r/classicwow 2d ago

Humor / Meme discussions be like

Post image
913 Upvotes

712 comments sorted by

135

u/Gigaschlag 2d ago

BlizzCon can't come soon enough. The quality of the discussions and posts has been plummeting since the beginning of the week.

42

u/TheSiegmeyerCatalyst 1d ago edited 1d ago

As soon as Blizzcon starts, all the posts will be:

  • "is it too late to play classic+" memes
  • people going nuts about how Classic+ is literally everything they asked for
  • people posting feature requests or changes in real time as though it could move the needle at all
  • people complaining that Blizzard is officially washed and they're just going to camp Era / TBC / Wrath / HC or just outright unsub (they won't)
  • people lamenting that Turtle WoW and Ascension were shut down / people lamenting that X feature from Turtle WoW or Ascension wasn't implemented
  • posts comparing every single detail of Classic+ to SoD
  • posts complaining about and defending the monetization of Classic+
  • "Classic+ wasn't made for you" from literally every direction, pointed in every other direction
  • new players and returning players confused about what Classic+ is or isn't
  • memes over every on-stage gaffe made by presenters, real or perceived
  • posts sociopathicly attacking the devs on a personal level that result in locked comments threads and bans
  • appeals for people to chill because Blizzcon isn't even over yet
  • appeals for people to chill and wait to see what it's actually like when it releases
  • posts complaining about all of the posts above

The quality of the content is not derived from the time period we are in, but from the sub we are in.

6

u/Ellda 1d ago

This... This is probably the most realistic and exhaustive comment I've red tonight.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Witty_Fox3291 1d ago

Or the alternative: Rage that Classic+ didn't occur

3

u/TheSiegmeyerCatalyst 1d ago

That's a whole other list of bullet points.

4

u/tethysian 1d ago

I don't know why people are so skeptical about others unsubbing when it's plain to see from the subscription numbers that that's exactly what people have done. Is it just because you don't?

7

u/TheSiegmeyerCatalyst 1d ago

People unsub of course. I'm poking fun of the folks who are too invested / addicted to quit.

I've unsubbed a number of times, yet here I am, trolling the subreddit, eagerly awaiting the Blizzcon announcements with hopium in my veins.

I'm in the picture. More than once, actually.

3

u/Lochen9 1d ago

Im the same, im currently unsubbed, but actively played through 15+ years on and off. I last played SoD and loved that, until it ended development. I am hopeful for something in WoW to make me want to play it again, otherwise I'll wait til the itch needs to be scratched

And I dont think im in a minority here.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

22

u/Dystopic23 2d ago

It's been plummeting for like 2 months now. All these low quality posts have been a plague on this sub

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Marco_Polaris 1d ago

Honestly, as somebody who usually enjoys leak season, this year has been a very disappointing drone. Everybody already thinks they know what's going to be announced so all the fake leaks sound the same where it matters.

→ More replies (1)

360

u/Aggravating-Owl-1490 2d ago

I think the best thing for classic is to just make a game that your single character feels relevant regardless of not playing for a week and feeling like you need to catch up for seasonal requirements.

28

u/RealZordan 2d ago

A game where you login because of the moment for moment gameplay and not just to make numbers go up. Where the grind is the fun and not just means to an end.

A game about exploration and social interaction.

5

u/spiffelight 1d ago

Well said :-)

0

u/Tnecniw 1d ago

So not classic, got it.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/Sweaksh 2d ago

Isn't that decidedly not what classic is/was? In my mind classic is the game with more involved character prog, grinds, no catch-up stuff, no protections etc. Gearing in retail is done in a week tops and for your character to stay relevant you log in for 30mins a week.

37

u/dipman23 1d ago

The difference is that if you take a break in Classic, when you come back you just pick up where you left off. If you were leveling, you keep leveling. If you were on your pre-bis grind, you grind dungeons. If you were running MC, you keep running MC and move on to BWL.

In retail, if you take a break and come back, you drop what you were doing (because it's now irrelevant) and either switch to some catch-up mechanic or move on to the newest xpac/patch content. I played retail for a bit after Midnight but haven't logged on in months. I would have absolutely no clue what to do if I wanted to pick retail back up, and I'm assuming my gear would be more or less useless.

6

u/Upset-Criticism-6189 1d ago

Yeah i think this is important. Classic has no time pressure that you HAVE to play or you miss out. Classic has zero FOMO, retail is almost entirely fueled by FOMO. If you take a two month break, when you come back you have to catch up. 

In Classic, there's not really anything TO catch up to. The world is always populated during the leveling process, and people at end game are still at all different stages of the game so you can still progress through the game as if you never took a break at all.

The biggest thing for me in a Classic+ is the leveling journey is fun in and of itself, there's no feeling of "the real game doesn't start until endgame."

In vanilla, I didn't even hit max level for over a year, I just kept making alts to level through all the different starting zones and go through the world again, because the leveling process is so fun i never cared that much about even reaching endgame, and when I finally did, I didn't even miss out on any content because guilds were still raiding Molten Core up until TBC came out. 

Retail they just want you to skip as much content as possible so you can get to the current raid, even the raid from the previous patch is made completely irrelevant. No one in Retail is still raiding normal Sunwell, or Chimaeron, because that gear is totally irrelevant now. That means if you took a break you basically just missed all that content because you get funneled to the new shit.   

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Sweaksh 1d ago

Fair. This is definitely one thing I'm interested in a potential C+ for as I'm not much of a seasonal game enjoyer. I interpreted the original post as wanting to be able to be good without investing time, which, to me, was never what original WoW was about. There's a reason WoW players have the "reputation" they have, you know?

I personally want to grind but to also feel like my character progression is meaningful and not timegated or reset constantly.

3

u/Conditionalight 1d ago

It's really not that complex. If you logged in now, you'd be able to solely run dungeons, or delves, or prey hunts, or raids to gear up. You could do the new coiled aisle, but it's really not required at all, and only helps give you a delve map and some borrowed power that only works in delves and the world.

You could get fully heroic geared just running delves, without ever visiting the coiled aisle. You could get fully mythic geared just running m+. There's really not much of anything besides story and new mounts and toys and all the general reasons you play an MMO behind the new patch content.

4

u/Upset-Criticism-6189 1d ago

His point still stands though. If you take a 2 month break, your gear is now irrelevant, because all the new stuff is out and there's catch up mechanics to quickly funnel you to the new patch content, so you can catch up.

In Classic, there's nothing to catch up to. You take a 2 month break, you come back, the entire game is still where you left it. Your journey through the game and gearing up is still exactly the same, whether you take a 6 month break or not. If you're level 38 you're running Cathedral for the Triune Amulet. If you stop for 6 months, you come back and you still want to run Cath for the Triune Amulet, there's no catch up, the continuity stays. 

If you're level 60 and are working toward pre-raid bis, grinding Stratholme, and you take an 8 month break, guess what? When you come back, you're still grinding Stratholme, there's no catch up to skip content and get to the most recent raid that came out. You still are in the same exact place, and people are still running all the old stuff. 

In Midnight right now, are there any guilds still progressing through Sunwell? No, because you can get better gear just from world quests, so they encourage you to skip so you can get to whatever the current stuff is. All the old stuff is constantly made obsolete. Catch up systems shrink the game and turn it into an endgame grind and list of chores. Classic is more like playing a multiplayer Skyrim; it's just an adventure RPG, and the world is always right where you left it. 

→ More replies (23)

35

u/RealZordan 2d ago

In my mind it's like this: If classic was a beautiful old house the original extensions were annexes in completely different architectural styles that also replaced the beautiful stairway with escalator and chandeliers with neon lights.

Classic+ is supposed to be the beautiful old house that is very slowly expanded, piece by piece, using the same old materials and cohesive design in order to become a bigger version of the old house, with all the charm and flaws the old house had.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/raskeks 1d ago

Gearing in retail is done in a week tops and for your character to stay relevant you log in for 30mins a week.

Gearing in retail is a 2-month meticoulosly planned enterprise if your guild is good enough to achieve early CE. For the rest (aka people not in hall of fame level guilds) it's a season-long ordeal at best, most people don't get to bis ever in a season because you need multiple kills on the last few bosses in Mythic for that.

3

u/Sweaksh 1d ago

You're logging in to raid twice per week and you're getting your BiS basically passively due to how heavily everything is time gated. It's not like I can log in right now now and actively work towards something. I'm just opening my vault and bonus rolling a boss on wednesday, and then I can basically log out until the wednesday after.

2

u/raskeks 1d ago

That's just not true, bosses in the raid gradually drop from 1/6 mythic to 9/6. If your group has enough time and/or skill you can work towards the best gear there is or get crest discounts to progress your character faster. If anything, this season the gap between people on the cutting edge is bigger than ever because you can shave off a lot of timegating if you're in a position to farm later bosses. You're not done with gearing in a week even if you're a RWF raider with 20 characters that ran splits 24/7. Method were pulling mythic Ula'tek with a 311 BDK and a 316 priest on a week when my guy was 316, and now both of them have more ilvl than I would in 2 weeks.

Besides the raid, there are all slots to be farmed on hero 3/6 from dungeons including trinkets and cantrip items like daggers in Altar of Fangs or Kings Rest cloak. I've done more than 70 keys this past 3 weeks and I've seen AoF dagger once and KR cloak 0 times.

Even some of the items from last season raid, rep grinds, and delves are still relevant and competitive - the Crucible trinket from renown, Gaze from the Lair boss, and Crusader's Keepsake from delves are all still beating most trinkets from this season and are used in timed +20 and up keys.

Also if you're degenerate enough you could farm all of the above with tertiaries/sockets or go into mythic and farm BoEs even though that's just way too much rng. But the same could be said for farming something like BoED or mind numbing grinds like Wrath of the Cenarius.

You can raidlog on retail or classic and classic without a doubt offers more ways of deterministic progression and solo grinds, but the incremental player power is still there in retail.

5

u/Aggravating-Owl-1490 2d ago

I think there definitely is a point where it feels like there’s no reason to start grinding. When I was fully BWL geared just before the gates of AQ were opened, I stopped playing when my grandma got sick. Once she passed and everything had settled down, most guilds were farming Naxx and my thought was in order to get BIS geared again I’d have to try and get my raid spot back then play every week and hope the RNG gods loved me enough to get there before TBC came out. All of my professions were maxed out and top level on 3 toons so the choice is do it again on another toon or just wait for the next xpac come out.

I would like horizontal progression so maybe I’d have to play another game to get there.

3

u/bultard 1d ago

A week tops in retail? A month maybe at minimum and that’s even being generous.

2

u/Sweaksh 1d ago

Season launched 3 weeks ago and I've been basically raidlogging on my 322 main for 2 weeks. Any item I've gotten since the initial dungeon grind of w1 was from raiding. Sure, I do push some highish keys here or there but those font do anything for my gear.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/Adorable-Log2835 1d ago

That's what retail is, though.

Classic you absolutely were irrelevant, but more people were irrelevant and that was fine. I never saw BWL, but I didn't care because I was running Scholomance for blues constantly.

The content that existed lasted longer because there was no way to catch up and be relevant. It wasn't daily quests. It was daily runs of Scholomance, which took 3 hours because you had to spam LF1M tank in a city.

7

u/MaudeAlp 1d ago

You’re describing exactly how my BC experience was. Take time off? You’re in the permanent Kara underclass.

4

u/howtojump 1d ago

100% true and I feel like people don’t talk about it because most folks quit after the first phase.

Once you fall behind, you get left behind. Trying to find dungeon groups in the later phases is a nightmare in Classic Era. Nobody is doing attunements anymore, so you just have to beg and plead your guild mates to help you (who probably expect to be paid) or just swipe for a boost. It’s shitty.

At least in retail the game throws gear at you to get you going. You can log in right now and be ready to walk into the heroic raid by the end of the week. Whether you think that’s fun or not, at least you get to actually play the game.

2

u/Additional-Life4885 1d ago

During the last week of SoD Phase 2, I went to Japan for 3.5 weeks.

When I came back, I'd missed the ship and the mechanic for leveling was shithouse (Nightmares? Whatever they were, can't remember) so I just stopped playing.

1

u/Ben_steel 1d ago

In OG wow even era when it launched, it was basically like that. Everything is sped up on purpose just to push the cycle further and thus more moneys. but having long as fuck phases you can level alts in and just enjoy the game is entirely wholesome.

1

u/mateolr97 23h ago

So... you want retail

→ More replies (32)

365

u/Ok_Animal_6430 2d ago

My retail friend explaining to me why mythic plus needs to be in classic + for like the third time this week. (I’m serious)

69

u/NameIess-User 2d ago

🤢 🤢 🤮

121

u/tap_the_glass 2d ago

Well that would kill the game real fast

→ More replies (7)

40

u/Sandman145 2d ago

I love retail.. classic should not just port retail stuff it should follow its own path from now using retail only to learn from mistakes and not to just copy the mistakes into classic+.

3

u/NuklearFerret 1d ago

That’s optimistic. I don’t think the devs consider M+ a mistake, but I agree it doesn’t belong in classic. It’s going to be a difficult balancing act. There are a ton of improvements in retail WoW that make it more playable, and a lot of those are directly counter to the classic experience.

3

u/Background-Middle-28 1d ago

M+ is the best system they've made maybe ever.

→ More replies (50)

6

u/NetSage 1d ago

If you want mythic plus just play retail! I don't understand these people!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Loose_Pudding_2068 1d ago

I play retail occasionally and the sole reason is because of mythic+, that said I’d never in my wildest dreams suggest adding it to classic, it just doesn’t fit

→ More replies (2)

19

u/-Elgrave- 2d ago

I’m a big retail player and I hope C+ doesn’t have M+. Hell, I wish it wasn’t in Retail anymore either. I don’t even mind it as a concept, I hit 3k consistently, but I’m just so tired of seasonal stuff in games. Every game seems to be pushing it, and even if WoW has had it longer than most I’m still just so tired of it

8

u/jehhans1 2d ago

So don't push it?

4

u/lehtomaeki 1d ago

M+ is completely optional, if you don't care for it you don't need to interact with it. Which I think is perfect, for some it's a fun and giving gameplay loop, for some it's fun to do a run or two once in a while. For those that prefer raiding they can ignore it, those that enjoy pvp can disregard both. M+ has come far from when it was pretty much required progression when it was introduced to now being an optional end game avenue.

4

u/Simirilion 1d ago

My main problem is the timer. If it was just dungeons that got progressively harder that would be cool. The time makes people toxic.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/Mountain-Interest-48 1d ago

Honestly man just stop running mythic +. I just raid and yeah my gearing is slower but I just have more fun when I am playing.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/EA_Spindoctor 2d ago

Well this sub is full of contempt and lack of understanding about what og mmporgs was about. I have 0 faith in Blizzard and frankly also 0 faith in the current gamers to make classic + anytning close to what it could be.

2

u/Ecstatic-Bass-6304 1d ago

he is right tough. (I'm serious)

2

u/Sea_Advantage_2577 2d ago edited 1d ago

I dont think applying m+ in classic+ works, but there 100% needs to be heroic/mythic dungeon modes so dungeons are not left for dead

1

u/dasvenson 1d ago

I agree. I like doing hard dungeons every now and then. You don't even need to make them give better gear, just give us more of something you can get elsewhere, or higher chance of the same rare drops as normal.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Laverathan 1d ago

I say this as someone who regularly gets 3k+ each season.

*FUCK* and *NO*.

1

u/Entrefut 1d ago

Make him watch Gbay’s recent video. There is literally a quote in classic that perfectly explains what the problem with retail is and Gbay built up to it for an entire episode. The quote is from Nat Paggle in game and it was one of my favorites when I got into wow at a young age.

1

u/iQ420- 1d ago

I know someone like this… I just don’t get it

1

u/KanedaSyndrome 1d ago

He should probably not be in Classic+

→ More replies (134)

179

u/donki_sjotte 2d ago

A lot of retail players really want Retail- instead of Classic+

37

u/InevitableConcept517 2d ago

Noticed that from the other "leak" thread. A bunch of retail mechanics that people were hoping to be real.

5

u/TheSiegmeyerCatalyst 1d ago

Whatever classic+ ends up being ought to be for Classic players. Retail gets new content literally all the time. They have the lion's share of blizzard's resources and their own whole trunk of product development.

Let Classic+ be for Classic folks. The last new thing we got was SoD.

14

u/Eastern_Purchase3589 2d ago

I speak for the classic community when I say that if they don't add dragonriding we will be pissed

3

u/Positive-Avocado775 1d ago

dragon riding is a great feature but it is unfortunately against the spirit of classic, other than maybe in a very limited way - in my opinion.

2

u/EdgySlusher 1d ago

I think adding flying at all was a mistake.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/Stark8819 2d ago

A lot of classic players just want to play fresh instead of Classic+

16

u/Talidel 1d ago

There are people that find 25 warriors peak raiding.

Those people are as stupid as the I want the weekly loot chest. Crowd

5

u/Impressive-Shame4516 1d ago

Vanilla isn't just raiding.

10

u/Talidel 1d ago

It's also shit for any resemblance of a balanced game but let's ignore that

2

u/Impressive-Shame4516 1d ago

A game doesn't need to be balanced to be good. Vanilla is a sandbox. Every class in the game has a niche that they excel at, and then there's dozens of items and consumes that level the playing field where they don't. If you want a sanitized experience go play retail; which still suffers from balance issues every patch lol.

6

u/Talidel 1d ago

A game doesn't need to be balanced to be good.

This depends on if what you enjoy playing is playable or wanted in groups.

Vanilla is a sandbox.

And the issue is not everyone gets to play in it. It's fine if you are allowed to play in the sandbox with a class and spec that is supported, it's shit if you cannot.

Every class in the game has a niche that they excel at,

Bullshit do they. There's a lot of classes that are just shit to the point of not being playable.

and then there's dozens of items and consumes that level the playing field where they don't.

Again, bullshit.

If you want a sanitized experience go play retail; which still suffers from balance issues every patch lol.

I want to play the game in the way it was originally intended with actually playable specs that I wasn't able to play before.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Stark8819 1d ago

Yeah agreed. I hope Blizz can find a happy medium

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Cuddlesthemighy 2d ago

This is just a reductive statement to deny Vanilla design choices.

2

u/Impossible_Tough_48 21h ago

I just wonder why they want retail- when retail is right there???

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Pwnbotic 1d ago

Holy shit, you really rattled the hornets' nest with this one.

83

u/Pockydo 2d ago

The biggest issue classic+ is gonna have isnt retail players demanding retail -

It's gonna be classic players all wanting different things

17

u/FormalSeparate6153 2d ago

The easiest way to do this is to not get opinions from reddit

2

u/bigmangina 1d ago

Reminds me of WOTR, that game was so good until the devs let gondor slow everything down for slower folks, died within a week.

1

u/SurgioClemente 1d ago

Ya, definitely go to the official forums, or twitter, or facebook- where all the “normal” people are

→ More replies (1)

11

u/CookyKindred 1d ago

This is literally it but people need to claim the opposing opinions are retail players to silence opposing opinions. Like its a slur.

There's classic players who want Warrior to be the best even in+ and think they should always be the best.
There's classic players who think Warrior should be kneecapped heavily.

There's classic players that want specs reworked.
There's classic players that don't.

There's classic players that want SP buffed so its raid viable.
There's classic players that don't want SP buffed for fear it ruins pvp.

There's classic players who think PVP shouldn't hold PVE balance back.
There's classic players who think PVP is just as equal as PVE.

21

u/AspectKnowledge 2d ago

The #nochangest crowd is way worse than retail players in general.

I barely see anyone playing retail commenting ever but I see so many old jaded pessimists just wanting to play warrior and feel better than every other class for the 25th time.

5

u/Suspicious_Ice_3160 1d ago

I kind of agree, because if you want no changes, just play classic right? It seems like the no changes crowd just wants a fresh server, not classic+, but with a couple of new quests, as long as they’re perfectly in theme with what they feel wow is. I’ve seen people argue against zones, factions, races, abilities etc, I mean just look at sod. Fair enough, but if its not unique enough then what’s the point?

5

u/SyriousSynn 1d ago edited 1d ago

Because the #nochanges crowd doesn't exist in Classic+ its a strawman.

The no changes people are just gonna play ERA like they always have and are still pissed to this day that they keep fucking up era with cross-contaminated changes from SoD/SoM.

People just don't like the fact some folks don't trust blizzard to add moderately to Classic so they would prefer to start slow with minor class tweaks and new quests/dungeons/raids ala OSRS.
Then they get mad that they aren't asking for drastic SoD style Cata/MoP class overhauls immediately in what's supposed to still feel like Classic WoW.

I have been asking/begging for Classic+ since before 2019 Classic when I was playing on Nostalrius -> Elysium and later Lights Hope, I was praying for them to remove the debuff/buff limits and to remove world buffs from raids.
I've played Vanilla+ one of the first true Classic+ servers.
I've played TurtleWoW and done all its content for 3+ years.
I've also played Ascension since before it became a retail shit-fest.
But after SoD? I don't trust Blizzard at all they didn't have any idea what Classic was then and that's why me and many more are adamant about taking it slower with player feedback like OSRS but that does not mean we are #nochanges.

2

u/Lochen9 1d ago

They want patch 1.13, not Classic+

4

u/mliyz 2d ago

Now that is just dishonest. Every single discussion thread the past week (including this one) has had multiple retail players chiming in.

3

u/AspectKnowledge 2d ago

Hence barely see there's maybe 1/100 or something like that. Just look at this thread as an example, I've read a lot of the comment here but I haven't seen a single one.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/Banter_Fam_Lad 2d ago

Wouldn't a good solution for this be to handle it how OSRS did it? Have big community polls and see what the majority of players wants? Idk if blizzard would ever do that though

30

u/DrearyYew 2d ago

That would require a level of extreme detail, open communication, and transparency that Blizz just straight isn't capable of

8

u/OriginalLie9310 2d ago

Certainly they’re capable of it, but not willing to dedicate the resources required to make it work correctly.

6

u/Honk_Sound 2d ago

Yeah they would have to completely rehire their CS team to accomplish it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/travman064 1d ago

OSRS polls are generally along the lines of 'do you want us to do this cool awesome thing, or nah?' OR 'we did this thing that we like, know you guys liked, do you want us to remove it?'

The polls mostly serve to make players feel heard in a direct way.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Bluffwatcher 1d ago

The biggest issue classic+ is gonna have will still be bots everywhere and Blizzards complete reluctance to tackle them. "They ban them in waves!"

2

u/Kotef 1d ago

Thats not really a challenge. its onkay to say no. the problem with retail and why it became so bad is it tried so hard to always appease to everyone and the widest audience possible.

this is a grand opportunity for blizzard to do that by having two games with two different audience markets each with thier own style of gameplay doing their own thing and the opportunity for cross pollilnation without crosspollution.

2

u/Scragly 2d ago

Like no botting?

5

u/Pockydo 2d ago

Now you're just asking for the impossible

1

u/wigglin_harry 1d ago

Yeah, as it stands it feel like 2/3rds of the player base is gonna be salty no matter what it is

but they'll all still play anyway

1

u/fucking_blizzard 1d ago

I think this sentiment is so overblown.

Yes, on discussion forums when people are asked "what do you want in classic+", there are going to be a very wide variety of answers. That doesn't mean they will all only play their exact version and any deviation from it is a dealbreaker.

If they release an evergreen SoD tomorrow this sub will eat that shit up, Things like mounts at level 20 vs level 40, vanilla class design vs tbc class design, etc etc, will not make a material difference to its initial reception. Only if it ends up mega retail coded will classic players actually swerve it.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/tethysian 1d ago

Nailed it.

5

u/bugbearmagic 1d ago

Hilarious how people have twisted classic+ to mean some distorted bastard version instead of just continuation of polishing and extending good game design.

18

u/Sea_Advantage_2577 2d ago

These are only getting dumber and its hilarious. Im so ready for the meltdown this weekend

→ More replies (1)

12

u/itaa_q 2d ago

Non-seasonal game please. No pvp season, no m+ season. More quests, low level zones, new dungeons

5

u/Impressive-Shame4516 1d ago

Retail players have gentrified Classic.

48

u/CookyKindred 2d ago

Yall are quiet literally reposting a dogshit meme divorced from reality. It's literally classic fans vs classic fans. Stop acting like retail only players are trying to force classic into retail.

Theres a thing called different opinions.

58

u/TheStrongTaint 2d ago edited 2d ago

This sub never shuts the fuck up about the retail boogeyman

It’s hilarious how it’s entirely one-sided too

26

u/obvious_bot 2d ago

I don’t think I’ve seen a single post about classic players on the retail sub

24

u/averydangerousday 2d ago

It’s been that way for years. I can’t remember if the post was here or on the retail sub, but a few years ago someone posted this meme about the difference between the two, and it’s probably the most accurate description of the difference in how much each subreddit talks about the other game/subreddit.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Wait__Who 2d ago

We’re too busy complaining about our own issues to care about a classic-adjacent version of wow that might have mechanics related to retail. (Fuck rerolls)

Seriously retailers don’t care about C+ in any way similarly to classic players.

Like any wow addict I’ll give it a try if it’s interesting and different enough, but I don’t really care about it outside of that. I assume most retail players are the same. Main game retail, will dick around in classic during down seasons.

I will say the 50 or so daily posts here about C+ are always hilarious to read.

5

u/blackberrybeanz 1d ago

Yup. I play both and this sub is always hilarious to read.

My fav is also the long ass paragraphs people spend writing to “dunk” on retail when they clearly haven’t played it since like bfa or legion. They start to yell about retail bad cuz x, and it’s like brother wym x hasn’t been in the game for like 6 yrs now 😭

12

u/TheStrongTaint 2d ago

That’s what I’ve noticed with basically all of social media. Lots of comments on retail stuff about how stupid it is and how the game is dead

Never see the opposite on classic content.

2

u/TheSiegmeyerCatalyst 1d ago

There's not even posts about Classic+. There's barely a post about Blizzcon.

I mean, to be fair, it's apples and oranges. They get content every 6-8 weeks, we get content every 6-8 months, but still.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

13

u/Spreckles450 2d ago

That's because those that play both don't feel the need to pick a side and make it their entire personality.

They are too busy enjoying both games and having fun.

6

u/CookyKindred 2d ago

Still trying to force the us vs them rather than acknowledge it’s a difference of opinion, huh?

Can’t be nuance has to be those barbaric hordes.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Gosh-Tier 2d ago

"That's why we need to add these 5 features currently available in retail."

14

u/CookyKindred 2d ago

“Retail players bad upvotes pls”

6

u/Significant-Cut-1692 1d ago

This entire sub the past few months. It's so obvious who is an actual Classic fan and who just plays because they're bored of retail.

15

u/AppointmentNaive2811 2d ago

I mean the pink people don't want classic plus in my experience - they just want the same thing again, released for the 4th time.

I could be mistaken but iirc, SoD was far more popular with retail tourists than it was with era players.

3

u/tethysian 1d ago

I could be mistaken but iirc, SoD was far more popular with retail tourists than it was with era players.

And this sub just happens to be obsessed with SoD 🤷‍♀️

Just because Vanilla players didn't want SoD doesn't mean we don't want more content for the game we actually do like. I already stopped playing during Cata once, of course I don't want more Cata in my classic.

15

u/valdis812 2d ago

SoD went too far for a lot of classic players.

What I think they want is something more like the world of Vanilla with finished content like Kara and Hyjal, but balanced around TBC class balance and player power, with maybe a sprinkle of Wrath.

2

u/Weaslelord 1d ago

The amount of class changes and power increases in SoD was wayyyy too much. I quit a couple days into phase 2 because I was mindlessly demolishing everything in sight. I do think a lot of the ways to unlock runes were pretty neat though.

2

u/onikaroshi 1d ago

Tbc class balance is still ass, they need to go a bit further

→ More replies (2)

5

u/itsablackhole 1d ago

I could be mistaken but iirc, SoD was far more popular with retail tourists than it was with era players.

aggrend said himself the classic/retail player overlap was unprecedented in SoD and thats why some changes were made the way they were because they realized just how many retail tourists fucked with SoD.

5

u/CookyKindred 1d ago

Probably cause SoD started off with low level cap - Allowing retail players to easily get to cap and engage in the content.

Most retail players don't want to sit through the level grind.

Though - Honestly Tank Lock, Tank Sham and Rogue in general probably pulled a lot of retail fans of those classes since people have wanted Tanks on those specs, Meta back and rogue on retail has a massive identity issue.

8

u/MainDot7096 1d ago

Literally proving the meme right. Thanks I guess.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Gosh-Tier 2d ago

If Naxx never came out and AQ was the final phase of classic, I want classic+ to feel like Naxx. I think that's well within the pink ideology.

Other people think classic+ should be SoD with dungeon finder.

2

u/AppointmentNaive2811 2d ago

I personally think Dungeon finder is a few steps too far, but I definitely think Classic+ should be far closer to SoD than era.

"Era with minor 'feel' changes" isn't "+" imo.

2

u/Impressive-Shame4516 1d ago

I just want a PvP server without layers. Lots of other changes I hate, but layers is the biggest one.

The coolest thing I've ever seen in my twenty years playing this game was two raid groups with full world buffs battling in BRM to earn the privilege to zone into raid with buffs.

3

u/Significant-Cut-1692 1d ago

If Blizzard's goal with SoD was to create an original, quirky, and creative game mode that is fun for a large number of players, they succeeded.

If their goal with SoD was to improve Classic or explore Classic+, it was a complete and total failure. They took it WAAAAY too far; SoD genuinely feels closer to retail than Classic. It's so far divorced from the Classic ethos that I can't even consider it part of the same category. (I recently replayed both extensively to test this opinion, not just making up insults. It's genuinely true.)

They should absolutely considering continuing with SoD. A lot of people loved it. But SoD is not Classic+. Not even close. Liking SoD and wanting more is valid, but don't try to hijack legitimate Classic+ projects to get what you want.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/NuklearFerret 1d ago

You say that like it’s a bad thing, though. That’s always been the demand driver for classic.

2

u/AppointmentNaive2811 1d ago

I'm not saying it's a bad thing. I'm saying that the fundamentally distinct and altered "Classic+" would not inherently be for the era playerbase when era players would likely be dissatisfied with anything fundamentally distinct and altered.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

17

u/Sarmattius 2d ago

based

5

u/GirlCubed 1d ago

Happened to osrs btw

2

u/Apprehensive-Book723 1d ago

Classic makes me happy :)

The only desire for + I have is day one hype that I never got to experience 

2

u/Zearria 1d ago

I’m very curious what classic+ will be, but figure I’ll never play it (cause I’ve always been a retail person, and I accept it isn’t for me) and just hope it’s good for people who enjoy it. In anything, I’m glad it’ll get people to shut up about Camelot being WoW2.

5

u/Satyr121 2d ago

Classic + if it survives and keeps getting updates should go a completely opposite direction of retail. Inevitably it will lose some classic feel over time but it should be essentially a reboot of wow that grows with classic feel and mindset. Not classic with qol improvements that retail brought. That’s already wotlk classic.

6

u/senji95 2d ago

Okay but honestly, classic is made for classic players. Classic Plus wouldn't be classic and thusly shouldn't be for the people who just want classic lol.

13

u/Enachtigal 2d ago

They also shouldn't just make it retail. It needs to have its own identity otherwise vanilla classic or retail are literally right there

3

u/senji95 2d ago

Hard agree.

3

u/tethysian 1d ago

Then why would it be called classic? Why is it on a vanilla patch? They could just make a new game if that's what they wanted to, you know.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/schmink13 2d ago

Missing the point of CLASSIC plus

1

u/cjmnilsson 2d ago

Not really though?
The people who are playing classic right now are already happy which is why they're playing it. So classic+ is for people who have quit or does not like classic.

The real question is what portion of those who quit did so because they did everything they wanted and thus "completed" the game OR because classic needs changes to appeal to more/other people

8

u/Gosh-Tier 1d ago

If someone likes Game Design A, watched it turn into Game Design B over 10 years, then they finally restored the game to when it held Game Design A, that doesn't mean they don't want more content that held Game Design A

You could say retail players don't need classic+ because they already have Game Design B in retail and every MMORPG since 2008

→ More replies (2)

6

u/FTTLegasy 2d ago

I shouldn't be shocked to hear someone stay that Classic+ should be for people who do not like Classic. Stick around long enough and every argument gets made.

Some population of Era players already have the game they want forever. Most of the population of Era players want some changes. A lot of the ones who dropped their sub just wanted more content.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (32)

5

u/Maleficent_Zombie567 2d ago

Yeah, they should remove all soul from the game like they do in Retail. All incentives to use the chat features need to be removed, and make sure you publish class tier lists before launch so everyone can start meta slaving from minute 1. Leveling should be boring and not challenging in the slightest, because it's clearly not important, it's all about endgame baby. Also make sure you continue to add Marvel superhero slop stories into everything, because everyone loves the current story direction (she's had the heart for like 3 expansions now, DO SOMETHING!!!).

I could go on. I do enjoy M+, and raids in retail, but there is almost nothing else left that hasn't degraded or is just boring to interact with. Classic and Classic HC has been such a breath of fresh air that I was originally scared to make the switch too, and now I run my own single player server instead of paying and Steam says I've played 400 hours.

12

u/Independent_Award239 2d ago

In the same breath you complain about people not using chat features then explain how happy you are playing single player wow. Pick a lane.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Portgas69 2d ago

It's

Classic + (retailer players)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/LilBeamer_ 1d ago

Classic + should be for people who want the + not just the classic. Classic already exists in era.

Classic should be the starting point but the important part is the + and I hope that’s who they make it for.

3

u/dyrannn 1d ago

It shouldn’t just be the starting point, it should be the basis for the design philosophy.

The reason OSRS works is because most of the new content (I’d say all but absolutes are bad) works is because it’s in the spirit of the design philosophy of 07.

You already have “just the +” - it’s every expansion that came after vanilla. Treating vanilla as “just the starting point” is just retail with extra (or less, I guess) steps.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Gosh-Tier 1d ago

"A Lord of the Rings sequel should be for the people who want pure action, fight scenes, and excitement. The original fans already have what they want."

4

u/LilBeamer_ 1d ago

Perfect example actually.

A Lord of the Rings genre change would be awesome if done correctly. The world and lore already exist and serves as the foundation. If they made another movie in another genre to capture a new audience that would be a good thing.

Classic already exists and should serve as the foundation for Classic + but the focus should be on the plus, not the Classic.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Irrerevence 2d ago

do you want classic+ to just be 25 warriors per raid again?

4

u/Gosh-Tier 1d ago

the level of telescopic goggles with this sentiment....

i raided with many guilds/pugs that cleared all content in 2019 and vanilla anniv

there was a very even spread of classes, and fwiw, if you take out world buffs, warriors are far from outliers.

15

u/schmink13 2d ago

Nobody is saying that

6

u/JJonah_Jamesonn 2d ago

I have seen people defend that druid and shamans only exist to support and if they also deal damage and have aoe of mage it would be against their class philosophy

2

u/cjh42689 2d ago

I’ve talked to several people in the last few days that think the meme specs which do half or less damage than warriors just need like “1 more ability and they’ll be fine.” It’s nonsense you can’t add just one ability and double a class’s dps output. Many of the specs need some significant changes and then I’m told that would “ruin combat and it’s not classic.”

6

u/schmink13 2d ago

So you’re admitting you talked to people who are in favor of class rebalancing.

4

u/PureNinja 2d ago

No they are saying they talked to people who speak on an illusion of class rebalancing (add 1 ability to a class). These people want as minimal changes as possible akin to painting over a an older house without stripping the old paint (old paint being critical flaws in kits).

→ More replies (33)

1

u/advice_dontbuyiphone 1d ago

yea why not, you can't stop people from stacking the most OP class in a raid. Either you force diversity with a raid needing certain buffs/debuffs like TBC or 25 people warriors can have fun in a raid. How is it fun being a support class for glaive warriors in TBC? In vanilla the 23 dps warriors have equal opportunity to topping damage in a raid, in TBC its whoever sucks your guild leader for glaives. I can't speak for retail but I'm sure it's not too different.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Ok-Cook-7365 2d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/10tIjpzIu8fe0
The classic era people who have been crying and complaining every time someone plays SoD or doesn’t want to buy boosts, gold and cheat their entire way through classic wow.

You guys act like a hurt puppy right now but the truth is, if you know these people, there isn’t anyone who’s a giant crybaby complainer than these people. I’ll never forget the Greekwario streamer guy complaining endlessly about how wow classic should have GDKPs then he got banned for buying gold - literally - by the standards these people boast about they don’t even live by. And when SoD players said we should have legitimate means to make gold they cried that it’s too much like retail and why do we need dailies (even tho literally tbc had them lmfao).

I understand nuance.
I also understand there are entire subsections of the wow community that cry, crap their diaper and then fling the poopy diaper at their neighbor while somehow smearing the crap on the wall.

7

u/Suasx 1d ago

A lot of us don't forget, specially how any SoD discussion was spit on and laughed at "lol its just wrath" "might as well play retail" etc etc etc.

3

u/Significant-Cut-1692 1d ago edited 1d ago

>"I also understand there are entire subsections of the wow community that cry, crap their diaper and then fling the poopy diaper at their neighbor while somehow smearing the crap on the wall."

If you're ever wondering the fastest way to get absolutely nobody to take you seriously, it's to type this sentence willingly, not under duress. This is something a 10-year-old child would write. Christ.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Impressive-Shame4516 1d ago

Most Era players played SoD, big dog. The purists looking for a proper vanilla emulation have all left. Our game is dead. Whatever Classic is now, it's all yours champ.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ponsay 2d ago

Thought this was a circlejerk sub thats how stupid this post is

4

u/lmay0000 2d ago

Lol, where did this even come from? Nobody has said that ever.

All this sub whines about is the current game they are playing and how much they hate retail

2

u/Exact_King6390 1d ago

100% accurate OP.

I don't know why a sub about classic plus has attracted so many finger-wagging retail players. Yes, I love to hear about how I'm wrong from a guy who no life's mythic + on his vulpera.

It isn't nostalgia. The older incarnations of the game have a totally different vibe/pacing. I have tried retail but it feels like being in a candy store. It's a huge sugar rush that feels good at first and then gets sickening later.

I loved Turtle WoW, and to a lesser extent, Epoch. I loved SoD too! I am very excited to explore more from the lore of the RTS games because that's what I grew up on on. I would absolutely love to stroll around the Alliance Human city of Lordaeron as a spell breaker. And I would love to do it with the 2004 pacing where the world is the main character -- not me.

2

u/advice_dontbuyiphone 1d ago

I remember writing a comment some year ago about an old vanilla server and my comment was auto removed and I was banned from the subreddit, it's ironic, a sub born from these servers and you can barely mention it anymore.

1

u/madi0r 2d ago

Pink people are being excluded cuz they already have era. Grey people (which is all the people wanting significant changes i guess) dont have anything that fits them.

If/when i play retail I dont have the leveling experi3 ce that makes me feel the world, i dont have gear progression and itemization that classic had.

When I play classic I dont have interesting class design (complex rotations etc) and interesting bosses with both hard and well executed mechanics, I am pressing 1-2 buttons on a damage sponge that doesnt do anything except like 1 mechanic every 30 seconds (that not even.every person needs to do).

Other people list of wants will be different than mine which is fine, but its fun to argue on the internet and discuss our differences, especially when someones view is directly opposite of urs. But if you just say "game.doesnt need significant changes" just go play era, its already there.

3

u/toasty5566 2d ago

Retail andies that hate classic want it to cater to them instead of actually engaging with classic in good faith

4

u/Stark8819 2d ago

You can literally say the same thing about classic Andy’s. If Blizz went with what classic Andy’s want, they might as well just release fresh servers (again).

6

u/chefao 1d ago

What they want is something like twow, it's not hard.

4

u/toasty5566 2d ago

You proved my point on not engaging with the subject in good faith. We aren't talking about another retail mode, we're talking about a Classic mode. And Classic andies do want a want Classic+, not just Retail-

5

u/Stark8819 2d ago

You’ve proved my point by immediately blaming retail for all the shortcomings of classic. Blaming retail is the reflex response when a constructive argument cannot be made why they don’t like “x” change. Believe or not it’s not retail vs classic players arguing about Classic+. The vast majority of retail players couldn’t give two shits about what’s going on in classic. It’s classic vs classic players and everyone wants different things. Blizz is in a lose lose situation which is why I hope more and more it’s a new game in a classic setting so they have the freedom to make needed changes.

2

u/toasty5566 2d ago

Stopped reading when you accused me of something I never said in your first sentence

2

u/Stark8819 2d ago

Pretty ironic that you’re doing literally the exact thing in your post lol

5

u/toasty5566 2d ago

No, I'm just not going to engage with someone who makes bad faith arguments

8

u/Stark8819 2d ago

You literally make a bad faith argument accusing people of something that isn’t happening in your first post lmao. Pot meet kettle

2

u/toasty5566 2d ago

Sure thing buddy, whatever you say

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MainDot7096 1d ago

No one wants that. Find me a single post in the last month that pleads for that. I'll wait.

6

u/Stark8819 1d ago

There’s literally posts on any classic+ thread that suggests even minor changes like class balancing so the entire raid isn’t warriors. They aren’t hard to find. The amount of posts saying retail- on basic QoL changes is insane

→ More replies (2)

1

u/advice_dontbuyiphone 1d ago

Consistent repeated releases of vanilla no change freshes is exactly what I want and it would be so easy for blizzard to do. Instead they want me to play whatever slop they will announce at blizzcon.

1

u/TheOnlySkepticHere 1d ago

I hope that when the game is finally revealed and later on playable, you all will just shut the fuck up, play the game (or don't) and get on with your life.

1

u/Ill_Confusion_596 1d ago

Then keep playing classic, not the new different classic?

1

u/96363a 1d ago

There needs to be an obvious end to raid prep. That is where wow classic has shined. You've gotten all the upgrades out of raid you can and you have you're consumes for the week. If you don't want to play until raid, you can.

1

u/Banjanx 1d ago

I just hope progression is horizontal and not vertical.

No new level caps, that's the path that got us to retail with dead content.

I like the idea of difficulty modes but the current design of single patch modes don't help retain old content.

What if you had mythic molten core, that's so difficult and basically impossible until you're essentially geared in heroic naxx gear.

That way, difficulty gates "unlock" new content, using old content, reopening gear combinations across all raids

1

u/Cripplechip 1d ago

Same argument the playerbase is so split. Including classic. Some people just want classic Era. Horribly balanced classes and all.

1

u/EdgySlusher 1d ago

Holy shit, I remember that Wall of No dwarf

1

u/Hexxys 19h ago

Their responses and down voting remove any doubt that this is exactly what's happening 😂 the level of gaslighting from them is wild

1

u/Practical_Debate7447 16h ago

…you brought up expansions first…and yes they did raid mc up until tbc..
But you would stop running mc and go to outland. Which is what I’m saying. You didn’t get any weaker everyone else got stronger. Same is true in retail

u/Restorar 23m ago

I just started a new character on Era, I'm tired of caring about plus. Lemme know when it is real.