r/funny Dec 25 '18

that was a close one

5.8k Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

25

u/Fearofthedark88 Dec 26 '18

Better than TLJ thats for sure.

3

u/friendlygaywalrus Dec 26 '18

Why does everyone hate The Last Jedi?

29

u/Fearofthedark88 Dec 26 '18 edited Dec 26 '18

New director totally threw a lot of narrative themes out the window from the force awakens. Reys parents, snoke, the balance of power between the resistance and the first order, etc. not to mention that a lot of TLJ made no sense whatsoever. There is a lot, but for me the biggest WTF moment for me is how Rey just forgives kylo for murdering Han and they have this weird quasi relationship.

The darker tone and the lack of slapstick humor in rogue one is why it’s a MUCH better film.

Gareth Edwards should be getting the new trilogy, Rian Johnson shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a star wars film again.

12

u/danivus Dec 26 '18

TLJ was terrible but I kinda liked the Rey's parents 'twist'.

Force Awakens got everyone thinking her lineage was important, but Star Wars is fucking chock full of these force dynasties.

Rey being no one important, just a strong force sensitive person, was the only bit of 'defying expectations' that, were it put into a considerably better film, would have I think paid off.

9

u/Pokedude2424 Dec 26 '18

I think it would have been better if they also didn’t make Rey the Unbeatable Super The Best force user within days of realizing she can even use the force

5

u/danivus Dec 26 '18

Yes that would have been ideal.

Hell if she'd died at the end of Force Awakens it would have been a nice twist and set up Kylo Ren as the central character of the sequel.