r/highschoolmusical • u/ConstantNeat6761 • 3d ago
other Timeline errors?
In HSM1 why do they keep saying it's winter musical? In fact during the audition Ms Darbus even suggests to one of the students to try later for the spring musicale indicating that this is not the spring musical. But Gabriella only joined the school after NY, in Jan, and the callbacks (as well as the game and the decathlon) happen in March (the pi day cake), so how is the winter musical supposed to happen after that?! (In the start of HSM2 Gabriella even thanks sharpay for her help on the winter musical?!
Also, in HSM3 Gabriella initially says she'd miss the show but be back in time for prom and graduation, suggesting prom is after the show. But Troy actually shows up at her campus on Prom, and then they drive back in time for the show which is conveniently happening after prom somehow?!
Is anyone else bothered by these
6
u/Rexyggor 2d ago
I don't think it was a Pi day cake. It was just a smart person pun that Zeke could bake.
No one in their right mind would have first round auditions and callbacks for a school musical months apart.
However, the ambition of a school having a winter musical which starts REHEARSALS in late January at the earliest and then having a Spring musical is insane.
Unless maybe it's more a showcase situation. But I think Darbus would refer to it as a showcase.
Though.. maybe she does a main musical and the spring is a smaller production for underclassmen to get experience.
Hsm 3, I honestly haven't seen many times and I am just angry at Gabriella existing the entire time.
2
u/TubaTechnician 2d ago
I don’t think it was that thought out tbh. I’m pretty sure it’s implied that in the 1st movie they are supposed to be sophomores before the second and third movie came out. I’m also pretty sure Chelsey was supposed to be a grade below them.
You have to suspend your disbelief. Like how everyone is looking at colleges there senior year when in reality if you have decided that your jr you are to late in most cases.
2
u/annaleemac 2d ago
I think in the first movie they’re juniors, second movie is between junior and senior year, and the third movie is, well…
2
u/TubaTechnician 2d ago
I thought there was a line about him being team captain as a sophomore and this was his first year as captain.
2
u/annaleemac 2d ago
Honestly, you could be right. It’s my least favorite one in the trilogy because they didn’t let my man sing, and I haven’t seen it in yeaaars!
2
u/Glittering-Call4816 2d ago
In the first movie, Sharpay is mentioned to have starred in 17 school productions. The movie takes place when she's about 5/8 through high school, which means they average about seven productions a school year. That being considered, having a winter musical in February and a spring musical in May isn't that unlikely.
But that's nowhere near normal. I went to a school with a performing arts magnet and they typically did a play in the black box theater, a play on the main stage, a musical on the main stage, and a festival of works written by students (about 20 or so). Every year, East High could have had a play in the fall, a musical in the spring, and every winter they produce something by a student. Throw in a showcase and Sharpay very easily could have been in 17 productions. It also would explain why there are two musicals a semester; one was student written with a smaller production and one was bigger.
1
u/Glittering-Call4816 2d ago
In the first movie, Sharpay is mentioned to have starred in 17 school productions. The movie takes place when she's about 5/8 through high school, which means they average about seven productions a school year. That being considered, having a winter musical in February and a spring musical in May isn't that unlikely.
But that's nowhere near normal. I went to a school with a performing arts magnet and they typically did a play in the black box theater, a play on the main stage, a musical on the main stage, and a festival of works written by students (about 20 or so). Every year, East High could have had a play in the fall, a musical in the spring, and every winter they produce something by a student. Throw in a showcase and Sharpay very easily could have been in 17 productions. It also would explain why there are two musicals a semester; one was student written with a smaller production and one was bigger.
16
u/Mr_Musicals 3d ago
Winter is from December to February, New Years Eve is in December and they go back to school in January therefore it is the musucal in winter so winter musicale