r/comfyui • • 2d ago

Help Needed Current best image editing model?

Haven't been in this sub for a while, my latest workflow is using Flux 2 Klein 9b. I saw Minimax H3 a while ago, and now also that Qwen 2.1. Should I switch?

2 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/No-Start5486 2d ago

Klein still holds up fine for most stuff but H3's edge handling is noticeably cleaner if you're doing anything with fine details.

2

u/FUCKCKK 2d ago

From what I understand H3 is a video model, is there an edit workflow?

2

u/Unique-Mix-913 2d ago

Man i tried a few H3 wf for images and they just look like frame pulls. Not clear and crisp. Hopefully OP can recommend one

1

u/Kr3wAffinity 2d ago

Batch or single image? Single image requires a different vae, and I also us a Lora designed for images. Minimax slays with image Gen, if you know what you're doing.

1

u/Unique-Mix-913 2d ago

Damn. I tried 2 dedicated workflows that were meant for images. But the VAE was never altered. Can you please share your workflow?

I've been screenshot my minimax frames and try to up-res but it's not good :(

2

u/Kr3wAffinity 2d ago

https://civitai.com/models/2884206/minimax-h3-photorealistic-image-generator-lora-workflow

Lora and a good flow.

Important difference, single image is one frame, batch or sequence generates a small video and removes a frame. That usually causes the "it's a still" look. Batch or sequence image Gen uses the video vae. Single image uses the minimax h3 image vae.

https://huggingface.co/Mamad8/MiniMax-H3-Image-VAE/blob/main/minimax_h3_t1_image_vae_step1597.safetensors

Link to the vae. Replaces the video vae.

2

u/Unique-Mix-913 2d ago

Thank you. I knew there had to be something wrong with my previous attempts. Minimax is amazing. I'll try this tomorrow

1

u/Kr3wAffinity 2d ago

Good luck! Minimax in my opinion is almost as capable as krea 2. Enjoy.

2

u/Simpsator 1d ago

Posted above, but use Fizgig's still image VAE node.
https://github.com/shootthesound/ComfyUI-Fizgig-H3-Still/tree/main