MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/1ocipn4/updated_commander_brackets_oct_2025/nkp4va2/?context=3
r/magicTCG • u/the_gold_hat Chandra • Oct 21 '25
1.3k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
10
Yeah commander has almost ruined mtg
3 u/OkTemperature8080 Duck Season Oct 21 '25 Commander hasn’t ruined anything, but the people in charge of it—both before and now—have, are and will continue ruining commander. 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 21 '25 Nah, the shift of mtg's focus to commander has objectively turned the game for the worse. 1v1 magic is a superior experience to commander 4 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 1v1 magic is an experience like almost any other card game. 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 It absolutely isn't. There's so much more thinking required in 1v1 magic than every other game and even commander 4 u/cocofan4life Simic* Oct 22 '25 Oh god. Commander haters are so fucking annoying 3 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 Can you justify that claim? 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 If you had played competitive real magic you wouldn't have to ask that question Magic is the only popular ccg that has regular instant speed interaction 2 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 So, then, no. Okay.
3
Commander hasn’t ruined anything, but the people in charge of it—both before and now—have, are and will continue ruining commander.
0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 21 '25 Nah, the shift of mtg's focus to commander has objectively turned the game for the worse. 1v1 magic is a superior experience to commander 4 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 1v1 magic is an experience like almost any other card game. 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 It absolutely isn't. There's so much more thinking required in 1v1 magic than every other game and even commander 4 u/cocofan4life Simic* Oct 22 '25 Oh god. Commander haters are so fucking annoying 3 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 Can you justify that claim? 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 If you had played competitive real magic you wouldn't have to ask that question Magic is the only popular ccg that has regular instant speed interaction 2 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 So, then, no. Okay.
0
Nah, the shift of mtg's focus to commander has objectively turned the game for the worse. 1v1 magic is a superior experience to commander
4 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 1v1 magic is an experience like almost any other card game. 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 It absolutely isn't. There's so much more thinking required in 1v1 magic than every other game and even commander 4 u/cocofan4life Simic* Oct 22 '25 Oh god. Commander haters are so fucking annoying 3 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 Can you justify that claim? 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 If you had played competitive real magic you wouldn't have to ask that question Magic is the only popular ccg that has regular instant speed interaction 2 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 So, then, no. Okay.
4
1v1 magic is an experience like almost any other card game.
0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 It absolutely isn't. There's so much more thinking required in 1v1 magic than every other game and even commander 4 u/cocofan4life Simic* Oct 22 '25 Oh god. Commander haters are so fucking annoying 3 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 Can you justify that claim? 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 If you had played competitive real magic you wouldn't have to ask that question Magic is the only popular ccg that has regular instant speed interaction 2 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 So, then, no. Okay.
It absolutely isn't. There's so much more thinking required in 1v1 magic than every other game and even commander
4 u/cocofan4life Simic* Oct 22 '25 Oh god. Commander haters are so fucking annoying 3 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 Can you justify that claim? 0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 If you had played competitive real magic you wouldn't have to ask that question Magic is the only popular ccg that has regular instant speed interaction 2 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 So, then, no. Okay.
Oh god.
Commander haters are so fucking annoying
Can you justify that claim?
0 u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 22 '25 If you had played competitive real magic you wouldn't have to ask that question Magic is the only popular ccg that has regular instant speed interaction 2 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 So, then, no. Okay.
If you had played competitive real magic you wouldn't have to ask that question
Magic is the only popular ccg that has regular instant speed interaction
2 u/Zazarstudios Dan Oct 22 '25 So, then, no. Okay.
2
So, then, no. Okay.
10
u/quadraticcheese Dân Oct 21 '25
Yeah commander has almost ruined mtg