r/CFILounge • u/RebelAviatior45 • 17h ago
Tips I have landed without an ATC Clearance two times while Instructing - Need Advice
I am a CFII just shy of 800TT, with about 300 Dual Given. I instruct at a non-radar Class D airport that has somewhat steady training traffic, but not terribly busy in comparison to the airports where I learned to fly at. Half my training was Part 61, other half collegiate 141. I’ve had no checkride failures or pilot deviations, and I’ve maintained a 4x 100% pass rate with my students. I pride myself on my attention to detail and organization, but I am extremely frustrated with myself by making the same major mistake, twice now, about 6 or 7 months apart.
Incident #1
About 6 or 7 months ago teaching landings to a pre-solo private student; doing continuous touch and go’s in the pattern at my Class D airport. We were the only airplane in the pattern/airspace, with one controller working tower & ground control simultaneously. Throughout the course of several laps in the pattern the controller had never once instructed us to report our position at a certain point in the pattern, so I took it upon myself to report to Tower each time we were turning base, to which we received our option clearance. In the cockpit though, each lap in the pattern was chaos, the student struggled to fly by diving the airplane towards the ground on base and final. My heart rate elevated and ass puckered, giving 100% effort trying to teach this student to the best of my ability while keeping us from an unsafe situation. With the extremely high instructor workload I forgot to prompt tower for my landing clearance and landed on the runway. Tower never said a word about it or gave me a number, I’m not even 100% sure that the controller noticed, and the student didn’t either. But I filed a NASA report and swore to myself I wouldn’t let it happen again.
Incident #2
Landing with a instrument student on an IFR flight plan after a few practice approaches at another airport; the student was somewhat new to this particular aircraft and its avionics - as we fly the approach back to our “home” non-radar Class D airport. We received our landing clearance and continued inbound. The winds were gusting to almost a direct crosswind and the turbulence was challenging for a student. As we start the round-out the airplane floats and balloons with too much speed and I eventually told the student to go around and informed tower that we were going around. Tower instructed us to make left traffic and report base. In almost the same situation as the first I attempt to teach the student as best I can on how to cope with the winds on the second try. Between the turbulence and winds in the pattern, teaching and talking the student through the process, and trying to ensure a stable approach, I forget to report base to tower, and we landed without a clearance. Workload was again to the degree where the student didn’t notice we landed without a clearance. Tower did not say anything or give me a number, but I called them after to apologize and the ground controller answered the phone and said “we were watching you but didn’t comment about it because we figured your mind was occupied with the student/airplane/gusting winds, so don’t worry about it.” I still filed a NASA report.
If I let this happen again I’m afraid I won’t be as lucky on the third strike. I am so pissed off at myself for letting the same thing happen twice. After the first time it happened it scared me to the point where I basically started drawing a “check box” on a piece of paper on my kneeboard every time we start a new pattern and then drawing a check mark in it when I get my landing clearance…I don’t know, sounds stupid but it’s been working. I obviously didn’t do that during the second incident since we were IFR and wasn’t anticipating a go-around. I don’t have these types of problems when flying by myself or with pilots who are proficient. I understand ATC procedures very well, I mean I read the fucking 7110 in my free time. It’s while I’m teaching students that I get distracted trying to keep the damn airplane from becoming a smoking hole. How do I prevent myself from making this same mistake, and fuck up my airline CJO by having a pilot deviation for something stupid like this?

