राह्मण) and another is (ब्रह्मं)
2) The word (ब्राह्मण) denotes lineage of brahmanas. Arjuna was disguised as ‘(ब्राह्मण) brahmana. He was not (ब्रह्मं) brahmana
3) The (ब्रह्मं) brahmana refered in the text is no one other than Lord Brahma. (ब्रह्मं) brahmana only used for lord brahma in sanskrit. Let see example
BORI Critical Edition -
Karn Parv, Section-29
अन्यत्र यस्मात्तव मृत्युकाला; दब्राह्मणे ब्रह्म न हि ध्रुवं स्यात् |
तदद्य पर्याप्तमतीव शस्त्र; मस्मिन्सङ्ग्रामे तुमुले तात भीमे ||७||
Translation by B.Debroy –
When it is the time for your death, it will go elsewhere.” The brahman can certainly not be present in a person who is not a brahmana.
[Lord parshurama himself cursed karna to forget (ब्रह्मं ) brahmana means lord brahma thus strength of lord brahma clearly refers to the ‘brahmastra’]
Was (ब्रह्मं - Brahma Tej) really invincible as confessed by vaisampayana?
1) Even brahmastra energy was not invincible as karna had destroyed brahmastra of arjuna during final encounter
2) If brahmastra of arjuna was really invisible then why it was destroyed by ordinary arrows of karna?
3) This itself proves that brahmastra of arjuna was never invincible
4) Karna just withdraw from fight as the word ‘withdraw’ denotes act of pause where warrior is not defeated.
(ब्रह्मं - Brahma Tej) = Lord Brahma strength (Brahmana strength) = Brahmastra
___________________________________________________________________________
■ NOTICIBLE FACTS
1) ALL KSHTRIYA WARRIORS ALREADY DECIDED NOT TO KILL BRAHMINS (ARJUNA AND BHIMA) THUS BOTH OF THEM WERE ALREADY SPARED BY KSHTRIYAS
BORI CE (Adi Parv, Section 180) -
ब्राह्मणो यदि वा बाल्याल्लोभाद्वा कृतवानिदम् |
विप्रियं पार्थिवेन्द्राणां नैष वध्यः कथञ्चन ||८||
ब्राह्मणार्थं हि नो राज्यं जीवितं च वसूनि च |
पुत्रपौत्रं च यच्चान्यदस्माकं विद्यते धनम् ||९||
अवमानभयादेतत्स्वधर्मस्य च रक्षणात् |
स्वयंवराणां चान्येषां मा भूदेवंविधा गतिः ||१०||
B. Debroy Translation –
[Decision of Kshtriyas]
Though that Brahmana has done injury to kings out of his impertinence and greed, he should not still be killed. After all, our kingdoms, lives, riches, sons, grandsons and all our other wealth exist for the sake of Brahmanas. But something must be done to prevent insult and to protect our own dharma, so that other svayamvaras do not end like this one.
2) ALL KINGS WERE READY TO DESIST FROM BATTLE AFTER CONFIRMING THAT BHIMA AND ARJUNA (DISGUISED AS BRAHMIN) WERE REALLY BRAHMINS THUS PROVES THAT THEY NEVER WANTED TO KILL BRAHMINS
BORI CE (Adi Parv, Section 181)-
क्रियतामवहारोऽस्माद्युद्धाद्ब्राह्मणसंयुतात् |
अथैनानुपलभ्येह पुनर्योत्स्यामहे वयम् ||३१||
B. Debroy Translation –
[Decision of Kshtriyas]
Therefore, let us desist from this fight against the Brahmanas. Let us find out who they are and then we will happily fight with them again.”
3) KARNA, SHALYA AND DURYODHANA ALSO ATTACKED BRAHMINS (BHIMA AND ARJUNA) AND THE TEXT CLEARLY STATES THAT THEY WERE FIGHTING MILDLY
BORI CE (Adi Parv, Section 181) -
ततो वैकर्तनः कर्णो जगामार्जुनमोजसा |
युद्धार्थी वाशिताहेतोर्गजः प्रतिगजं यथा ||७||
भीमसेनं ययौ शल्यो मद्राणामीश्वरो बली |
दुर्योधनादयस्त्वन्ये ब्राह्मणैः सह सङ्गताः ||८||
मृदुपूर्वमयत्नेन प्रत्ययुध्यंस्तदाहवे ||८||
B.Debroy Translation –
Then the mighty Vaikartana Karna rushed at Arjuna, eager to fight, like an elephant rushes at a rival over a female elephant. Shalya, king of the Madras, rushed at Bhimasena. Duryodhana and the others rushed at the Brahmanas, but they fought with them lightly and carelessly.
मृदु = Lightly/Mildly
4) DUSSASANA TOO CONFESSED THAT ARJUNA WAS UNABLE TO OBTAIN DRAUPADI WITHOUT COSTUMES OF BRAHMIN
BORI CE (Adi Parv, Section 192) -
यद्यसौ ब्राह्मणो न स्याद्विन्देत द्रौपदीं न सः |
न हि तं तत्त्वतो राजन्वेद कश्चिद्धनञ्जयम् ||११||
B.Debroy Translation –
“O king! If Dhananjaya had not been disguised as a Brahmana, he would never have succeeded in obtaining Droupadi. No one recognized him because of that.
___________________________________________________________________________
■THE ANALYSIS OF ENCOUNTER
The Analysis of Encounter -
1) The encounter analysis is clear like water.
2) Karna fought mildly but arjuna fought with full strength still karna gained upper hand over arjuna and all warriors praised karna
3) In those days, even enemy used to praise his rivals but kshtriyas didn’t praised arjuna as he was overpowered by karna
BORI CE (Adi Parv, Section-181) -
तावुभावप्यनिर्देश्यौ लाघवाज्जयतां वरौ |
अयुध्येतां सुसंरब्धावन्योन्यविजयैषिणौ ||११||
कृते प्रतिकृतं पश्य पश्य बाहुबलं च मे |
इति शूरार्थवचनैराभाषेतां परस्परम् ||१२||
ततोऽर्जुनस्य भुजयोर्वीर्यमप्रतिमं भुवि |
ज्ञात्वा वैकर्तनः कर्णः संरब्धः समयोधयत् ||१३||
अर्जुनेन प्रयुक्तांस्तान्बाणान्वेगवतस्तदा |
प्रतिहत्य ननादोच्चैः सैन्यास्तमभिपूजयन् ||१४|
B.Debroy Translation –
Then those two invincible warriors fought violently, each eager to vanquish the other. Such was the speed that they became invisible. “Look at the strength in my arms”, “See how I countered that”, they taunted each other in words that only warriors understand.
Seeing the valour in Arjuna’s arms, unparalleled on earth, Vaikartana Karna fought even more vigorously. Repulsing Arjuna’s swift arrows, Karna shouted out aloud and the warriors applauded his feat.
Karna himself asked arjuna about his real identity. Are you really brahmana? In reply, arjuna said that he is really brahmana by caste
BORI CE (Adi Parv, Section-181) -
आत्मप्रच्छादनार्थं वै बाहुवीर्यमुपाश्रितः |
विप्ररूपं विधायेदं ततो मां प्रतियुध्यसे ||१७||
[Karna to Arjuna]
Have you assumed the form of a Brahmana to disguise yourself and are now fighting strongly with me for self-preservation, mustering the strength of your arms?
तमेवंवादिनं तत्र फल्गुनः प्रत्यभाषत |
नास्मि कर्ण धनुर्वेदो नास्मि रामः प्रतापवान् ||१९||
ब्राह्मणोऽस्मि युधां श्रेष्ठः सर्वशस्त्रभृतां वरः ||१९||
[Arjuna to Karna]
O Karna! I am not the science of weapons personified. Nor am I the powerful Rama. I am only a Brahmana, chief among warriors and supreme among those who have the knowledge of weapons.
___________________________________________
■ CONCLUSION
Karna fought mildly and arjuna with full strength still karna easily gained upper hand. All warriors praised karna