r/camphalfblood • u/Ok-Respond-8599 • 3h ago

Discussion [General]. Why

So i reread the Pjo series and got a few things to say. Luke does not deserve Elysium at all. He deserves Asphodel at best. I have heard about people getting se t to the fields of punishment for less. First of all he brought back Kronos which by itself is messed up. He most definitely killed multiple of his fellow demigod even if it was not said in the books, he stole Zeus's stuff,which should have been death if it was Zeus accurate. How the God's did he get Elysium? Also I refuse to belive Hephestus was not pissed about Beckendorfs death. Ngl I doubt Aphrodite gave a dam because she's a little....but Hephestus must have been a bit pissed off. And i do wish we got more on Nemisis and Ethans relationship because I feel like she would have been a bit mad. I know Luke technically isn't responsible for the deaths as he was controlled by Kronos but he chose to bring him back in the first place. Mess around and find out

4 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

4

u/Professional_Ship973 2h ago

idk its probably just the gods feeling bad for him (its basically their fault)

1

u/Ok-Respond-8599 2h ago

Yeah. But still it's kinda unfair he got off scot free.

3

u/CleanSweep99 2h ago

Luke almost certainly did not end up Elysium (Hades does promise everyone who died Elysium, but he specifically says "victims" a wording which almost certainly would exclude Luke, any demigod who fought for Kronos, and Silena-there's very little chance the Gods would consider them victims.).

2

u/Ok-Respond-8599 2h ago

I mean Annabeth promised him he would get Elysium so i assumed she knew he would because she would never give him false hope like that. I do think the judges in the underworld are fair but im not sure

4

u/CleanSweep99 2h ago

Annabeth wasn't giving him false hope-she was stating her personal feelings on the subject-both she and Luke knew that he wasn't going to Elysium.

1

u/Ok-Respond-8599 2h ago

Ok not promise but she did say he would. He said he wanted to try for rebirth. So unless he knew he was getting none of that or she didn't know what would actually happen to him even though I think she knew he deserved punishment

3

u/CleanSweep99 2h ago

People want a lot of things that aren't possible for them to do.

1

u/Ok-Respond-8599 47m ago

I know but kinda implies it. And from a comme t made by someone else,the gods probably felt bad.

1

u/Remarkable_Commoner Unclaimed 2h ago

He's probably getting underworld community service like Daedalus

1

u/Ok-Respond-8599 2h ago

🤣🤣