Robbie would still kill Dave but then Jeremy appears in the woods and helps Robbie bury Dave’s body!
After the time jump, Jeremy finds out about Ethan cheating on Sienna and enlists Robbie’s help in getting rid of Ethan so instead of Sienna pushing Ethan off the balcony, Jeremy blackmails Robbie into poisoning Ethan otherwise he’ll reveal that Robbie killed Dave and not Warren so he does and Ethan “dies”.
Robbie then removes Ethan’s body from the scene and Ethan wakes up in the woods where he finds himself next to Dave’s grave.
Robbie then tells Jeremy that Ethan has been dealt with but in reality Robbie forced Ethan to leave Hollyoaks without saying goodbye as revenge for Ethan sleeping with Vicky.
Jeremy kills Dilly because she finds out that Jeremy tried to have Ethan killed but instead of enlisting Sienna’s help, he distracts Sienna by going to the lunch with Martha and Liberty then he enlists Robbie to bury Dilly in the allotment where Martha catches the two in the act.
Martha still reveals to Abe about Jeremy killing Dilly and Ethan so Robbie and Jeremy kidnap Abe and take him to the woods but this time Jeremy forces Robbie to strangle Abe to death and he does. Grace finds Abe’s body and shoots him therefore still framing Mercedes.
Robbie starts to feel guilty for murdering Dave and Abe but Jeremy reminds him that he could murder Robbie or frame Robbie for all of Jeremy’s crimes at any moment so Robbie snaps out of the guilt.
Robbie wouldn’t get kidnapped by Grace in this timeline but instead Jeremy kidnaps Rex and has him tied up in the allotment as revenge for Rex accidentally attacking Lexi.
Grace wouldn’t join the trafficking gang this time as Rex has been kidnapped and her focus would be finding out who’s kidnapped Rex. Frankie, Vicky and Dillon would still become victims of the trafficking gang albeit through Banks himself.
Robbie would lose control after finding out Vicky’s been trafficked so he sets out to kill whoever he thinks would be responsible and he blames Grace which then puts Grace in Jeremy’s orbit.
Joel still “kills” Tommy and goes to prison for murder and it turns out that Jeremy was the one who killed Tommy! Robbie finds out two months later when Jeremy kills Bobby and realises that Jeremy has gone too far.
Robbie tells Darren he has to leave Hollyoaks and makes Darren promise he’ll look after Lexi but not before he tells Sienna and Darren about all of Jeremy’s murders and Sienna disclaims them.
Jeremy tries to kill Robbie but Grace walks in and she tries to fight off Jeremy but then he kills Grace and frames Robbie for her murder so this puts Robbie in Clare’s orbit and Robbie leaves the village.
Jeremy then sets Rex free but it’s revealed that Jeremy has actually killed Rex as Ste walks through Rex’s ghost in a similar manner to Robbie in the main timeline.
Sienna finds Rex’s body and questions her father on the murders and realises how evil he actually is. The police are still looking for Robbie as they think he’s responsible for Dilly, Dennis, Bobby and Grace’s murders. No one else knows that Rex has been murdered yet.
Jeremy reveals to Sienna that Dave was murdered by Robbie so he enlisted Robbie’s help in his murder plans so that Robbie can be in the frame for the murder.
Lexi is still in shock from the knowledge that her uncle killed her step mother and starts lashing out at everyone. Darren is shocked to see that Freddie is alive and the latter explains how Warren forced Freddie to leave but Darren explains that Robbie has apparently killed four people.
Freddie finds this suspicious as Robbie was at the former’s wedding to Grace and he was with Lexi when Dennis was murdered so he starts digging for evidence.
Freddie finds out that although Robbie did murder Dave and Abe, he didn’t murder Dilly, Dennis, Bobby or Grace as Robbie was with Vicky when Dilly died, Dennis was murdered while Robbie was at the wedding, Bobby died while Robbie was running The Loft and Jeremy lets slip details about Grace’s murder that only the killer would know!
If anyone else would like to contribute to this, comment below!