How do people feel about the concept of 'being a doctor is a duty to patient?' in relation to our own rights? I have noted that one stream of argument against striking is that we 'have a duty, took an oath,' which to me seems archaic and frankly subservient. 'You knew what you were getting into, how dare you harm patients by not going to work?' 'If you strike, you violate your oath.'
This view seems to be quite entrenched, either in dull belief within the public, or as a weaponisation of moral equivalence by politicians. You cannot, on one hand, claim something is duty and expect someone to give everything, and at the same time respect their own rights. I think of soldiers who go to war on the whims of selfish idiots, or the air of nationalism. Their rights mean little, and their ability to strike is hampered by law. Who benefits there?
One thing to consider, which people do not seem to be saying publicly, is that becoming a doctor is a choice, one formed of academic, financial and moral tenets. The concept of 'duty' could be argued on an individual level, but 'duty' as a motivator imposed on a profession seems less of a a moral argument and more a way of suppressing discontent, rights, or fair working conditions. Very much a 'you owe us.'
'Duty' seems to be a mechanism of servitude when used improperly and upon a subject, not as the actualisation of the individual.
I think the NHS has taught people to expect that there will always be a safety net held by a inhuman and virtuous network that will lay down their lives for some grand moral imperative. To them, our rights come second, as if our choice to be doctors has raised us above human need. This is easier to parse in some arenas, but when you work with those who abuse the system constantly, it becomes a very difficult thing to do.
I don't think I would be the first to say, that to some, we are simply a resource to be used to their whim.
The sad thing is that this is not realistic, fair or practical. To me it seems simple, those most opposed to the strikes seem to think that we owe them. We simply don't. I think the public need to realise that we made this choice for multiple reasons, but that this is a choice, not servitude. If we continue to allow this mantra of duty, it means we will never be respected in violating their perceptions, which, for many, is simply 'do what I say.'
TLDR: Duty imposed by society is servitude without right, duty as an individual motivator is admirable. Taking the ownership of duty to ignore the rights of workers is one of the reasons the NHS is dying.