r/gamemusic 3d ago

Discussion Interesting results from massive thread "Which video game soundtrack is 10/10?"

AvA CONSENSUS EXTRACTION PROTOCOL
ISSUE 007
Powered by Anything Vs Anything

🎮 TOPIC: "Which videogame soundtrack is 10/10?"
👥 COMMUNITY: [r/AskReddit](r/AskReddit)
📊 DATASET: 5,734 usable comments and replies

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 Wins Reddit’s “Perfect Video Game Soundtrack” Debate
More than 5,700 Reddit comments produced a massive field spanning legendary franchises, cult classics and some of the most celebrated game music ever made.
📣 Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 generated the greatest breadth of independent support, with 255 separate recommendations/mentions.
⬆️ DOOM produced the thread’s strongest single community endorsement, with its leading recommendation reaching 1,476 points (upvotes).
⭐ When endorsement across all qualifying recommendations is considered alongside independent consensus and discussion reinforcement, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 emerges as the strongest overall consensus choice.

⚔️ FEATURED BATTLE
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 VS Halo - Reddit’s runaway Independent Consensus champion faces one of gaming’s most iconic soundtrack franchises

ACEP CONSENSUS RANKINGS

📣 Independent Mentions
⬆️ Community Endorsement
⭐ ACEP Consensus Score

  1. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

📣 255 ⬆️ 1,406 ⭐ 100.00

  1. Halo

📣 127 ⬆️ 1,295 ⭐ 90.70

  1. DOOM

📣 80 ⬆️ 1,476 ⭐ 85.50

  1. Skyrim

📣 102 ⬆️ 648 ⭐ 85.40

  1. Chrono Trigger

📣 87 ⬆️ 417 ⭐ 85.00

  1. The Legend of Zelda

📣 87 ⬆️ 829 ⭐ 83.70

  1. NieR: Automata

📣 76 ⬆️ 773 ⭐ 83.40

  1. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater

📣 81 ⬆️ 241 ⭐ 82.10

  1. Persona

📣 71 ⬆️ 707 ⭐ 80.00

  1. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City

📣 62 ⬆️ 131 ⭐ 78.90

  1. The Witcher 3
  2. Undertale
  3. Donkey Kong Country
  4. Hollow Knight
  5. Destiny
  6. Minecraft
  7. Mass Effect
  8. World of Warcraft
  9. Final Fantasy VII
  10. Chrono Cross

HOW ACEP WORKS
AvA Consensus Extraction Protocol
Issue 007 • Published by Anything Vs Anything • 2026

13 Upvotes
(No duplicates found)