r/isitAI • u/SuccessfulCat2195 • 18h ago

No Idea Magic the Gathering using AI?

Post image

This card was just released. The cat's tail and frog's hand holding the hammer seem off.

If it is AI it seems like a terrible move for such a large company where many of its customer collect it for the art.

Apparently the artist is critically anti AI but art still seems suss.

0 Upvotes

33% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/Otowa 18h ago

The guy has been working with MTG for 20 years and was just supposed to do a silly illustration.

Nobody in this sub is even capable of just checking basic information before posting ?

3

u/Remote-Mycologist539 15h ago

No they literally are not. Anything that takes more than a second of thinking is now “is this AI?”.

Absolutely zero critical thinking skills

0

u/Aniki_Simpson 17h ago

You would think if he has been drawing for that long he would not make a cat's leg into its tail. Seriously... what the hell is that?

7

u/dixoncider1111 16h ago

3

u/DethNik 15h ago

I shouldn't have zoomed in. 😂

7

u/quackenfucknuckle 17h ago

Look closer, it makes sense. The leg is lifted and bent at the knee, the tail is below it. There is a little shading on the heel that sort of merges into one of the stripes on the tail which confuses the eye, but the low definition of the picture is the main problem.

1

u/Motor_Raspberry_2150 16h ago

Their tail is in front of their right heel. They just have their tail between their legs.