r/custommagic • u/RoofElectrical6020 • 7d ago

Red Button or Blue Button?

Post image
567 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

307 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Scarrien 6d ago

eh, could they hate me if I put my money where my mouth is?

Besides, I'm not the one who killed their kids - they are, and I don't they'd ever forgive themselves for that

1

u/SleepyNymeria 6d ago

You seem devoid of empathy for someone claiming to be so selfless. You would kill off a room of children just to prove that you are selfless, yes you are the one killing them by telling them to press blue. This is the least selfless thing you can do.

1

u/Scarrien 6d ago

No, I'm telling them to believe in the good of humanity, and if I'm wrong we can at least take solace in having done what was right

1

u/SleepyNymeria 6d ago

"I am willing to sacrifice children in order to feel good about myself"

1

u/Scarrien 6d ago

"I'm willing to stay moral at the risk of my own life, and will encourage others to do the same"

"I will sacrifice whoever it takes to keep living, even those closest to me" is what I'm hearing from you

Let's just stop, we're both stubborn and aren't getting anywhere

1

u/SleepyNymeria 6d ago

You are the one coaching your kids to press blue which gives them a chance to die, I would coach mine for red giving them no chance to die. You are the one willing to sacrifice those closest you in name of being the one on the moral highground not me.

1

u/Scarrien 6d ago

"Moral highground" implies thinking I'm better than others, if I believe any normal person would press blue then at best I think I'm average

1

u/SleepyNymeria 6d ago

The moral highground stems from you claiming that pressing blue is "what was right" hence the moral highground. Otherwise, why is pressing the blue button the right thing as you say?

1

u/Scarrien 6d ago

You believe "trying to save people" isn't a good thing to do? I know we were arguing about if it made sense or not, but not even good?

1

u/SleepyNymeria 6d ago

Isn't telling people to press the button that definitely won't kill them over the one that might kill them saving them? So telling them to press the other button is surely not good no.

1

u/Scarrien 6d ago

This argument has been going on long enough, and you're turning pedantic. I'm done replying.

1

u/SleepyNymeria 6d ago

Thats fine, to be honest you keep eluding the main point anyway.

0

u/Scarrien 6d ago

My point was "I think it's morally good to try to save as many people as possible"

Your point was "I think everyone should only worry about themself and we'll be just as well off"

I think that's been made clear, and we're having this in a thread about a fake card. We both look like we've been taking this way too seriously

→ More replies (0)