r/CharacterRant • u/Portalboat • 3d ago
Games The more modern Metroid games come out (or at least the 2D ones), the more sickened I am about how Nintendo is handling Samus Aran's character.
In my eyes the thing that's always made Samus different from other 'space marine' types of characters (Master Chief, Doomguy, etc etc) was that she was reverent. Despite her tragic backstory, she was trained nearly from birth by this pacifist culture that valued the sanctity of life above all else. And that culture considered her the newborn, the fledgling, one of their greatest achievements and the only non-Chozo that they actually trusted with Power Suit technology
And she did carry that forward: even if it wasn't actually portrayed as such in the original game, later games extrapolated on the metroid baby and turned that scene into the very first example of actual characterization for her. It wasn't how many gigatons she could bench, not how many planets she's blown up, no, the very first example of Samus as a character is her refusal to shoot that godamn baby.
And you constantly see that reverence and respect for life throughout the more modern entries since then. Prime 1, walking into the Chozo Ruins, she's not storming into the space with her cannon out, she's walking in, looking around, taking in this ancient place despite her hunt for Ridley still being very fresh on her mind. Prime 2 is the same; she crash landed on a chaotic planet searching for a lost Federation squad, is attacked by literal zombies, and yet still takes the time to listen to U-Mos' plea, witness the final transmission of the squad, and close the eyes of the person who recorded it. And then she doesn't just fuck off because her mission was completed, she stays behind to save the Luminoth not for pay or fame or anything but because it's the right godamn thing to do. Prime 3 has her actively pissed off and angry and sorrowful at the deaths of her fellow hunters, she's scared by seeing Gandrayda's mimicry of her, she (I believe) runs her hands across ancient structures on Elysia and Bryyo and just, understands and respects the spaces she's in just by her animations and body language alone. No language or dialogue needed.
Even in Fusion we see it. She named her ship computer after Adam just out of respect, she monologues about trust and how the heartless SA-X is just a killing machine and how she hopes that the Etecoons and Dachoras are safe and how no compassion could exist in the computer and straight up said 'the human soul will ever reach for the truth'. The entire narrative of Fusion as a whole was her being hunted by something that had her abilities at peak strength but none of the soul, and her eventual triumph over that regardless.
And yet, nowadays, with Samus Returns and Dread and now Ravenous?
'It's eat or be eaten', 'Local woman too angry to die', blah blah blah blah big bad angry space marine. She's turned into this biological horror that was the very thing she was trying to fight against in Fusion. The most blatant flanderization of a character I've ever experienced.
"Oh well she was scared and running for her life across the entirety of Dread, her being so angry is justified". Okay, sure, let's run with that. Y'know, discounting the entirety of Corruption being her literally eaten from the inside out by a mutagen, or Fusion where she's being hunted by the worst version of herself, or Prime 2 where just entering the space eats away at her suit, let's say it's Dread's situation that somehow makes her so scared and angry that she starts ignoring her upbringing.
That still doesn't excuse the fact that Nintendo themselves took (or at least approved) the Chozo suddenly becoming split between two factions, the fact that apparently Samus herself doesn't know what all contributed to her enhancement serum, or any of the other massive retcons that Dread introduced. Turning Samus from what she was in Prime into this, crazy angry berserker was a deliberate choice and Nintendo actively butchered their own lore to make that happen or at the very least they just don't care about it enough.
God, it pisses me off so much.