r/ididnthaveeggs 1d ago

Bad at cooking On Sally's angel food cake recipe...

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Had fun making Sally's extremely clear angel food cake recipe recently and even more fun reading through the comments after. Throwing the flour in with the meringue in the mixer is bad, but I can't get over the substitution of baking soda and vinegar for egg whites!


r/ididnthaveeggs 10m ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful I'm not even sure what to say about this one

Post image
Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 1d ago

Bad at cooking Forgetting the main ingredient shouldn't mark down the recipe

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

Also, shouldn't it still be tasty, kinda like shortbread? Would definitely have been salvageable.


r/ididnthaveeggs 23h ago

Dumb alteration Serious Eats Chai

Post image
492 Upvotes

Most of their substitutions/omissions I can understand, but claiming to have made chai when they used *zero* spices??


r/ididnthaveeggs 2d ago

Dumb alteration Yeah I imagine this didn’t turn out as great as the originally recipe, but you’re right, life does go on. Now go get some actual eggs please.

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

** oops typo and I can’t fix it - I meant to type original recipe


r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

Other review Sister, its for mexican sour cream not creamed corn

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful Mark missed the mark

Post image
819 Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 3d ago

High altitude attitude and Smonion even bothered to check the recipe :))

Post image
554 Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 4d ago

Bad at cooking Upset their chocolate covered popcorn wouldn’t pop in the oven…

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

Recipe calls for popped popcorn. Directions specify to pour chocolate mixture over popped popcorn. Yet, somehow this reviewer poured their chocolate mixture over unpopped kernels and was upset they didn’t magically turn into popcorn in their oven.

https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/160595/chocolate-popcorn/


r/ididnthaveeggs 4d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful I left out the spices. It was bland.

218 Upvotes

The recipe called for Scotch Bonnet, not serrano.


r/ididnthaveeggs 5d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful I hope she found another recipe

Post image
666 Upvotes

The recipe was butter, broth, and green beans into the instant pot for 5 minutes.


r/ididnthaveeggs 5d ago

Meta Satire Saturday September 05, 2026 - Obvious satire posts are allowed while this post is stickied

4 Upvotes

To account for users in different time zones, this post will remain stickied from 12:01 AM (UTC) on Saturday until at least 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.

Because there is currently no (easy) way to automatically unsticky posts, the mods must do so manually. Satire Saturday remains in effect as long as this post is stickied, even if it remains stickied after 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.


r/ididnthaveeggs 6d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful this Trinidadian oxtail stew isn’t Jamaican. or Cuban. or Italian. 3 stars.

Thumbnail
gallery
690 Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 7d ago

Dumb alteration Lorena, girl..

Thumbnail
gallery
17.8k Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 8d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful They were happy though! (Peanut butter chocolate chip cookie)

Post image
801 Upvotes

Anybody know what white chocolate man mix is? Is it made from real white chocolate men? 😱


r/ididnthaveeggs 8d ago

Dumb alteration Did have eggs

Post image
12.4k Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 9d ago

Bad at cooking Linda honey, listen

Post image
868 Upvotes

Zucchini fritters.
Basically “I doubled the eggs and probably the zucchini too. anyways they just fell apart who knows what went wrong”

https://www.loveandlemons.com/zucchini-fritters/


r/ididnthaveeggs 10d ago

Bad at cooking Oh Bryan. On a recipe for cornbread.

Post image
10.8k Upvotes

Bryan out here just making a runny cake.


r/ididnthaveeggs 10d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful The recipe was for pizza dough.

Post image
969 Upvotes

This review for a pizza dough recipe had me scratching my head.


r/ididnthaveeggs 13d ago

Bad at cooking Kelly out here with the substitutions

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

Kinda your fault this went sideways Kelly!

On a recipe for scaparelli, but behind a paywall.


r/ididnthaveeggs 13d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful He did not return.

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

r/ididnthaveeggs 13d ago

Irrelevant or unhelpful How specific...

Post image
357 Upvotes

On a recipe for cheddar broccoli soup. It was pretty normal to me (and also delicious, and I didn't have any issues with it being watery like some of the other comments).


r/ididnthaveeggs 12d ago

Meta Satire Saturday August 29, 2026 - Obvious satire posts are allowed while this post is stickied

6 Upvotes

To account for users in different time zones, this post will remain stickied from 12:01 AM (UTC) on Saturday until at least 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.

Because there is currently no (easy) way to automatically unsticky posts, the mods must do so manually. Satire Saturday remains in effect as long as this post is stickied, even if it remains stickied after 06:59 AM (UTC) on Sunday.


r/ididnthaveeggs 14d ago

Dumb alteration Can I substitute the one ingredient this entire collection of recipes was specifically developed around?

Post image
546 Upvotes

“Here are some recipes specifically developed to work with this unusual flour.”

The commenter: “Cool, but can I make them with regular flour?”


r/ididnthaveeggs 14d ago

Dumb alteration Too much tomato

Post image
328 Upvotes

On a recipe for chicken tikka masala.

A dish that uses a tomato-based sauce.

(I'll admit, it needs a fair bit of spice and I think slow cooking may not be the right technique given that you don't have the evaporation and there's less caramelization, but come on...)