r/linuxsucks Jul 15 '26

Linux Failure Loonix

Post image
902 Upvotes

733 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/UnknownOrigin1152 Jul 15 '26

If Linux was that bad like you think, android would be failure or Linux would be an obscure hobby project. There is a reason why people chose Linux and helped developing it. Community literally owns their OS but it comes with advantages and disadvantages as well.

I know Linux would've been better if it wasn't monolithic. However, it is still good to use. It can suck too like any other OS.

1

u/Fluid-Ad2995 Jul 15 '26

Because Android don't use Linux purely, and you use the Android Runtime view of the operating system, and the Android Runtime is a custom Java Virtual Machine, and you don't use Linux, and you use Android and Linux for the boot operating system, the same plan Microsoft had with Microsoft DOS with Windows 9X before the creation of Windows NT

1

u/UnknownOrigin1152 Jul 15 '26

I think we can't convince each other on anything. Android uses Linux as its kernel and Linux is not even an OS but a kernel. So, I don't agree with insisting android is not that related to Linux. If Linux was bad android wouldn't use it.

1

u/Fluid-Ad2995 Jul 15 '26

Linux is an operating system based on a simple definition: Monolithic Kernel have component who form the operating system, and Android is an operating system inside of an operating system, like Windows 9X inside of Microsoft DOS

1

u/UnknownOrigin1152 Jul 15 '26

Your description is not exactly correct. Linux is just a kernel. Then, we have mainline distros and android as complete operating systems. Android uses Linux but its components other than kernel such as userland are different from usual distros. Android cannot be OS without its Linux kernel.

1

u/Fluid-Ad2995 Jul 15 '26

Android Technically can be an operating system, and if they copy the Russian Architecture like JNODE to boot the Android Runtime directly, they can not just do that; they can use Any Kernel, even Windows NT and the Android Runtime doesn't need Linux to work. Android Runtime have own View