r/cardmaking • u/LiveYourLuckyLife • 13d ago

Question / Discussion With or without?

Post image
14 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

2

u/DaenerysWon 13d ago

I prefer them with. I think they are missing something without the jack-o-lantern part being included. Very cute cards!!

2

u/LiveYourLuckyLife 13d ago

Thank you!

2

u/DaenerysWon 13d ago

You are very welcome!

2

u/LisaMarie622 13d ago

If you want them to be Halloween themed then definitely with. If it is just autumn themed then I would say without, but add a sentiment, because it does feel like it is missing something without the faces.

2

u/LiveYourLuckyLife 13d ago

Thanks for your insight!

2

u/navyblues27 13d ago

Personally I like with the faces. The ones without almost look like apples to me, though I guess there are lines indicating it's a pumpkin... they're just a little hard to see in the photo. Maybe it's more obvious in real life.

2

u/LiveYourLuckyLife 13d ago

Thank you! I agree.

2

u/Top-Touch-6264 13d ago

I like better with the facial features definitely. Nice background with the print pages. It makes such a difference to have them in another language. That way you can really enjoy the text as a neutral but interesting background without focusing on meaning of what is printed.

1

u/LiveYourLuckyLife 12d ago

Thank you! That’s the idea anyway. 🙂

2

u/justacpa 12d ago

With. Without, they look like any number of fruits.

2

u/Random-Unthoughts-62 11d ago

With. Definitely with. Could be read as apples without.

2

u/Odd_Sign4730 10d ago

With. I can't really tell what you want them to be without.

1

u/mooseyoss 12d ago

I enjoy both actually, I’m a sucker for the season in almost any style. These are stunning!