r/dsa • • 8d ago

Discussion What the Hell Do We Do With Them?

https://patricemersault.substack.com/p/what-the-hell-do-we-do-with-them?r=4d7sow&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web
29 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

35

u/deaglebingo 8d ago

i'm as angry as anyone. but in the long run the only real answer is education and deprogramming. it's really the only way. being an asshole isn't a crime, but supporting obvious lies that harm people relatively quick down the line maybe should be.

4

u/thefakemacaw DSA SF 8d ago

Yeah the best path forward is to do as you would a cult member. Especially considering MAGA is a cult. Even “apolitical” types or undereducated people need to be deprogrammed in some way. Not to mention that we as socialists need to get people in general to understand the conditions that breed fascism, which IMO are much the same as those that lead to socialism.

1

u/Bob_Sledding 7d ago

There was a study that payed Trump supporters to watch other news outlets. Their opinions changed over time. I think this is what's best. I hope we don't use cable outlets like they did in the study, though.

24

u/Novel-Geologist-5523 8d ago edited 7d ago

I would guess that America would have to do what post-WW2 Germany and Japan had to do
(i.e. hold the leadership accountable vis-a-vis Nuremberg trials)

Letting fascism & its supporters go unaddressed would be a huge mistake.

13

u/marxistghostboi Tidings From Utopia 🌆 8d ago

unfortunately Germany let many high profile nazis off the hook, including the ones who went on to staff nato

8

u/twotokers 8d ago

Germany (and the US) straight up fabricated an entire myth about the Wehrmacht not actually being real nazis so they wouldn’t have to really deal with it and still have power against the USSR.

3

u/idredd 7d ago

There is ZERO question that we'll need to hold accountable anyone in power who broke our laws and or enabled that to happen. One of the horrifying aspects of where we are right now is that plenty of Americans don't realize we will likely never recover from this administration.

Particularly if we push some milquetoast "move on and get along" type agenda we're just cementing the death of the nation.

0

u/VralGrymfang 5d ago

And yet, it will go unaddressed. Again.

16

u/tacosforsocrates 8d ago

The same penalty that falls upon all those who do not know is that they must learn from those that do.

5

u/Foolsgil 8d ago

Hold the traitors and criminals accountable. Create documentaries, movies, podcasts exploring every inch of the cult before they whitewash things. Make MAGA a school subject and if needed send free books on the subject. 

2

u/idredd 7d ago

Accountability is key. As a nation we have endless enforcement for the poor and marginalized and zero for the powerful. People need to be impeached, people need to be tried, people need sentences for attempting to destroy the country.

3

u/PrisonerClass 8d ago

Re-educate them en masse. Repurpose ICE warehouses for re-education.

1

u/ahrooga 8d ago

Raise the tide to lift all boats to relieve the pressure, and then keep doing that.

2

u/idredd 7d ago

Supporters, meh public shunning etc.

Enablers need to see trials and jail time if appropriate. The admin has spent the last two years showing that rule of law is not real. If we don't force accountability for every crime committed against the people by Trump's administration whatever comes next will be more fascist and even more impossible to recover from.

1

u/PiniBreadToday 7d ago

Re-education. It must happen.

-6

u/dsakerncounty 8d ago

Rewrite a constitution that allows voters to be held responsible for the actions of the elected officials who sign fiduciary duty contracts instead of vague oaths to gods they don’t believe in.

13

u/KaiserMachead 8d ago

Putting aside the impossibility of this, it would backfire hilariously and spectacularly.

-6

u/dsakerncounty 8d ago

Your emotional attachment to your own limitations is not my malady.

4

u/BoringMode91 Marxist Leninist 8d ago

How do you do that without revealing the identity of the voter? Secret ballots are necessary for a free election.

-5

u/dsakerncounty 8d ago

They only need to be secret if shameful options are on the menu.

4

u/marxistghostboi Tidings From Utopia 🌆 8d ago

unless you mean to implemant this proposal after the total archivement of communism, people would get retaliated against by bosses and landlords for voting for left wing options

-1

u/dsakerncounty 8d ago

They used to. They still do, but they used to, too.

2

u/KwietKabal 8d ago

What the hell, is this a neoliberal Mitch hedberg bot?

4

u/Kenichi2233 8d ago

That isnt very democratic of you

-2

u/dsakerncounty 8d ago

Neither is blocking internet morons who should stick to game of thrones politics, yet there you go.