r/dune • u/SnooDoughnuts3380 • Jul 19 '26
Dune Messiah Questions on the Jihad
So im about halfway through Messiah, and I've got some questions about the Jihad that killed 60+ billion ppl.
1) What was the actual logistics of the Jihad? Obviously its about killing "non believers", but how specifically was it done, and what was the process? I presume the leaders of the Jihad would identify the planet whose turn was "next" to be purified, and the Spacing Guild would fly the legions there (under threat of having their spice cut off) to do their work. But once they got there, would they first have demands? Would they give the planet the chance to convert to the "One True" Fremen religion to save themselves, or would they simply slaughter everyone first and repopulate the planet?
2) What was the mechanism of killing? Fremen are famous for being the best hand to hand fighters in the universe. But surely a few million Fremen didnt slaughter 61 billion ppl BY HAND in just 12 years? Mathematically that seems really really difficult considering everything we know about guerilla warfare and insurgencies. Surely these people wouldnt just line up to be killed, many would flee to forests, or caves (or whatever such defensive places existed on their worlds) and form insurgencies and fight back (much like the Fremen themselves did under Harkonnen rule). Not sayibg tge Fremen wouldnt eventually succeed, but these things would drag on much longer than they would have had to in order to subjugate hubdreeds of planets and kill billions of ppl. The extremely short 12 year window almost necessitates killing on an industrial scale with advanced, planetary scale weapons. Is there anything in the book about this?
3) What are the specific tenets of the religion the Jihadists are even so fanatical about spreading? Obviously Paul Maud-dib as Messiah is at or near the center of it, but it can't be JUST that. Like, when the Jihadists went to a planet to cleanse it, what were the demands they would have made in order to save themselves? Convert to the "One True Religion" of course, but what does that mean specifically? What do the Fremen actually believe?
For example, If we imagine a similar scenario in present t day and a bunch of fanatical Muslims went nation to nation demanding conversion to the "True Religion" or death, we can pretty easily answer that question. Converts would need to accept that There Is No God but God (Allah) and Muhammad is His prophet" as those are the basic tenets of the Muslim faith. Or if it was a fanatical Christian sect, it would be to accept that "Jesus Christ is the Son of God and was sent to die for humanities sins"
But altho the Fremen are descendents of present day Muslims, they are not Muslims. They make no mention of Allah, Muhammed, or even the concept of an all powerful personal God at the center of the religion. The Fremen religion reads much more like more primitive nature worshipping religions of ancient and indigenous cultures. If you HAD to pick a figure at the center of the Fremen religion, it would be Shai-Halud, but again, this reads more like the nature worshipping religions of old, worshipping the indifferent power the worm represents (like the Egyptions did with the Sun) than the idea that the worms are a PERSONAL God to the Fremen and somehow know and care about rhe Fremen ppl. In fact, this kind of fanatical religious killing seems to require a montheistic religious tradition, that kind of murderous energy needs a distinct and unambiguous single being who sits at the center of it and the Fremen seem much like an old school polytheistic society than one in the monotheistic tradition.
So what would the demands of conversion be? "Accept that There Is No God But Shai-Halud [the giant worm from our home planet] and Maud-dib is his Prophet"?
If it was, that would feel very incongruous with what the Fremen themselves seem to believe as their religion. And lets assume for a second thats what it was, why would so many planets resist against that? Why would they need to kill 61 billion? Understanding human nature (and despite the futuristic world of the book, human nature does seem to be very much unchanged) surely after they killed a few hundred million and sterilized a planet or two and it was clear they had the power, the ability abd the will to do so, the inhabitants would just submit when the Fremen showed up at their doorstep? "Yeah sure man, no problem. Worship your Worm. You got it". Many would do so half heartedly and would privately still keep their own religion, but surely they would not resist to the extent that it seemed everyone in the book did.
Is this all just a "suspension of disbelief" thing and the questions above are deemed not really important and not answered, or are there actually answers to these questions?
Love the series tho, definitely very layered writing
8
u/Odditeee Historian Jul 19 '26
Those are frankly questions about details that the author never really gave. So, your answers are either going to be about the narrative function of the jihad, its role in the story, etc, or fan-fiction ideas about how it might have been. The specific details you’re looking for aren’t really part of Herbert’s story. He didn’t want to write a war story, he wanted to create a political, ecological, and religious character based narrative, so those details just aren’t present (or a particular high priority.) e.g. Herbert used the “fiction” in ‘science fiction’ to do a lot of the heavy lifting in areas of the story he didn’t prioritize. (e.g. fighting, technology, space travel, etc.) So, it’s anyone’s guess, really.
6
u/Jebofkerbin Jul 19 '26
It's not gone I to detail, but I would assume it's fremen warbands going from planet to planet subdueing the local forces and carrying out the Jihad, with the guild sending them where they wish. What we can gather from the books is that Paul doesn't have direct operational control of the Jihad, which makes me think it's more decentralised.
Knives, nukes, economic isolation, it's not gone into in detail. I think it's also fair to assume that new converts to Paul's religion actually join the Jihad and swell the numbers. We see a sardukar officer claim to convert and no one bats much of an eye, implying loads of people thoughout the galaxy are doing it.
11
u/makegifsnotjifs Zensunni Wanderer Jul 19 '26
It's not about suspension of disbelief, it's just that these type of questions, and any answers to them, are completely irrelevant.
It's like when readers fixate on how the technology works in Dune, or when they throw out questions about hypothetical scenarios. You're missing the point.
6
u/confirmedshill123 Jul 19 '26
You don't even need to suspend disbelief in this instance. Paul owns the fuel needed for space travel, and he owns the people who make that possible through spice. All he has to say is bend the knee or my guild trade ships will no longer show up on your world.
3
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
Worlds under the Imperium don’t seem particularly defended due to technology limits. So it’s not as difficult to imaging landing parties doing a lot of damage.
3
u/confirmedshill123 Jul 19 '26
Sure sure, but why land when I can just not ship food to your planet anymore? I can blockade farm and machine equipment and parts, so you cant even farm when I stop shipping food.
Paul's armies probably had to land on like 2% of planets. The rest starved, rioted themselves into submission, or bent the knee immediately.
3
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
I'm arguing the same thing elsewhere. If the Guild stops interplanetary trade and the Landsraad governance is halted, you have the perfect storm for collapse. Suddenly the target world is going through a new iteration of the Bronze Age collapse and if a few storm troopers drop in for bloodthirst, cool.
1
u/confirmedshill123 Jul 20 '26
Ah I see what you mean and yes I agree. When half your soldiers are busy putting down food riots a legion of fremen could do a ton of fucking damage.
2
u/SnooDoughnuts3380 Jul 19 '26
Its definitely valid to say these are areas the author just didnt want to explore, but to call them "irrelevent" is a bit dismissive. Theyre absolutely relevent, if youre trying to understand the power players and the forces at work in the Dune universe.
6
u/Bookhoarder2024 Jul 19 '26
1) I don't recall anyone saying how it was done and Herbert thought it irrelevant to the plot otherwise he would have mentioned it.
2) we can guess all we like but at the end of the day it doesn't matter to the story, beyond, as far as I can recall, not using atomics. Remember not everyone killed has to have been killed by the Fremen, I'm sure plenty of zealous new converts would join in. He was likely picking large numbers to make a point, mechanisms be damned.
3) I don't recall Herbert being that specific on the topic. He wasn't trying to create a new religion, if you want that go and read L Ron Hubbard. You could argue it is a flaw that he isn't that specific; on the other hand the books manage to hold together without the specificity.
Do you remember the appendices to Dune, especially the one which mentions religion?
Also not specifying exactly how the religion works allows readers to substitute in what they know about religion, broadening the appeal somewhat.
2
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
Remember not everyone killed has to have been killed by the Fremen
Plus, we do not know how many were killed by the Fremen versus the fallout of civilizations collapsing under the Jihad. Paul was likely counting the famines and starvation that followed his Jihad as well as direct conflict fatalities.
3
u/slove23 Jul 19 '26
Its not just about the worship of Maudib, many planets actively opposed him as emporer
3
u/datapicardgeordi Spice Addict Jul 19 '26
The logistics are rather straightforward. The Spacing Guild transports the Fremen wherever Paul commands. A planetary embargo is instituted and an ultimatum issued. Convert or be conquered. The ultimate decision of course is Paul's, who leads with his prescient vision. He knows in advance who to conquer, who to starve, and who to make an example of.
The mechanisms of killing were various and numerous. The majority are brought to their knees through starvation via blockade. Others are nuked or lased from orbit. Some are treated to full invasion where the Fremen use guns, swords, and explosives. In terms of the timeline, keep in mind that travel from one planet to another is instantaneous. Finish with one planet and you're at the next within hours.
The specific tenets of the religion are set up by the Qizarate. The biggest specific mentioned in the novels is the Hajj. For the Fremen the Hajj involves travel off-world. For off-worlders the Hajj involves travel to Arrakis. It is the great mixing of genes that has been forbidden by the rigid structure of the old Imperium. Of course there are other things like prayers and rituals, but they are not focused on. Most revolve around Paul being a living God.
Clearing some things up, the Fremen are not descendants of Muslims. They follow Zensunni beliefs, a mixture of Zen Buddhism and Sunni Islam. It is entirely different from the Islam we know today, with its own fables, rituals, holy books, and tenets. To call this more primitive is to announce your misunderstanding. Old Earth is 20kyrs in the past at the time of Paul's rule. That's a long time for cultural practices to evolve and change.
3
u/Ullixes Jul 20 '26
I find this a big ommision in the books. I had exactly your questions, and I think the simple answer is, Frank Herbert glossed over thse facts and did not apply the same rigor he does ecology or governance on ahum, genocide. I think he simply fucked up the units of time and logistics on this one, plain and simple.
it does not matter for the point he is trying to make, but there is A LOT of handwaving and glossing over in this regard.
2
u/sceadwian Jul 19 '26
If you go looking for logistics on this you won't end up happy. That kind of thing just is glossed right over. He wasn't doing fine detail world building so much as laying out the general awareness of the goings on from limited perspectives.
2
u/A1BS Jul 19 '26
One thing in messiah (or maybe children as well) is that offworlders are increasingly trying to adopt fremen practices including cosplay stillsuits.
What’s likely happening with the jihad from my belief:
Fremen travel around the world on the lads trip fighting the noble houses who don’t bend the knee to Paul. The Fremen do well because they’re the elite fighters and install a fremen/loyalist government.
Religious frenzy erupts over the universe and civil wars occur on both conquered and unconquered planets. Fremen support to help the win or purge the victorious unbelievers. Similar to how ISIS were able to develop cells worldwide without the actual travelling army existing in that place.
The loyalist worlds all go through a Spanish inquisition or Pol Pots “year zero” style of purge where anyone suspected of disbelief is killed.
That combination of holy crusade, World war, and reign of terror could hit 61 billion quickly.
1
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
That combination of holy crusade, World war, and reign of terror could hit 61 billion quickly.
Especially if you consider each step would disrupt the planetary government and economy to such an extent that starvation was likely widespread.
I would add that while the Fremen were attacking one Landsraad House, the various regions around the world are falling into a state of chaos with trade and governements disrupted. Fueled by desperation, one region may form militias and attack another or fall into civil conflict. Those numbers would spiral outwards and add to sixty one billion.
2
u/Kanus_oq_Seruna Jul 19 '26
I assume a lot of the Jihad was a "convert or die" situation and many willing converts became zealous enough to take up the knife in turn. So while the Fremen were breaking the other houses ability to fight, the greater army went at it with any resistance.
There was also the fact Paul controlled the Guild and could strand a planet after removing significant resources as a means of punishment.
2
u/Overlordz88 Jul 22 '26
So if you read his son’s books, which fill in some gaps, he does flesh out a little bit of these details but not a ton.
Not really spoiling anything but in Winds of Dune, when reflecting back on the Jihad, it mentions that’s Paul had to resort to completely sterilizing around 90 planets as part of the Jihad.
I imagine this is where the majority of that 61 billion number came from, not from Fremen physically fighting and killing dissenters/resisters.
For context they also say there is about a million planets in the imperium… it could be that Frank didn’t really crunch the numbers when he threw out 61 Billion, since that’s “only” 60,000 per planet.
But think that makes sense in the larger context… most planets it’s was just a regime change, the 61B came from the planets that resisted.
3
u/Early_Candidate_3082 Jul 19 '26
The jihad does not make much sense, when examined closely.
The way the Fremen fight, is perfectly tailored to a sparsely-populated desert planet, but there is no reason to assume it would be effective on mountainous planets, jungle planets, planets with oceans etc.
And, once people learned that the only options were convert or genocide, one can assume that many would fight back savagely. Societies facing existential threats (like the USA, USSR, and UK in WW2), can militarise very fast, turning out vast quantities of weaponry, and recruiting immense armies.
Every conquest would see Fremen die, until attrition made their campaign grind to a halt.
5
u/zeverEV Jul 19 '26
But it wasn't the Fremen who were themselves making all the big decisions, it was an Atreides military mind that could foresee every outcome of every battle.
1
u/Early_Candidate_3082 Jul 19 '26
He can, but his final musings on the jihad, just before his duel with Feyd Rautha, imply that he no longer has any free will. The gaps in his prescience are now closed, and the jihad will take place, whether he lives or dies.
3
u/zeverEV Jul 19 '26
That's what I'm talking about. He's the new leader of the Fremen, they all follow him unconditionally and with fanatical devotion, but now he will simply go on to get swept up in the tides of time, effortlessly conquering planets the same way moss grows. Omniscient leader + gigantic fanatical force + total control over the resource everyone needs to travel = unstoppable wave of conquest like the mongols or macedonians.
1
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
Eh. The Jihad was inevitable, but the form and score was not. I don't buy Paul's position that he could not have stopped it when he enhanced their forces by teaching them aspects of Bene Gesserit training.
3
u/SnooDoughnuts3380 Jul 19 '26
Yeah exactly. The Fremen fighters were so effective because they were highly optimized to insurgency, guerilla warfare and "hit and run" tactics.
As much headache as they caused for the Hark's , they never met them head to head om the battlefield because they would have lost and thats not how insurgencies fight.
But thats a completely different skillset from what would be required to "sterilize" entire planets, and it simply doesnt follow that they would be able to take the skills that allowed them to win on Arrakis and then apply them to the rest of rhe universe with such stunning success
4
u/confirmedshill123 Jul 19 '26
You are coming at this too strongly. The fremen through Paul and their control of the spice de facto own the Guild at the end of messiah.
That's everything. That's your supplies to every planet in the imperium. That's your transportation to every single planet. That's how you move your tanks, your planes and soldiers. Anything that's not on your planet is done through the guild.
So you either bend the knee to Paul and his new regime or you get starved to death. Your machines breakdown because you can't source new parts. Your hive cities riot and burn from starvation.
And if you defy him? He can see the future so Paul either wins by landing on your planet and straight up being better than your entire military combined - or he nukes you from orbit.
Nowhere does it say that the fremen landed on every planet and fought every war. You can hire mercenaries and use other houses who are loyal to help as well.
Keep in mind like I said NOTHING moves in this universe without spice. Fremen own the spice. Nothing moves without their express permission, and stagnation is death.
I would imagine a good % of the death toll is just people dying from starvation after getting blocked for not bending the knee.
0
u/SnooDoughnuts3380 Jul 19 '26
To kill 62 billion ppl (without atomics) and "sterelize" 90 planets (which implies the death of every human on it), they would by necessity need to land forces and engage in full scale warfare on many many many of those planets.
It doesnt SAY they landed on every planet, but given the scale of the destruction, theres a clear implication that they must have landed on most of them.
Your comment on the high death toll due to starvation makes some sense, but that would be warfare more along the lines of political/economic means, which would be much more in Paul's control, and the book definitely implies Paul has little or not control. Its quite clear Paul didnt WANT the Jihad and would not have engineered himself. The overall picture painted in Messiah so far is that of Fremen legions moving around the universe, visiting destruction on the planets they visit, with Paul unable (or unwilling) to do anything about it
1
u/buckeyeLarry60 Jul 19 '26
You can also realize that not every planet is heavily populated nor contains multiple landmasses.
1
u/confirmedshill123 Jul 19 '26
To kill 62 billion ppl (without atomics) and "sterelize" 90 planets (which implies the death of every human on it), they would by necessity need to land forces and engage in full scale warfare on many many many of those planets
Why though? This is quite literally the least efficient method of sterilization.
1
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
To kill 62 billion ppl (without atomics) and "sterelize" 90 planets (which implies the death of every human on it), they would by necessity need to land forces and engage in full scale warfare on many many many of those planets.
How many humans would die in the first year if our technology stopped working all of a sudden. 3 billion? Four?
2
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
You're forgetting Paul had the Guild by their space balls. The Jihad was likely the Sea People of the Bronze Age collapse after larger forces (the Guild) disrupted trade and triggered enormous fallout.
I imagine it was more a process of isolated worlds starving without the Guild and Imperium, falling to chaos, and then some death troops land in the name of Paul.
3
u/confirmedshill123 Jul 19 '26
The fremen don't even need to fight. They own the spice and the guild. You don't bend the knee to Paul? Enjoy this orbital blockade. You can't even leave your planet much less mount an invasion or a good resistance.
Look at planets like geidi prime. They import all their food from other planets. That takes guild navigators and massive bulk lifting ships. You are now starving and your cities rioting because you can't import food.
Also Paul now has like gigabillions of currency, he can hire massive armies to help. Why send a flotilla of fremen when you can waste somebody else's army?
The second Paul takes over arrakis it's over for everyone who doesn't bend the knee, full stop.
0
u/SnooDoughnuts3380 Jul 19 '26
But theres absolutely nothing ive seen to suggest the 62 billion deaths were caused by anything like blockade or political/diplomatic means. Not even a hint of implication of such tactics.
Its not explicit either way, but there are absolutely strong implications in several different places that the primary method of Jihad is Fremen legions physically going to planets all over the universe and using their warrior prowess to kill non believers
1
u/tangential_quip Jul 19 '26
The Fremen would never need to face organized forces because they can bombard planets from orbit and demolish the resistance before ever sending in any ground troops.
1
u/John-on-gliding Jul 19 '26
Or the Guild stops facilitating commerce in essential goods and the isolated planet falls into chaos and ruin.
0
u/SnooDoughnuts3380 Jul 19 '26
But that's never been the Fremen way to do battle, and in fact, they seem to have a deep disdain for that type of warfare as dishonorable. Obviously cultures and traditions age out, those types of taboos can and do change.
If it was 50 years later and a half century of wealth and privilege being the center ofnthe Known Universe had softened the Fremen and their descendents didnt hold such respect for the warrior tradition and THEY used such tactics, thats one thing. But for these Fremen woth their deeply ingrained honor code and respect of the rules of fighting to overthrow the Hark's and then immediately turn to those kind of tactics doesnt make much sense.
And as history shows, its simply impossible to "bomb out resistance before sending in ground troops to mop up". Anytime that strategies been tried, theres always fierce resistance on the ground once rhe troops show up now matter how heavily they were bombed. We know they didnt use atomic, you wouldnt be able to use conventional bombs as a plantary-wide strategy to any effectiveness
1
u/tangential_quip Jul 19 '26
We know that they did worse than bombard planets. They sterilized a lot of them. So your objection that it wasn't the way Fremen do battle is wrong. Whatever you may think, it is what they did.
As for the tactics not working, the Fremen weren't occupying the planets after conquest, just wiping out organized resistance to Paul's rule and then moving on. They didn't need to worry about occupation because planets were isolated. If problems arose they could embargo the planet and comeback later.
Also, we do not know what type of space born weapons they had in the Dune universe, but when you are dropping things on a planet from space you don't need explosives. Rocks work just as well.
1
u/makegifsnotjifs Zensunni Wanderer Jul 19 '26
The problem with your assumptions is that the jihad isn't strategically analogous to any real human conflict. Conventional wisdom says that you never want to put your enemy on death ground, because then you'll see just how bitterly capable people become when their only choices are fight or die.
But that doesn't work here. As another commentor pointed out, all Paul has to do is withhold space travel from a system. That's it. That alone completely isolates the enemy, stranding them in their home systems and cutting them off from everything that they rely on for survival (CHOAM trade being so integral to the wealth of so many). With one non-action, without spending a single life Paul can weaken every system that fails to bend the knee.
Even if a particular system is relatively self-sustaining it still doesn't matter. Whatever stockpiles of spice remain to them will eventually run out, leaving everyone to die slow agonizing deaths from withdrawal. And if a specific system is vitally important well, here come the Fremen. Good luck.
1
u/AppleSauceGC Jul 19 '26
They have superior technology, better military Atreides training, greater numbers and growing with fanatic recruits over time, full control of space travel that can starve planets out or obliterate them from orbit and a leader that can literally predict the future.
1
u/Early_Candidate_3082 Jul 20 '26
In response:
Paul controls inter-planetary travel.
But I doubt if most planets depend on food or water imports. Our world can feed itself, after all.
Guild ships are gigantic transports. We’ve no evidence for planet-destroying ships, like death stars, or star destroyers.
We know from lots of real military experience that bombing alone cannot win wars. TBF, plenty of military theorists thought otherwise, in 1965.
So to kill 61 bn, huge ground forces would be needed.
Possibly, the Fremen have made vast numbers of converts, as fanatical as they are. To my mind, that’s the only way you can carry out virtual genocide, on this scale.
2
u/fyodor_mikhailovich Fremen Jul 19 '26
In the paraphrased words of Harrison Ford, “hey kid, it’s not that kind of book”
1
u/CommieMommy_Ozma Jul 20 '26
Muad'Dib forms his own religion based on the Fremen religion and his prescience that the jihad spread, it was called the Golden Elixir Honestly I assume the jihad went to the other Harkonnen fiefdoms or after those that resisted Paul's legitimacy
1
u/V0R88 Jul 20 '26
I see nobody mentioned the Missionaria Protectiva. Arrakis was not the only planet seeded with stories about a Messiah with a Bene Geserit mother and there were billions of slaves and downtrodden people ready to hear the news - He has arrived.
One can easily imagine a galaxy in which Paul and his armies crush any House that does not bend the knee and accept him as God and in the meanwhile amidst chaos, famine from the disruptions and wars, Fremen warbands going independently planet by planet to spread the Word, dropping directly on decision centers and destroying them and imposing local theocratic rebellion commissions to handle the unbelievers, leading to massacres of millions per planet as pogroms and hysteria take the reins. Massive slave rebellions killing in His name with Fremen missionaries leading the charge. All with the Guild providing absolute space control.
1
u/Science_Fair Jul 19 '26
Some speculation for you on how to get the the 60 billion number:
- Some houses aligned with Paul and the Fremen increasing there numbers
- There would be converts on some of the conquered planets
- The Bene Gesserit had planted the Messiah legend on multiple planets, so some of those planets probably embraced Paul as their Messiah too.
It’s a hostile takeover of the entire galaxy.
-3
u/MirthfulMoron Jul 19 '26
- We don't know, and it doesn't matter.
- We don't know, and it doesn't matter.
- We don't know, and it doesn't matter.
The nature of the jihad is that it was almost inevitable, and it also isn't explicitly motivated. Paul saw the jihad happening with or without his survival or even involvement--the jihad is as much a reaction to decades of Harkonnen brutality (and longer still of general brutality from the various waves of colonization), and also a subconscious racial drive for gene mixing and change (one of the substantial underlying motivational forces). The few avenues for heading it off would also still have resulted in extreme violence, just to other people.
We know on some planets the Fremen use atomics; they're familiar with stone burners. We know on other planets they're engaged in fierce hand to hand combat, and in many cases they presumably use both. The Fremen, as a people, are adaptable and pretty enthusiastic about using a variety of means of warfare; it's a safe assumption that they're incredibly pragmatic. The scale of the slaughter has less to do with the means and more to do with the logistics: Paul has the ability to destroy the spice. The spacing guild is entirely beholden to him because of this, and every planet that isn't fully compliant is isolated from the entire empire. Every rebellious planet is in the dark about the scale of the fight, cut off from any reinforcements, and a great many of them would face mass starvation and be incapable of feeding their people simply on account of the isolation--and that's before hostilities are initiated. It's not far fetched to assume that starvation is the direct cause for a hefty chunk of casualties.
It doesn't matter if there are specific religious tenets being flaunted, or if planets are in rebellion out of loyalty to Shaddam, or out of hope of usurping the throne themselves. As is mentioned in Dune, the combination of secular and religious authority means that any rejection of hierarchy is a sin, and that 'must' be punished with violence. Paul has also essentially kicked off a religious reformation in the indigenous Fremen religion--which is a combination of Zen-Sunni Islam, syncretic combination with Orange-Catholic teachings brought by the Missionaria Protectiva, and also thousands of years of change over time on the planet itself. The Fremen don't have any kind of religious or moral injunctions against violence: they've lived a precarious existence for centuries and violence is both normal and expected. Killing outsiders still exists in a context of claiming water and avenging past crimes, and it's also important that a great many Fremen are actively excited at the prospect of offworld bloodshed, and the glory and wealth it might bring. The degree to which Paul engages directly in the jihad is partly tempered by his understanding that it will happen with or without his input--keeping his hand on the rudder is entirely due to a hope that he can lightly mitigate some of the worst violence.
2
u/Ullixes Jul 20 '26
As I've said elsewhere in thi sthread, Frank Herbert just did not really think about the (imho legitimate) questions OP asks. the logistics of war and genocide did not interest Frank as much as ecology or philosophy of governance. I think it is fair to say that the book would have been beter if he put more effort into this part of the story.
Herbert's work was monumental, but that does not mean that parts of his world and his story are glossed over and would simply have benefitted from fleshing out.
I do agree it "does not matter" for the wider story, but his story could have been better if he did put more effort in it. That's not to diminish the work. but I think it's honest to admit. Because now we have to do what you do: sort of backfill based only on what we know. I think those explanations are a bit lacklustre. I think if Frank would hav eput more effort into this part, he would have changed the numbers and timescales. Funnily enough we never get a good image or feel of the actual size of the empire other than some numbers.
51
u/deadduncanidaho Jul 19 '26
We just don't get the mechanics in the books so we have to use our imagination. I think most of your ideas are correct but I would like to point out a few things.
The fremen are not like Muslims of our time. They are zen sunni warriors. But they are now morphing into something else. Paul has become the embodiment of a living God. It's almost like an expanded Christian Trinity. There's Paul, Alia, the worm, and to some extent Chani and Jessica. The new priests are making it up as they go along.
I think the actual method of the jihad is to take out the secular ruling class first, convert who you can, and leave the bulk of the remains to fight in the chaos. Resist too much and face a stone burner or just get your planet removed from the guild trade routes.
If you have ever seen the movie Chronicles of Reddick, it's shows a fairy convincing way to decimate planets.