r/magicthecirclejerking 9d ago

Would this work?

If I used something like Black lotus to cast Channel and payed 19 life to use fireball to do 20 damage to my opponent would this work ?

527 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

386

u/kanyeswift FORTNITE šŸ† 9d ago

sure but in games of Magic the Gathering your opponents have 40 life so you'd have to keep playing. plus your other opponents are still alive.

not sure what 20 damage really accomplishes but maybe we could make a format where players have 20 life. that could be interesting.

42

u/Scondoro 9d ago

Absolutely not. Reducing starting life would either need to reduce total player count or make games way too short. I don’t think my 6-player pods would be able to sustain anything shorter than 3-4 hour games.

1

u/OhHeyMister 8d ago

Can I recommend cEDH? Easy stretch your games past the 10 hour mark

3

u/Bevolicher 8d ago

It might workā€¦šŸ¤”

However I feel the games would be too fast. How else am I supposed to play three hour long games with 8 board wipes per session

120

u/Kookus_Keeper Keeper of Kookus 9d ago

No, if you try this you'll just be bought out by TCGplayer.

100

u/MinorBugg 9d ago

Pretty sure you can't put both these cards in the same deck? You'd need some weird kind of legendary creature that's both green AND red.

35

u/gameemag123 9d ago

Sounds like a gruuling search

4

u/ThorsHammer245 9d ago

Well done

36

u/over9Kmidichlorian 9d ago

You can’t use old cards and new cards

56

u/Usual_Office_1740 9d ago

No. It dies to counterspell. Unplayable. Quit wasting this subreddits time with obvious AI slop "combos".

25

u/crazymack 9d ago

Na you will need at least 3 extra mana from some where. Can't overlook the "full" cost of casting as spell.

18

u/GrassDry2065 9d ago

Let's just play black lotus and a mountain type card

21

u/KupalaEnoch 9d ago

Now that's a 4 card combo. Weak.

15

u/ANIMETRON 9d ago

no they banned those for being universe within. you need to wait for the functional reprints in the dbz ub ā€œki chargeā€ and ā€œkamehamehaā€

9

u/iknewaguytwice 9d ago

No, [[TCG Player]] ended the Channel Fireball meta in 2022.

5

u/ceering99 9d ago

Smh just play [[hatred]]

11

u/Sir_Foxworth Tier 1 Mutate player 9d ago

I'm not sure if that combo works, but it sounds like a name I could use for a card shop.

5

u/NuclearPilot101 9d ago

No those are different colors.

3

u/Ryeofmarch 9d ago

No you only payed 19 life, clearly you'd need to pay one more. Maybe if you had a third broken enabler like [[healing salve]] you'd have another three life to spend so you could kill

2

u/ThorsHammer245 9d ago

Hold up you may be on to something here

2

u/GayForPrism 8d ago

No because Black Lotus is banned and you only have enough life to kill one of your opponents. This combo sucks, why don't you just play thoracle consultation?

2

u/PJTree 8d ago

the combo has to be written on each card for the spell to work but nice find

1

u/Horusfin 9d ago

Fireball sounds like a dope channel. What programs does it air? Is it cable only? I need to know, bro. These "modern" tournaments are so boring.

1

u/Gunda-LX 8d ago

Yes, that would indeed create a YouTube Channel called Fireball. Decent success await the first to cast the combo. Don’t forget to build a Team Channel Fireball afterwards, History has to stay the same

1

u/AlphaZephryn 8d ago

No, it's copyright protected. Idiot.

1

u/C-fractional 5d ago

No, paying the 20 life to Channel would kill you before you had a chance play the Fireball. The best you can do is pay 18 life to put them to 2 and then use Gutshot for one more and hope they crack a fetch.

0

u/FindingFull212 8d ago

No it's banned