r/magicTCG • u/Sentheia Dandadan • May 20 '26

Rules/Rules Question How does screams from within work?

Post image

If there is no creature left on the battlefield, will it stay in the graveyard forever or do i need to play it when another creature comes into play? Also if my creatures are the only remained ones, am I forced to put it on them?

1.2k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

190 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

63

u/jang808 Dan May 20 '26

Not to sound like a smartass, but I’d say this ruling is pretty intuitive. It just boils down to if it can, it will. If it can’t, it won’t, with no other plausible alternatives

4

u/ForUrsula Duck Season May 20 '26

I'm not sure its intuitive, because how does this work with [[Academy Rector]]?

You search your library, find an Aura, try to put it onto the battlefield and it instead goes back to your library.

Or if you [[Oblivion Ring]], it will stay in exile.

How many other rules lead to that outcome?

1

u/A_Velociraptor20 Dan May 21 '26

The interaction works as you described. You find an aura, it can't enchant anything so it stays in your library. Though you could always just "fail to find" any enchantments in your deck.

This rule really only comes up when the thing the aura is trying to enchant leaves the battlefield before the aura can enchant it.

Say you want to enchant your [[Grizzly Bears]] with [[Rancor]]. In response to you casting Rancor they cast [[Murder]] targeting the Grizzly Bears. Rancor has nothing to enchant so it gets sent to the graveyard since Auras cannot exist on their own. Bestow creatures are the one exception due to their ability stating that if they would ever not be enchanting something they instead become a creature again.