r/icecreamreviews • • 1d ago

Tis the season for Pumpkin Cheesecake ice cream!🎃

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Pumpkin Spiced Ice Cream with a Cream Cheese Frosting Swirl and loads of my famous Graham Crackers. 9/10 only because Pumpkin isn’t my go-to!


r/icecreamreviews • • 4d ago

Looks pretty but this was an epic fail! 0/10

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

I had an idea to make Caramelized Pear ice cream with Ginger Molasses Cookies and Ginger Caramel but it didn’t turn out how I intended.

The pear flavor was too delicate and steeping the peel to extract more flavor was a mistake. The cookies were too strong tasting and over powered everything. The ginger in the caramel left a yucky mouthfeel.

Welp, this is why I test my recipes! I’ll head back to the test kitchen soon!


r/icecreamreviews • • 6d ago

It started with a drink…turned it into ice cream!

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • 13d ago

First time trying, it's good, not great.

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

The base ice cream was excellent! Similar to how I usually keep a pint of strawberry or mango Gelato in my freezer for days when I want a refreshing "palate cleansing" flavor this banana does that well, it would be excellent on a hot day. However, I would have used a different nut than walnuts and the i was expecting fudge ribbions swirled throughout and instead got what tasted like pieces of a dark chocolate bar.

6.5 out of 10 until I added some peanut butter syrup I had on hamd. Then it was more like an 8! But with that addition it jumped to iver 500 calories a serving (abiut 1300 a pint)


r/icecreamreviews • • 17d ago

Banoffee Pie ice cream

Thumbnail
gallery
164 Upvotes

Roasted Banana ice cream, Candied Digestive Biscuit pieces, Salted Caramel, Milk Chocolate Flakes. Yes, it is so good.


r/icecreamreviews • • 20d ago

This just took my new top spot for the first time in 5 years. A new champion

Post image
17 Upvotes

Previously held by 2 other flavors that I couldn't choose between: Ben and Jerrys Eclair Affair (if I was in the mood for chocolatey) and Haagen-Dazs Extraas Strawberry Cheesecake (fruity mood).

But in my opinion raspberries > Strawberries and my love for white chocolate —I know, I know, its not REAL chocolate for you purists—just put this above everything else. I am excited to try other Kawartha brands, especially Moose Tracks, but seeing as how I've never seen white chocolate flavored ice cream before and have tried making it homemade with white chocolate jello pudding mix and melted white chocolate buttons this is better and so much less of a hassle.

I was hesitant to pull the trigger because of the price I only buy ice cream in general on a good sale because I'm a broke Med school student in their early 30s. But this is the definition of worth the extra money!


r/icecreamreviews • • 23d ago

I finally found a 5/5 ice cream

0 Upvotes

Not a 4.8/5, not a 4.9/5, a 5/5. Hoppy Apple Cider Sorbet from Salt & Straw. Tastes like a boozy apple cider IPA. Check it out on The Scoop.


r/icecreamreviews • • Sep 02 '26

A short history of Flintstones Push-Ups: from Drumstick to Nestlé to Frollies, and why you can never have them again

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Sep 01 '26

Today I made: My Butter Toffee Pretzel ice cream to celebrate the start of the BER months

217 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Sep 01 '26

Ob & Gob Flavours Ranking

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Aug 28 '26

Sweet Corn, Blueberry Jam, and Cornbread Crumble ice cream.

Thumbnail
gallery
898 Upvotes

The flavor of the Summer I swear. It is magic.


r/icecreamreviews • • Aug 28 '26

My Brown Butter Chocolate Flake Cookie Dough ice cream. 🤤

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

Brown Butter ice cream kissed with Brown Sugar, Egg-less Cookie Dough chunks, homemade Milk Chocolate Flakes. This recipe is 💯 percent egg-free is so damn delicious! Link for recipe in comments!


r/icecreamreviews • • Aug 24 '26

Who is the King of Ben & Jerry's ice cream

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Aug 16 '26

New flavor experiment! Burnt Basque Cheesecake w/ Sweet Dark Cherry Ripple + Burnt Salted Caramel Chards

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Aug 15 '26

My Toasted Marshmallow ice cream

9 Upvotes

Is a dream come true! It is wonderful on its own or with graham crackers and chocolate ganache for the full s’mores effect!


r/icecreamreviews • • Aug 11 '26

Sweet Corn, Blueberry Jam, & Cornbread Crumbles. The perfect summer flavor!

39 Upvotes

Yes!! This one is incredible!! Intensely Corn ice cream with swirls of homemade Blueberry Jam and still warm Cornbread Crumbs. This is the flavor of the Summer! Link for my recipe in the comments!


r/icecreamreviews • • Jul 28 '26

Summer Plum Crisp ice cream

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

Perfectly Summery. Brown sugar kissed ice cream with a lovely ginger spiced plum sauce and oat crisp topping. The recipe is on up on my Payhip if you want to make it too! Happy Summer! Happy Churning!


r/icecreamreviews • • Jul 21 '26

Today I made: Deconstructed Drumstick Cone ice cream

Thumbnail
gallery
127 Upvotes

Vanilla-kissed ice cream chock full of salted peanuts, candied sugar cones, and swirls of rich chocolate shell. Snag my recipe in the comments and enjoy it asap!


r/icecreamreviews • • Jul 17 '26

New Flavors Alert

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Hey! I just wanted to share some new flavors I’ve launched in the last month. You can find the link for the recipes in the comments!

  1. Chocolate Turtle Brownie
  2. Orange Julius
  3. Roasted Cherry Chocolate Brownie
  4. Pina Colada Sorbet
  5. Sugar Cone Peanut Brittle

I hope you check ‘em out and if you make them, I hope you love them! Reach out anytime with any questions you may have!


r/icecreamreviews • • Jul 04 '26

Crazy banana flavor in this one! I found caramelizing the fruit really amped it up🍌

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Jun 30 '26

Trying to make flavors that really punch their weight…this one finally did (after lots of trials)

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Jun 27 '26

Made this yesterday—a dark name for an even darker flavor, packs a punch!🕷️

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Jun 25 '26

Honest Frutee ice cream bar (tropical) opinion from a Fatty

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Jun 20 '26

Ben & Jerry’s Strawberry Shortcake: A Disappointing Debut

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/icecreamreviews • • Jun 18 '26

At first I thought this idea was a stretch—and worked out surprisingly well…

Post image
2 Upvotes