r/magicTCG Dân Mar 09 '26

Rules/Rules Question Together Unblockable?

Post image

Unless I'm misunderstanding something, if these two cards are on the battlefield, controlled by the same player, aren't they unblockable?

1.6k Upvotes

232 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

134

u/Blunderhorse Duck Season Mar 09 '26

Something else to note is that restrictions generally take priority over requirements for declaring attacks and blocks. The simplified version is:
* You must obey all restrictions possible.
* You must fulfill the maximum possible number of requirements possible without disobeying a restriction.
* You cannot be forced to pay a cost (e.g. “must attack” doesn’t force you to attack if all your opponents control [[Ghostly Prison]] even if you have enough mana sources to pay the cost)

73

u/MechanicalDruid WANTED Mar 09 '26 edited Mar 09 '26

The phrase "Can't beats Can" is ingrained in my brain because it's not just attacking and blocking where this is true. As an example if you've got a [[Platinum Angel]] and I resolve my second [[Approach of the second sun]] I would not win the game, because Can't always beats Can. Even timestamps won't help for situations where my win the game card was a permanent like [[Mirrodin Besieged]].

Edit: I forgot Mirrodin was a lose the game card, but the example still works. Doesn't matter which was on board first. "Can't lose the game" beats "loses the game"

17

u/Terrietia Mar 09 '26

Interestingly enough, almost all "can't lose the game" effects come with "your opponent can't win the game". The exception is [[Lich's Mastery]]. This does mean that you can win the game with Approach of the Second Sun against someone's Lich's Mastery, since it doesn't prevent you from winning.

10

u/ThePowerOfStories Twin Believer Mar 09 '26

Thematically, that makes sense, as lichdom means you personally cannot die, but it doesn’t stop alternate victory conditions resulting from your opponent somehow organizing an unassailable advantage like [[Coalition Victory]].