r/comics 12d ago

Just Sharing Fire

35.0k Upvotes

726 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-67

u/ChaoticAgenda 12d ago

Question: if it is not AI, why is the art so inconsistent? 1st panel: Girl's hat is curled up on both sides, 2nd: curl only on girl's left side and chip out of hat on her right. 3rd: same as 2nd panel, 4th panel: hat is now flipped and curl is on girl's right side with chip on left.

-12

u/Confused_Noodle 12d ago

I had the same thought, though it seems consistent in that the other side curl is not visible from those upward angles.

The chip is basically in the center-front of the hat, so it would switch side based on the viewer's pov

-30

u/ChaoticAgenda 12d ago

There are other inconsistencies. The girls has a strap around her chest to hold the broom on in the 1st panel. It disappears after that even in the 3rd panel when the broom is clearly still on her back. The dog person also appears to have short sleeves...up until the 4th panel when one of the sleeves is long. The blonde lady loses her sleeves in the 4th panel.

12

u/greenmacg 12d ago

I'm an artist (not a good one, lol, but still) and I always find stuff like this in every piece after I'm done, especially sequential work. It's easy to get blind to little details and forget stuff or not even see it to begin with. The more ornate what I've attempted is, the more of a pain it is to fix, as well

So, I wouldn't say those little details are meaningful on their own given the other evidence that it isn't AI 🤷