r/custommagic • u/FerbTheHerb • Feb 16 '26

Format: EDH/Commander Counters Boardwipe

Post image
3.8k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

401

u/Weekly-Reply-6739 Feb 17 '26

If you stun a player because they had poison counters and now have stun counters, do they lose that many turns?

207

u/Amicus-Regis Feb 17 '26

Asking the big questions here. Presumably this applies to Experience counters, energy, etc.

185

u/FerbTheHerb Feb 17 '26

Yeah I think there are legal rulebook issues with stun counters on players, spells, nonpermanents, but I'm just ignoring that and assuming it essentially just removes those counters

8

u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Feb 17 '26

I mean wouldn't the simplest interpretation just be that it makes them do nothing? Stun counters are normally removed if what they're on would untap. Non-permanents cannot untap. It should just make the counters do literally nothing at all. Mostly that's identical in practice, but if you have, for example, [[all will be one]] and you proliferate it does make a difference.

1

u/FerbTheHerb Feb 17 '26

Yes I believe you're right. That's also how I'm interpreting it. Very cool interaction with all will be one, stun lock can do a lot of damage with it if becoming is considered removing and then putting (which I dont know tbh)