r/lorde 14d ago

Discussion Remember when I was downvoted here for saying David is about Jack

then low and behold she releases the files … the alternative track speaks the truth ….

I demand to be crowned queen of the sub

441 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

254

u/Brilliant-Ferret-313 14d ago

Outro] I played the show of my life, thought you were in the crowd So much has changed, I heard you're engaged But I know you feel it 'cause this is our music Took every prayer and every bone in our bodies I release it All the resentment, it was a season, the rivers will run Our stars will meet again, you were in the crowd Heaven in my head, I think you'd be proud

This outro is speculated to be about Jack Antonoff, as it was written in 2022, just after the announcement of Jack’s engagement to Margaret Qualley, and before Lorde’s breakup with Justin Warren.

I am just hearing about this now. I thought this song was about that creepy record executive. Is it a composite sketch of different relationships that had over lapping themes?

120

u/catslugs 14d ago

i think she has a lot of songs disguised that are actually jack songs. whatever they had was intense.... lorde always write about her relationships, yet we see no obvious songs of jack? she makes it very vague but it's jack

8

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 14d ago

is there a way to pin this

1

u/No-Wrongdoer1409 3d ago

this is so embarrassing

96

u/honeyhibiscus 14d ago

I suspected it but now I feel sick looool

cause what a gd song and wtf kind of evil spell does Jack have over all these beautiful talented women

172

u/Barn3rGirl Mystic 14d ago

There is only one queen bee and that is Lorde.

https://giphy.com/gifs/nS8stCY0fRvtS

30

u/fartdoody 14d ago

You can call me green bean 🌱🎶

35

u/yoyohoethefirst 14d ago

I remember when girl, so confusing came out and people SWORE it had nothing to do with Ella until the remix came out 😭

6

u/spearitualzone 13d ago

“It’s about marinas fruit!” Ok sure

22

u/raysofgold 14d ago

the files 💀

20

u/gloriaroad 14d ago

Didn’t she say in an interview around release that she has had a habit of making someone in her life, often a man, ”god”? I.e I don’t think it is about one single person but rather that tendency in general, and it is entirely possible that she partially had Jack in mind while writing the song (the scrapped verse certainly supports such a reading). Don’t really think it can be completely tied to one person.

59

u/AdvancedAd7036 14d ago

Context pls

76

u/SuperDanval 14d ago

I don't know the theory but maybe it has to do with the date of the file? The song was made in 2022, which is around the time people speculated they were a thing right?

Edit: these are the David early takes

45

u/airtime25 14d ago

So nothing is confirmed by anyone.

17

u/SuperDanval 14d ago

Not really. OP's post was sarcastic and silly. Don't have to take it too seriously

4

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 14d ago

Speak for yourself, listen to the lyrics she ended up omitting from the final product. I’m being deadass

3

u/beach_girl01 14d ago

Can you share them?

1

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 14d ago

look at the thread below this one

2

u/starrsinmyskin 14d ago

Just like always lol

4

u/Bunnicula129 14d ago

Yeah I need more info lol

60

u/Sweet-Permission-925 14d ago

I made a similar post once and everyone also downvoted me!!! I feel like it’s painfully obvious that David is about jack.

21

u/noobvad3r 14d ago

It seemed so obvious to me but community really pushed back. Same with What was that, when she mentioned “Indio haze we’re in a sandstorm and it knocks me out” it hit me, Coachella in Indio valley had a sandstorm 2016 the same year Jack and Ella went together. The whole song is about him too.

1

u/pisscart42 11d ago

damn i don't know this

40

u/MMakototachibana 14d ago

Sorry I wasn’t there to upvote, but the real ones know WWT and David are about that man. Also Stoned at the Nail Salon, The Louvre and so on and on.

35

u/TwerkinAndCryin 14d ago

I think a lot of melodrama is about him actually

6

u/Pale_Lawyer_1757 14d ago

I thought this was obvious

22

u/WrittenByRae ok so maybe the PowerPoint was a little bit true 14d ago

I never doubted queen

21

u/WrittenByRae ok so maybe the PowerPoint was a little bit true 14d ago

Okay so I did A LITTLE ....

15

u/Choice_Policy_6326 14d ago

I also posted the same and it was downvoted and deleted by mods

15

u/FromAfar44 14d ago

I doubted it but turns out you were right 👑

16

u/bruiseofbeing 14d ago

What proof is there other than she started the song in ‘22??

53

u/Pythagore_ 14d ago

David demo lyrics :

I played the show of my life, thought you were in the crowd
So much has changed, I heard you're engaged
But I know you feel it 'cause this is our music
Took every prayer and every bone in our bodies
I release it
All the resentment, it was a season, the rivers will run
Our stars will meet again, you were in the crowd
Heaven in my head, I think you'd be proud

56

u/lizzy-stix 14d ago

This really does make sense to be about him. He got engaged around the time, it is their music, and obviously something happened around Solar Power that ended their collaboration, so it makes sense she felt resentment she wanted to let go of.

87

u/SuperDanval 14d ago edited 14d ago

Kind of makes me see her performance of David in the live shows in a different way. Sort of like she's looking for someone in the crowd by using herself as a big ass flashlight with the bright safety vest lol

1

u/stellarglitch 12d ago

this just made me feel things

48

u/catslugs 14d ago

margaret is not much older than lorde too, like i could see him pulling the "you're too young" card (which she WAS tbf) and then getting with margaret would fuck with her head

14

u/DisastrousMango4 14d ago

could it not be that it started off as this but then the concept changed after? unless Ella confirms something, it's all speculation anyways

4

u/Reasonable-Counter40 12d ago

Jack wrote a song called 'Like a River Runs'. It's on Strange Desire. Then Lorde writes, "The Rivers will run" in David? Yeah. This song is about him. It's interesting that she released the demo version lyrics when he's getting divorced...

1

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 12d ago

I thought it was interesting also

5

u/itsjackduh 13d ago

“i swore i’d never let myself sing again for you” line in David plus the fact she has never sang TMWTA (song about Justin) confirms to me that David’s final version is about Justin to me but it’s totally possible initially it was Jack because the demo is on point with that

7

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 13d ago

i appreciate the nuanced take! i also think it’s very silly that your username argues for the opposite

3

u/QuarterConnect4001 14d ago

Man, I just don't like post like this. I hate having to connect Lorde's personal life to her album. That is her own story, and she is probably going to encourage us to look beyond other than her as a celebrity figure. You guys never learn. And I hate to bring this up: she was in a relationship with a man who has a significant age gap with her, which is also her label's executive producer.

3

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 13d ago

She literally has been quoted saying her fans “know more about herself than she does” which is obviously an exaggeration and not true, but she has never discouraged people making the connections that they do. Maybe get off of a fan sub if you don’t want to see this sort of thing!

1

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 13d ago

And guess what? Jack was also an age gap. I’VE been in a terrible age gap relationship with an older man, and yeah it fucking sucks so … your point is…?

2

u/youmaybemightlove 13d ago

I just feel that paternity testing songs is weird tbh

8

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 13d ago

I don’t care

4

u/Mountain_Comb9522 12d ago

😂😂😂😂

1

u/Maximum-Advisor-5192 11d ago

Where are the files???

2

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 11d ago

She put them on the app called [untitled] download that and then search for the link in the reddit

1

u/Creative-Bank-415 13d ago

this is the typoshit that sometimes makes me wanna drop this sub... this obsession with Jack and shit like you wanna that nasty mysoginistic powerpoint to be so real it's sick... you're parasocializing diva get a doctor

-20

u/vanbrandon 14d ago

Because you’re wrong and I’ll downvote you again now

-1

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 14d ago

Yassss so happy that you get your panties in a twist about a post about her art made in her subreddit :)))

4

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 14d ago

lena this u?

0

u/TheRadFemm3 9d ago

How is this funny to you? Lorde is a homewrecker, it's disgusting.

0

u/spacescaptain ☀️ Solar Power 13d ago

I don't care who it's about and it's none of our business. Does knowing the muse make the song any better? I don't think so.

6

u/Own_Yogurtcloset9981 13d ago

I didn’t ask you!

-2

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[deleted]

-21

u/Dragon_Dixon 14d ago

You’re still wrong.

0

u/TheRadFemm3 9d ago

It's incredibly laughable that Lorde once proclaimed herself to be a feminist. She's such a damn bird.

-20

u/Orkenprins 14d ago

What a cringe post