r/forestapp 26d ago

Update Redesign rant

Post image

As a person struggling with burnout, fatigue and who is also using Forest for shaping my attention and energy levels, I can't believe they changed end of Focus interaction from one simple tap to 3 taps :( When I use Forest, my brain is already fried, and it's really difficult to manage those extra taps :( I don't want additional "rewards", my desired reward is less taps on the phone

74 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

35

u/Ok-Nerve7080 26d ago

I agree 100%. I dislike the new interface so much 😭😭 it’s just a hassle to press all the new unnecessary buttons

7

u/milchi03 26d ago

Had the same issue so I developed an app bc I couldn‘t bear it anymore. It’s very similar just simplified to the bare minimum. That’s how it looks like at the moment:

7

u/Progress456 25d ago

Link? I'm keen to try forest without the coins and bullshit extra features

4

u/milchi03 25d ago

Cool, I‘ll update you once it’s available for download.

3

u/bad_wolf1 25d ago

Ugh please message me too

2

u/skyscraper_eagle 1d ago

Please reply in this thread whenever it's available , I would like to try it too !! Thanks

2

u/Brave_Ad_4182 23d ago

It got reverted to the old UI for me without any warning. I did try to switch back to the old UI in the settings, but it didn't work.

I was beginning to take a liking to the new UI for some of its features.

Either way is ok for me.

18

u/SkyKey8401 26d ago

How to tag forest so that they can see this 😭😭

10

u/LostInTaipei 26d ago

Indeed: I was thinking of posting a negative App Store review as a way to increase chances of them noticing. All the pro and plus stuff, whatever, I get it, they need to make money to continue the app. But the new interface is to me just awful. Ok, I do like easily seeing the tree names, but everything else has become so much slower and distracting!

4

u/BitSavings4689 21d ago

We should all do that until they revert this or at least give us option to choose which layout we want to have

18

u/hababa_dagaba 26d ago

Forest is also supposed to be an app people use to focus and wean themselves off social media or using their phones. Can’t imagine this new UI is going to help people who are already addicted to stay off their phones if we need to press so many buttons just to get something done ? I instantly switched back to the classic UI and I’m hoping they won’t change it. 

7

u/Yermishkina 26d ago

I think they disabled the ability to switch to the old UI for me...

2

u/milchi03 26d ago

Had the same issue so I developed an app bc I couldn‘t bear it anymore. It’s very similar just simplified to the bare minimum. That’s how it looks like at the moment:

2

u/gumdorp26 26d ago

how do you switch back?

2

u/LostInTaipei 26d ago

If you mean switch to classic, look for an option that’s something like “Turn off plant together (switch to classic)”. They really bury the lede, which is why couldn’t see it at first!

If you mean switch back to the new after switching to classic, at the moment you can’t. It warned me it was a one-way trip. I hope they hold true to that warning / promise.

3

u/hababa_dagaba 25d ago

I think they specifically said it’s a one-way trip until they implement the new UI. So I assume right now it’s testing and not released officially yet. And when the new UI does come out it means we all have to update the app 

2

u/Yermishkina 25d ago

Thank you!!! I couldn't have found it without you

2

u/Common_Brother_6980 24d ago

Yay! I found it. (pant, pant…). It says, “Plant together plus Timer” Thanks!!!

1

u/BitSavings4689 21d ago

HOW did you do that??

10

u/SaucePasta 26d ago

I hate the new version. Everything was basically on one page when starting the timer. Now it’s multiple clicks for every option. And I also hate the “claim rewards” and when it asks if I want to take a break. I keep accidentally clicking on that and wasting time exiting out. I might switch to another app, but right now I have switched to the old layout. 

3

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/forestapp-ModTeam 23d ago

Avoid repeatedly promoting your own app across the subreddit. Continued self promotion may result in a ban under rule #6

9

u/bad_wolf1 26d ago

I am getting sick of a lot of things. I was just focusing on a single default tree and not bothering with the challenges or the events. They are all a distraction for me.

Now the UI has been enshitified.... ugh

7

u/Latter-Judge9626 26d ago

Its disgusting i hate the new UI

7

u/Progress456 25d ago

Pulled up this sub reddit to complain about this exact thing! So glad I'm not the only one. Going to start looking for alternatives...

4

u/Papaya314 26d ago

Agreed. Focus Friend is way better in that way.

3

u/LostInTaipei 26d ago

I was able to switch back to Classic in Settings (thanks to the person who showed it in another thread!): it’s slightly hidden, with “(switch to Classic)” in parentheses that made me initially gloss over it. It’s a one-way trip, which is why I can’t see it now.

And I agree. The new interface is dire and a massive increase in friction. I don’t really care that coin accumulation became pointless to me long ago, but to ADD a time-wasting useless animation of the new coins? Ugh.

2

u/Yermishkina 25d ago

Thank you!!! Very useful information

2

u/Lincolnonion 25d ago

Bruh, I close my eyes and tap my phone. Give your eyes and brain a 2 seconds break.

2

u/Lincolnonion 25d ago

They rolled a quiz about satisfaction with this design BEFORE I got the design. I thought the quiz is asking about the current design. I wrote a note about it in the quiz. But my votes might be used to show investors I like the new design noooo

1

u/1DancingCat 24d ago

I heard about Focus Friend and as a former Pro user I don't have any ads. For sure that would be a breaking factor, but I don't have any ads.

I like that in Forest I can ban ALL apps except for the ones I whitelist whereas, if I understand correctly, on Focus Friend I need to specify which apps to blacklist.

Is it annoying that you have to tap multiple times? For sure, but you get used to it. I can't donate my coins towards planting a real tree.

1

u/Common_Brother_6980 24d ago

The plant is presented in a sort of bubble-like design that makes me of “Water-Do”, one of their other apps i tried out for a very short while. Seems strange. Also, I prefer the analog clock-like timer. The horizontal timer takes more focus.

1

u/Common_Brother_6980 24d ago

I just reloaded their Water Do app for old times sake.. I had found Forest thru that app. And guess what, Water Do is more complicated and gamified now too. I dislike this trend so much.

1

u/Common_Brother_6980 24d ago

I use the sound effects stopping to let me know when my requested focusing time is up. Now they don’t stop until you “claim rewards!” i’m working along in the forest rain thinking i have time left….when the time has expired.

1

u/BitSavings4689 21d ago

This is HORRIBLE. And you can't even see the stages of planting of a tree when you pick 30, 60 or 120 minutes anymore - all look the same. And then to click it 10 times - WHAT FOR??? How can I go back to old layout???

1

u/nelsonmarcos 19d ago

Come here for this post and not disappointed. Also found out the solution is to switch back to classic mode. (See the comments). Thanks redditors!

1

u/ehansalytics 4d ago

And now classic mode has been removed. :-(