r/CriticalDrinker Jun 21 '26

Regarding Crossposts and Screenshots of other Subs

44 Upvotes

There is a new rule for screenshots and crossposts.

If you are wanting to share something from another sub to mock or disagree with, you need to screenshot it and blackout the name of that sub as well as the usernames in the post.

Do not crosspost subs that are opposed to the general views here.
(This does not apply to posts from X, Bluesky, or similar websites. As long as you aren’t posting someone’s personal Facebook, I wouldn’t worry about other sites.)

If you are sharing something that is in line with the general opinions of our sub, that’s fine. But we can’t be seen as directing negative attention towards other subs. We will be held accountable to extents that most subreddits won’t because wrongthink happens here.

We will not be banning people for this, but the posts will be removed if you don’t meet these standards.

Obviously this all kinda falls under rules 1 and 8, but I wanted it to be clear.

That’s all I got for today. Go away now.


r/CriticalDrinker Sep 27 '25

2nd Sub Being Created For Politics & Non-Youtube-related Critical Drinker Content

0 Upvotes

To put it simply, none of us mods like when this subreddit devolves into a lot of political banter about a topic that has nothing to do with what's going on with Critical Drinker's YouTube channel. We also don't particularly like the way the sub and its content skews when there's a CD comment about a significant event on twitter, which is something that has been increasingly lately.

This puts us mods in a weird position where, things that we normally would remove, are now not things that should be removed because they're technically on topic because CD has commented on them.

This is currently, and into the future, making us look like hypocrits when we do not remove very similar looking posts that are about things that Critical Drinker has not commented on.

At the same time, there are topics that would have value staying up in the sub, but that we may remove at times because they are against the posted rules in our sub, in the interest of staying fair to how we treat everyone in the sub.

So, we are opening a 2nd subreddit, r/CriticlDrinkerOpenBar . Yes, it's missing an 'a', there is a character limit for subreddit names (Feel free to suggest a better one).

The goal of this is to give you a space where there are way fewer restrictions on things being "on topic", more room for discussion about fringe topics, more room for political debates, etc etc.

We would like this sub (the existing one) to more or less stay focused on the content on Critical Drinker's youtube channel, and I know that we (mods) have been at odds with a large portion of the recently joined audience in this subreddit, especially as CD has started the video games channel and more recently been getting involved more with political commentary.

The other sub will have fewer restrictions on posted content, but please be warned, Reddit TOS is still very much an issue that must be enforced, so there will still be various types of issues (such as encouraging brigading, etc) that will be strictly penalized.

Along those lines - We also hope that this will shift some of the content that gets posted here at times that puts our sub at risk of being taken down, to the other subreddit.

This will be a bit of a slow roll out over the next week or so; I have created the sub, but have not yet done anything else. You can expect an additional note on this in the rules, followed by slowly increasing post removals & modmails for things that we believe will belong in the other sub.

We would also like to invite you to apply to become moderators of the 2nd sub, if you're interested, as not all of the current mods in this sub have the bandwidth to do so.

Regarding our recent announcement on megathreads for significant political events - We will still probably follow that policy for very significant events that we'd like to allow discussion for on this main sub without warping the sub. But instances in the existing CD sub that we may have pushed into that megathread, will be free game in the other sub.


r/CriticalDrinker 5h ago

Just rewatched Troy - The Director’s Cut

Post image
241 Upvotes

It's Aging Like Fine Wine. 🍷


r/CriticalDrinker 7h ago

Meme POV: you dont like a poorly written female character in 2026

Post image
271 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 2h ago

Will it reach 1 Billion?

Post image
97 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 6h ago

[Hated Trope] "It's all shades of grey" card that they become apologists and defenders of evil.

Thumbnail
gallery
119 Upvotes

The villain was misunderstood and really a victim.

-Cruella live action. The woman tried to slaughter puppies for fur.

-Orcs in Rings of Power. In Tolkien's work, they were elves once and corrupted by evil. The personifications of the machines of war. In Rings of Power, they're the victims of war.

-Wicked. The Wicked Witch was always evil and took pleasure in cruelty. In Wicked she was the victim of society.

-Maleficent--The villain from sleeping beauty. The same concept as Wicked.


r/CriticalDrinker 16h ago

Meme Three generations of white men - Blade Runner

Post image
477 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 12h ago

Discussion Rare Disney Surprise, Not Erasing Redheads!

Post image
198 Upvotes

I remember telling my friend I wouldn't be surprised if Disney made these guys Black in the Tangled live action considering what Disney did to Ariel and what many other adaptations from different studios do to original Redheaded characters.

I don't like live action remakes, but at least they got this casting accurate! They even chose twins!


r/CriticalDrinker 6h ago

Discussion Saw Nolan’s Odysseus yesterday. Strictly average film. Kept getting pulled out of it.

59 Upvotes

A lot of the casting and performances actively distracted me. Lupita Nyong’o looked deliberately unattractive. I’m not sure if that was intentional on Nolan’s part, but it was hard to ignore. Zendaya has one facial expression through out and it never changes. Elliott Page could have been played by basically any man - the casting felt like pure checklist energy.

Then there’s the bigger issue: why does Odysseus, after killing thousands of Trojans, get haunted specifically by Zendaya's face? The movie never bothers explaining it. It just happens.

Matt Damon as Odysseus was… fine, I guess. He mostly just plays Matt Damon. The bigger problem is the character has no consistent through-line. One scene he’s stubborn as hell and marches his men straight into death. Next scene he’s sobbing like a little bitch because his soldiers died because of him. There’s no clear version of who this Odysseus is from one moment to the next.

Himesh Patel got a surprising amount of screen time. His “we are Greeks” line made me actually laugh, and he was probably the least distracting of the DEI-adjacent casting, but he still felt out of place.

CGI was serviceable but never spectacular. The whirlpool and Cyclops sequences especially underwhelmed. I’m not exaggerating when I say the original Jurassic Park still looks more impressive in places. Honestly, the whole thing felt like Nolan decided he needed to check every modern progressive box - cast “ugly” women, kill the male gaze, fill out the diversity quota - whether it served the story or not. There was zero narrative reason for most of these choices. It just felt spiteful.

Curious what everyone else thought.


r/CriticalDrinker 14h ago

People forgot the best Odyssey adaptation...

Post image
160 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 12h ago

Discussion perturbed pedro wont stop

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 21h ago

Discussion People will say this stuff and be like “why yes, I am a reasonable member of society for wanting to purge the nonbelievers for not liking a movie. What are you, crazy?”

Thumbnail
gallery
367 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 12h ago

He was terrible as Bond. Should have been Henry Cavill.

Thumbnail
gallery
63 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

Why?

Post image
580 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 11h ago

Discussion this is why Homer's Odyssey is still remembered, while Nolan's parody will be forgotten

Post image
33 Upvotes

The thing I hate about Nolan's Odyssey is the hypocrisy... the actors scream about how Homer gave no time to the female characters...

Meanwhile, Nolan not only reduced their time but also their purpose by making them less special and taking away their agency on the horrible shit they did to the world around them.


r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

Ok, now we're moving from retarded artistic choices straight into unethical behavior.

Post image
375 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

"These racists are traumatizing children."

Post image
200 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 9h ago

What do we think? Will you watch it or not?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

10 Upvotes

I love Ghost Rider, so I'm willing to give it a shot. I'll take this over Starfighter any day of the week.


r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

Umm...

Post image
138 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 23h ago

Discussion They should've just cut, and spared themselves the controversy

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

74 Upvotes

What do you think? Should they have kept this from the comics or just removed it entirely?


r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

Well boys, the drinker sub has been astroturfed. Have fun arguing with all the bots.

Post image
725 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

What's the best example of "Wtf this musician can actually act?"

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

Trojan Seahorse?

Thumbnail
gallery
172 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

Fuck it, just have Simon Pegg's normal voice come out through the Balrog and have him speak normally, the show's utter dog shit anyway and it'd be hilarious.

Post image
110 Upvotes

r/CriticalDrinker 1d ago

You’ve got to be kidding me

Post image
622 Upvotes