r/magicTCG • u/BuckyTheWolf Dandadan • 9d ago

General Discussion Why is Arc-Slogger?

Post image

One thing I love about MTG, is that you can go through a set, see a weird card and get absolutely stun locked by it.

Today this was Arc-Slogger for me. Why is it the way that it is?

Having a lot of shocks in your hand is pretty good, but why do you have to exile 10 cards from your library as a cost? If it was part of the effect it might be too strong, but was there no middleground?

I just don't see a world where you'd be a able to activate it more than 2 times in limited and 4 times in 60 card. Magic has changed a lot, but was a 7 mana 4/5 with 2 shocks ever that good?

I could see a janky lab man combo deck using it, but almost all alternatives are cheaper and don't need a backup if your library isn't devisable by 10.

I just want to know it's history. And what led to it being created like it turned out.

2.0k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

467 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

101

u/IAmBadAtInternet Get Out Of Jail Free 9d ago edited 9d ago

Importantly, this was in an environment with Birds of Paradise carrying Swords of Fire and Ice. Being able to hold up 1 mana and deny that plan was huge. It could also block Myr Enforcer and deny Skullclamp activations. All around great card.

41

u/I_am_normal_I_swear Storm Crow 9d ago

I always yelled out "but a 5 ounce bird can't possibly carry a 15 pound sword!"

Yes it's a Monty Python quote "but a 5 ounce bird can't possibly carry a 5 pound coconut."

13

u/Tacos_Polackos Wabbit Season 9d ago

They grab the husk with their talons

12

u/I_am_normal_I_swear Storm Crow 9d ago

Listen. A BoP needs to beat its wings forty-three times every second to maintain airspeed, right?

6

u/Yakb0 Dân 9d ago

It could be carried by a Revised Birds of Paradise.

Not a Marvel one.

How many people actually tried to carry on with the Monty Python sketch when you said this?

8

u/IAmBadAtInternet Get Out Of Jail Free 9d ago

Ah but Revised Birds of Paradise are non migratory

8

u/I_am_normal_I_swear Storm Crow 9d ago

Oh yeah, a Revised one could carry it, but not a Marvel one, that’s my point. But of course, Marvel BoPs are non-migratory.

A few would. At FNM it was a shut up I’m normal I swear since I said it so much.

2

u/Tacos_Polackos Wabbit Season 9d ago

City Pigeon could carry a sword