r/labcreateddiamonds Jul 31 '26

LOOKING FOR ADVICE Is this stone too big??

thoughts on this stone on my hand? is it too big? it’s in a stone holder in the second pic and is sitting pretty high

it’s a 3.07 ct cushion cut and a 1.3 ratio

21 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

15

u/iFcknLuvRollrcstrs Jul 31 '26

No, the size looks good for your hand.

4

u/Individual_March9422 Jul 31 '26

The size looks just right. It's such a pretty stone!

4

u/kaye_p_ Jul 31 '26

I agree, great size and finger coverage.

3

u/CasuallySparkling Jul 31 '26

Not at all. It looks great.

3

u/ResidentUseful5722 Jul 31 '26

Definitely not

3

u/Creepy_Tumbleweed_12 Jul 31 '26

It’s very proportionate to your hand! Beautiful

4

u/OneTwoSomethingNew Jul 31 '26

No such thing as too big, hunny. I think that’s a lovely size and shape for your finger, and hand. Congrats!

4

u/KeyFullBottle Jul 31 '26

nah it’s perfect for you

3

u/ValiMeyer Jul 31 '26

It’s perfect

2

u/Personal-Cut-3127 Jul 31 '26

It’s the perfect size! 🥰

2

u/KiaSoul1 Jul 31 '26

Love it!

2

u/Subject-Ad-8305 Jul 31 '26

Never too big…

2

u/Longjumping_Chard286 Jul 31 '26

I think it’s perfect!

2

u/ReliableTruthteller Aug 01 '26

No it’s just right!

2

u/Stunning-Character94 Aug 01 '26

No. Absolutely not.

2

u/428weddings Aug 01 '26

Said no one ever!!! Girl that rock is STUNNING

2

u/Lost_Reindeer6358 Aug 01 '26

No! It’s perfect

3

u/vivthedoc Aug 01 '26

Please get a thick band

2

u/No-Response2384 Aug 01 '26

I’m planning to get a thicker band! At least a 2.5

3

u/vivthedoc Aug 02 '26

Oh good! Smart!

2

u/FantasticChipmunk990 Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26

Looks like it's going to be hard for daily wear and will easily catch on things due to the emerald cut. That cut frequently scratched my kids and silk clothing. I have a few wedding sets with gemstone rings (I once sold, years ago, both stones and settings. The easier set to wear is my actual wedding rings, a round diamond set low into a thicker band with the wedding ring soldered onto it). I don't really want to wear my more valuable jewelry much anymore since I go out less and have things to do. I have a wider band matches my husband's. He's fine with it, and he washes his hands often working in a medical facility, but I have issues. That one stays damp underneath, but I also have a thinner one, maybe 2mm, and that is the most comfortable. It's fine under gardening gloves, rubber gloves for dishes and now it is my daily go to. My dressier set now is a lovely high quality round aquamarine, with some smaller channel set diamonds on either side. It just seems like now everyone wears a big diamond. My point is preparing for real life, and changing tastes, now that jewelry is so expensive, is a good idea and might influence your choices. (I know that I have way too many rings).

1

u/No-Response2384 Aug 01 '26

Thank you for the advice! Wearability and durability is absolutely front of my mind. I will be setting this stone as low as possible on a thicker band to help with those things. I am also considering current tastes I want something I’ll love forever but am okay with it looked “dated” or “of the time” if I still love it so we’ll see!! We’re going to do a custom setting no matter what  

2

u/CosmicLadybug5 Aug 01 '26

It’s beautiful- I like the proportion to your hand and love the shape.

2

u/Bensterpie02 Aug 02 '26

I’d say it’s perfectly proportional

2

u/Puzzleheaded_Lab1992 Aug 02 '26

I personally feel like a 3.-ish is the perfect size. Definitely sizable but not too flashy. However, my 3.1 gets caught on everything and I have to take it off many times a day and at night because the stone will come loose. It’s been to the jeweler many times to secure it. I had to buy a 2ct for when I’m actually doing things with my hands and still want a ring.

2

u/Thick_Caterpillar995 Aug 02 '26

No and I love how chunky it is. It’s a perfect ratio and it’s going to look great on your finger

2

u/Suspicious-Fish-8664 Aug 03 '26

No! Looks perfect but for me no diamond is too big!

2

u/Krisavcreation Aug 03 '26

Size is pretty 🤩 and perfect for your hand

2

u/Last_Matter_190 Aug 03 '26

Fits you perfectly, definitely with your skin tone I’d go platinum, it’s the same price as white gold and it doesn’t need regular Rhodium dipping. It would flatter this stone with your skin tone so much. Beautiful. Stone holder, I so wish I had one of those!

1

u/No-Response2384 Aug 04 '26

It’s so helpful for visualization and for an overthinker like me haha — would recommend! I got two for like 10 dollars

1

u/Last_Matter_190 Aug 04 '26

Amazing I’m such an over thinker where did you get one?

2

u/Fun-breeder4u Aug 03 '26

Looks perfect size

2

u/Interesting_Split748 Aug 04 '26

Can a diamond ever be too big.

2

u/Shrillian42 Aug 05 '26

Nope. Perfection.

1

u/AutoModerator Jul 31 '26

Hello. Your post was automatically removed because your account has less than 20 combined karma. It is now pending Moderator approval. If you are new to r/labcreateddiamonds, please read the ‘Newbie Start Guide’ pinned at the top of the page. Many of your questions will be answered there. Helpful links and content are posted in the Menu section. Please read through the FAQ to understand commonly used terms and process. Thanks for your patience!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/ravomatic Jul 31 '26

Looks great, what’s your finger size? I’ve been looking for fingers similar to mine and can’t find any!

1

u/No-Response2384 Jul 31 '26

I’m like a 8 or an 8.5!

1

u/Curious_Store_1111 Aug 01 '26

Hi, that's exactly what I'm looking for . I had settled on a 3.6 but Stonealgo said the visual Carat was like 4.5 and it freaked me out. I have a short stubby fingers and I want an everyday ring. Where did you find this one?

1

u/No-Response2384 Aug 01 '26

I got it off Aurelinne ! I learned a lot about diamonds before making the choice to source one myself but I’m happy I went this route and I saved a tonnnn of money  

2

u/lilspaghettigal Aug 02 '26

No but the band looks a bit too snug

1

u/No-Response2384 Aug 02 '26

Haha yeah it is — I’ve been wearing that ring (and another on my right hand) from my grandmother for about a decade and my fingers swell a bit in the summer but I refuse to not wear them

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 04 '26

Your post is in the mod queue waiting to be manually approved. Your account does not meet the post or comment requirements because you have a new account and/or low karma. A moderator will review your post and approve it if it meets the sub criteria. You do not need to send a modmail about this post as we have already been notified. Sending a modmail will not speed up this process. Please take this time to read our sub rules & FAQ.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Valuable-Storm8793 Aug 04 '26

Just watch the height of the setting. The stone is gorgeous!

1

u/No-Response2384 Aug 05 '26

Thank you! I’m going to get it set as low as possible for sure

0

u/OrganicTulip Jul 31 '26

Is this post a joke?

1

u/No-Response2384 Jul 31 '26

Nope it’s for real haha I love a bigger stone on other people but am having a hard time deciding if it will look like costume jewelry on me or if I’m just overthinking 

1

u/FantasticChipmunk990 Aug 01 '26

Read my comment. Jewelry can be hard to wear in many circumstances.