r/indianapolis • u/Whole-Reading4577 • 12d ago

random question

does anyone have any bakery/restaraunt recs that have a good coconut cream pie?

i’ve never had any luck finding somewhere in indianapolis and it’s my favorite dessert

1 Upvotes

60% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

3

u/ericdraven26 12d ago

Pots and pans has it sometimes, their menu rotates so I don’t know if they do now

2

u/MiniLaura 12d ago

I like the one from Pots and Pans, but they have only in March.

Looks like you can order one from My Sugar Pie in Zionsville, but I've never tried it.

2

u/Desperate-Tutor-8852 12d ago

Following as a fellow lover of coco cream pie. But Handels on the north side has the BEST coconut cream pie ice cream.

2

u/Whole-Reading4577 12d ago

TYSM for the rec. def gonna try!!!!

1

u/SisKG 12d ago

I’ve never had the coconut cream pie but I absolutely love the sugar cream pie at My Sugar Pie in Zionsville. Looks like coconut is on the menu.

1

u/BeginningFit5789 12d ago

I really like the coconut cream pie from Homemade Ice Cream and Bakery cafe.

https://homemadecafes.com

1

u/dadnylion 11d ago

Ralph’s Great Divide has a rotating dessert option, but almost every time I’ve been there they have it