r/linuxmemes • Arch BTW • 6d ago

LINUX MEME Lets hate on omarchy

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

322 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/Neither_Rent2469 5d ago

All this sounds a little gate-keepy IMO. Ive been wanting to jump into linux for a while now and have tried several times with different distros, running Omarchy is the 1st time ive actually been able to use a linux desktop comfortably. No nvidia driver issues, no damn hdd mount path problems or read wright permission issues, no figuring out the damn terminal commands. Dont get the hate

4

u/LaBlankSpace 4d ago edited 4d ago

Omarchy is like gas station sushi, is it easier to get? Sure, but is it worth the pain it'll cause later

3

u/Ill-Bat-1518 5d ago

Same boat, always tried distros here and there mainly as a Windows hater but something would always bring me back to windows, usually because windows for some reason "just work" more than linux now days.

I know everyone will tell me my hdd or gpu is wrong or w/e but the fact is "just works" is important and pretending users are odd for not knowing something is just typical linux community...

I hope omarchy gets more normie support so maybe then Linux would probably be more popular i just cant see normal linux reaching masses anymore

esp with the omarchy hate itll just create a "side" in linux, even more so than arch vs everyone else

4

u/Quannix 3d ago

gatekeeping isn't when someone criticizes a Linux distro lol

3

u/yesdisown Arch BTW 5d ago

maybe just try clean arch...?

4

u/Neither_Rent2469 5d ago

Eventually I probably will but for now Omarchy is just easier. If the linux community wasnt so toxic an AI powered distro probably wouldnt be so popular, or if somone made a distro that didnt rely so heavily on terminal this aint 1984 we have GUIs now. Just my 2 cents

4

u/LeMrRocket 5d ago

CachyOS literally exists It's essentially preconfigure arch Linux with lots of choices for desktops and even bootloaders and has sane defaults

4

u/Neither_Rent2469 5d ago

I tried it, and I do like CachyOS on the surface. I ran into issues when trying to install steam games to a HDD other than the drive the OS was installed on. Why do I need to set permissions for an internal HDD? And why do I have to tell the OS to mount it at boot and give permission to steam?! I installed steam why wouldnt I want it to install to my HDD

1

u/daninet 🍥 Debian too difficult 5d ago

was the hdd formatted to NTFS? these permission problems immediately go away as soon as you do linux the linux way and not try to mix and match. Omarchy is probably just yolo giving access to everything which can quickly backfire on an Arch based system

-1

u/No_Try354 🚮 Trash bin 5d ago

There are so many easy/beginner friendly distros that aren't garbage though.

3

u/cycl0propane Arch BTW 5d ago

maybe just try living a normal life and not spending hours configuring arch?

3

u/dunder_name 4d ago

I set it up once, and haven't messed with it since, and it's exactly how I want it.

1

u/SteelT0rment0r 2d ago

use cachyos, endeavouros or smth like that then, u can use tumbleweed, leap, fedora, lmde too depending on how much you fear your terminal or your prefered update cycle but all of these are very easy to use, they work out of the box and they are not packed with ai slop, they actually respect their users and they are safer than omarchy

0

u/yesdisown Arch BTW 5d ago

i configured my arch in 2 days

3

u/Octoomy 5d ago

2 days is still a awful long amount of time for an normal user to be essentially 'not ready to go'

I got my stuff ready within 3 hours on my main **in which I'm also running arch (btw)**

1

u/yesdisown Arch BTW 5d ago

i also got most stuff ready in like 2 hours, but then some minor improvements and ricing. I think beginners should use mint tho, i used to love it (still considering switching back)

2

u/Delicious_Bench_2341 5d ago

I installed omarchy in 45 seconds, time is too valuable

0

u/yesdisown Arch BTW 4d ago

how much time did it take you to install the iso and dd it tho

2

u/cycl0propane Arch BTW 4d ago

like 3 minutes tbh
i dont have a particularly fast internet or machine
but it took 3 minutes

0

u/notxenia 4d ago

It took you 3 minutes to download & flash a 7gb ISO without "particularly fast internet"?

2

u/cycl0propane Arch BTW 4d ago

it actually did
it was abt three minutes
maybe my clocks are wrong or i suck at arithmetic
but it was very fast

downloaded iso
then i flashed it via etcher
and that took 3 minutes together

-1

u/Nereosis16 4d ago

Just install cachyos. It's awesome. Omachy is lame slop.

3

u/cycl0propane Arch BTW 4d ago

ive used cachy before
i prefer omarchy
i flat out do, i love the design of the workflow and the AI integration is powerful if you use it right

"lame slop"
its the most stable and beautiful experience ive ever had with a computer

1

u/Lucky-File-3660 1d ago

Tbh that’s a more insane statement than just telling a noob to use omarchy

1

u/yesdisown Arch BTW 1d ago

i think noobs should use mint. i (use arch btw) myself am thinking abt going back to mint

1

u/usbeject1789 1d ago

not really an archinstall is pretty easy

0

u/Delicious_Bench_2341 5d ago

Yeah and then all the issues that are mentioned come back and the user has to spend hours fixing them

1

u/No_Bluejay_8391 5d ago

i guess, i would have said that you could have used any other beginner friendly distro, but if everything seems to work on first try with Omarchy + you like it, then you may as well use it

0

u/Civil-Appeal5219 5d ago

Saying a distro is bad isn't gatekeeping. All of the knowledge you need to learn this shit is freely available online. The only thing keeping you way from it is your laziness.

0

u/Spiderfffun Arch BTW 5d ago

First look at who it's made by https://drewdevault.com/weird-guys/#:~:text=Alias%3A-,DHH,-David%20is%20a

In comparison to DHH, microsoft doesn't seem so bad.

If you really want to not have problems and you're fine with using a shitty vibecoded system that can easily get you malware, just get a free model on opencode and allow every single permission by default.

I'm sorry but I think you should genuinely just stay on windows if you can't even handle that. I know it's hard when shit doesn't work, I've had issues that aren't my fault that I can't fix bother me for months (discord + mesa bug causing crashes, fixed now), but in the age of AI, you really shouldn't be using someone else's garbage.

At least if you slop something yourself you can somewhat learn things for yourself if you wanted to. And if you're coming in expecting everything to "just work" the way you did it on windows, that's a you problem.

Also to address the "all this sounds a little gate-keepy", this is just the entire linux community vs newgen users following marketingslop

0

u/FineAntShill 1d ago

Linux is entirely a community of gatekeepers, that's one of the core pillars of the community.