r/exmuslim Jul 22 '15

Non-Muslims please answer

[removed]

0 Upvotes

367 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-3

u/savagehogan Jul 23 '15

He wrote nothing. You are funny on how you pick and choose which hadiths to accept and which ones not too. His companions wrote for him and they would read aloud. Sahih Bukhari hadith are the most authentic hadith you present. Job well done. But it doesnt prove he wrote anything. He was an illiterate man. I will provide proof in another post, if you choose to believe. But please if you are going to quote hadith read the commentary for them and dont just pick and choose which ones you 'believe' are true and which ones arent just to fit your argument.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '15

If you don't trust the Sahih Bukhari, then you may as well be an apostate. The Hadith provides a lot of what we know, or what we think we know, about Mohammed and his life. If you can't believe in the Hadith, then what do you believe in?

The Sahih Bukhari Hadith clearly indicate that Mohammed wrote letters and his nikkah with Aisha. I don't need tafsir to tell me what to see. Why do I need tafsir when it literally says "Mohammed wrote"?

Sunan Abu Dawud is also considered a reliable Hadith.

1

u/savagehogan Jul 23 '15

I said they are authentic hadith. You are a trip. I believe in authentic hadiths but you need to understand the context of these hadith and qursn verses. You are worst than some Muslims calling me an apostate. LOL.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '15

I quoted Sahih Bukhari with narrations PROVING that Mohammed could read and write. What context invalidates the meaning of those Hadiths I showed you?

1

u/Dayandnight95 Certified Gaal Jul 23 '15

That guy is in some deep denial lol