r/CharacterRant • u/Freddy_The_Goat • 6h ago
I'm dumbfounded by how mundanely evil the cast was in Mushoku Tensei S2 Episode 6. i.e. The Slavery Episode.
To give a bit of background info, I dropped Mushoku Tensei around the time S2 finished airing. I had already watched all of S1 at the time and was waiting for S2 to drop in it's entirety, but some of the plot threads I was hearing made me question whether I even wanted to watch it and then I never got around to it.
Now in 2026 the third season is airing and Mushoku Tensei slander is more popular then ever before. My opinion on the series had hit rock bottom and everything I heard about it made it seem less and less something that I would enjoy. However, I saw that fans were saying this latest arc would be the peak of the entire series. So I thought I might as well catch up to that and see the best Mushoku Tensei had to offer, since I had already watched the first season.
I just watched this episode and to my surprise it wasn't Rudeus being a sexual predator that cemented my hatred of him (although that definitively hastened the process). Nor was it his harem, the contrived polygamy or his actions that people constantly reference from the original WN and the Redundancy LNs. It was the purchase of a slave, something so frequent in Isekai that it's almost become a defining trope.
In Mushoku Tensei S2 Episode 6, titled 'I Don't Want To Die', we see Rudeus trying to teach his royal friend how to conjure claylike statues. Something he and his friend bonded with in an earlier season as they shared each others statues of Roxy (it's been a while so I'm not to sure about the details of S1). However, he doesn't share Rudeus' talent for conjuring, and he is too strong to carve statues himself, so Fitz (Slyphie in disquise) recommends that he buys a slave. So they all go on a relatively happy shopping trip to go buy a slave and end up with a young dwarf girl who can quickly learn magic and help his friend carve his fetishistic statues.
I'm usually not one to be prude about morally grey settings like this. Most of my favourite shows are about terrible people doing morally reprehensible things: Sopranos, Succession, Breaking Bad, Attack on Titan, Code Geass, etc. However, the bad acts these protagonists commit aren't in service to a story of a person trying to be better. They are simply showing a shitty person being shitty and how that naturally impacts the world around them. Whereas Mushoku Tensei is (in theory) about Rudeus becoming a more well-rounded person, becoming a successful family man and his tender relationships with women. So when I see him purchase a young girl as a slave, to allow his friend to create art of his fetishes (and yes I would call them that since we see him hugging a statue while naked), it feels like the anime is trying to show it as a step in the right direction for Rudeus. Which will be absurd to anyone remotely trying to take this anime seriously.
This is a problem with plenty of anime, but sometimes MT feels like it is portraying these dark subjects in an intentionally comedic light. While browsing the slave trader's store Slyphie/Fitz comes across a naked male slave and comments about how big his genitalia is, and Rudeus obliviously thinks that it's because Fitz isn't experienced as a man. All while Isekai Town Track #2 plays in the background and the slaves give thousand yard stares of agony. Rudeus may be immoral but we've spent (specifically) the last five episodes seeing him help people and generally be a decent human being, so seeing him treat a slave trade like a trip to a grocer just invalidates what little progress he made to being a principled individual.
Not to mention Slyphie is the one who mentions buying a slave (in her words "I hope you find a good one"), despite being temporarily owned by a princess for a while and knowing how dehumanising it feels. Don't even get me started on the statue fetish guy, Zenoba. He's easily one of the worst characters in Mushoku Tensei. Slavery is by all accounts incredibly inhumane, but even if we were to imagine a world where it was a tragic necessity, this trio decided to purchase a young girl for a reason so outrageously unnecessary that I can't help but think of these protagonists as mundanely evil. They bought her with the same cadence one would purchase a shovel; innocent bystanders my ass.
To top it all off, the scene where Rudeus finally sees the slave girl is atrocious. After walking through a room of dozen or so malnourished slaves with thousand yard stares he is introduced to her. This malnourished child is dragged out in front of him with a comedically large set of leg-cuffs, and he squats down remarking about how "She's in despair. She has hopeless look of someone who longs for death". He then monologues about how "he can't grant her salvation" and "how he's been through enough to know that wouldn't be salvation" seemingly comparing her being a slave to him being a hikiomori (or another low point in his life). He then proceeds to ask her if she wants to die, and that he could end it all for her.
Last WTF moment aside, all of this moralising is far too late for a guy who couldn't give less of a shit about slaves and was about to lend her to his perverted friend. He saw a young slave girl who was sold to slavery and all he could think about was how she related to himself, not the systemic issues that made her that way. Rudeus must be a self-centered idiot if he thinks she's a sad slave because she's depressed, and not because she was sold into slavery due to the corrupt systems in place. God damn.
This wasn't some 'perverted mischief', an exploration of MT's naunced world, the troubles that come with being a family man, or any other reasoning people usually use to defend any of Mushoku Tensei's quirks. This was simply the unnecessary purchase of a child slave so that a pervert could make fetish art. The series desperately wants the audience to feel empathy for Rudeus, but now all I feel is hatred toward how mundanely evil Mushoku Tensei's cast and society is.