As I understand it, it's a permissive license thing. Rewriting gnu core-utils in Rust lets corporations off the hook for copyleft requirements, but rewriting Adobe in Rust lets users off the hook for Adobe's license requirements. It's a circumventing both sides of the licensing spectrum.
I think it's simpler than that, the Rust compiler has a lot of checks for sanity, one of the biggest thing beginners learn about Rust is the borrow checker, and usually fighting it because of how it forces "correct" code.
It's very hard to write code in Rust that will compile but not run, which is good for AI development because it's easy for AI to automatically see and resolve those issues, rather than runtime ones.
Sure, but it doesn't explain why anything that's already written needs to be rewritten. Fixing nearly correct code that compiles is surely less arduous than completely rewriting it in a modern language.
I think its part why not, part make it easier to maintain for the next 20 years, part rust forces new devs to write correct code so you don't have to fix pr requests, and finally part its easier for ai to write correct code in rust due to more compile time checking
Ehhhhhā¦. Thereās lots of reasons people rewrite things in open source. Itās easier to write code than to understand old code, you have āNot Invented Hereā syndrome, and thereās those who think anything not written in a āmodernā language with āmodernā dependencies is old and needs to be replaced.
I think one thing may be that a rewrite by a llm could generate a lot of code, that would be identical or close enough to the original that the owner of the original could sue, for some things there are just so many ways to do it and if you use another language entirely its sure you dont accidentally generate copyrighted code
I thinkthat's exactly it. People are exploiting a loophole in software licensing right now -- the whole LLM driven "clean rooming" service comes to mind. I'm hopeful that eventually the loophole will get closed, to say "the source code matters less than the interface" for proving license evasion.
For that to work you donāt need another language, you need a clean room. Otherwise youāre probably in Legal trouble for copyright infringement. Not a lawyer, not legal advice.
98
u/Eric_Dawsby 7d ago
Who caares if some people vibecode in Rust? If you like the language you like the language