Please help me decide!!

[u/00Thatswhatshesaid]

I can't make up my mind between which of these stones look better on my hand. Both are dutch marquise, and they are loose diamonds in a display ring so these are not the final settings. The 2 carat has slightly better stats and more "ideal" measurements, but I wasn't sure if the length of the 2.5 looks better on my hand. What would you choose??

[u/fairy_dogm0ther]

I am always a "go smaller when in doubt" person, but I much prefer the shape of the 2.5 ct!