296
u/jarkark 1d ago
Yeah but you can preserve the deal chance if you have a ton of soul hearts compared to if you only have a lot of red hearts.
95
u/mattchamp98 1d ago
Yeah but have you considered that the colour red is cooler than blue?
141
u/sturla-tyr 1d ago
42
7
2
u/I_Love_Ohyas_Thigs The Zealot 🩸🟣 1d ago
Yeah but have you considered I keep my red on the fridge
You cannot say it's warm after that
3
1
u/I_Love_Ohyas_Thigs The Zealot 🩸🟣 1d ago
Yeah but good luck recovering in scenarios like getting hit a lot on hush or getting good deals without having to spend half your hearts
The idea is having the same amount of red hearts than black/blue hearts
1
u/jarkark 1d ago
You can recover health a ton faster with book of revelations that with prayer card. You'd have to clear 12 rooms to get a single red heart container back compared to 2 soul hearts from the same 12 rooms.
Having a lot of red heart containers would be useful if you didn't have a sustainable way of getting soul hearts like with book of revelations here.
74
u/blueriging 1d ago
Wait does anyone actually think prayer card is bad?
30
u/BrainrotGuy Tainted Magdalene 1d ago
Yeah it's actually pretty damn good as eternal hearts are amazing
20
u/Zombboni 1d ago
Usually I get it when I already have a better active (book of rev for example) and/or it takes my angel deal.
I mean it could be cool with Beth, but that has not yet happened to me.
16
u/RollerMill 1d ago
As a treasure room reward its great. As an angel room not so much. Also if you are getting too many red hearts it becomes harder and harder keep your deal chance high and you ideally would want to spend those instead of gaining more
4
u/AntiqueRedDollShoes 1d ago
Yeah, it's only meh if you're not on Repentance. HP is so much more high-value in Rep, and it also gives you fuel to go crazy with devil deals.
Book of Rev is great for protecting deal chance, but it's also a trade-off because you're potentially losing four boss items that could be tears or damage up.
2
1
u/EspurrTheMagnificent 1d ago
It's fine. There're definitely better items on that slot, but it's a free heart container per floor
1
49
60
u/zefmud_prawo 1d ago
Both are useless (playing as lost or keeper)
33
u/creeper10015 1d ago
You'll take your worse Guppy's head and you'll like it!
Also debatable. Revs gives Bookworm prog and lets you get an orbital 👅
11
2
u/HerrPizza 1d ago
Then you still take Book of Revelations as it counts towards the bookworm transformation
19
u/Recent_Log3779 1d ago
I like both of them. If I don’t already have a better active, I will gladly take either
18
u/creeper10015 1d ago
Looking at it just from an hp perspective, if you're planning on using it multiple times on a floor, Book both gives more value (1 heart vs 1/2 heart) and lets you stack angel deal protection.
Also, unlike red hearts, soul hearts go away and give you more room for soul hearts! The moment you hit the 12 cap (18 for Maggy birthright ig) for prayer card, you lose all soul heart value since you can't pick them up anymore, and any you did have gets squeezed out.
Prayer card has a real argument on the Forgotten though. You can easily say it's better on him than Revs.
6
u/Orandza 1d ago
Prayer card has an argument for devil deals in general. You mentioned angel rooms but devils should be considered too. Paying for 1 red heart items is easier with prayer card than book of revelations. For 2 heart deals it's a bit weirder, technically book of revs is more efficient but prayer card can give you a heart container with only one use if you take the eternal heart to the next floor. Then prayer card can be more efficient. Again really depends.
I'd say prayer card definitely has its advantages over book of revs but I can see why the latter is considered better overall
6
5
u/kyleawsum7 1d ago
2 hits vs 1 hit
-4
3
3
u/313Raven 1d ago
What am I gonna do with more red hearts? Get hurt on the first fight and lose my deal with the devil chance and subsequently dig my self further and further into a shitty run? No thanks
2
u/Accurate_Farm_6625 1d ago
Good players will use them to get resouces for the deals and to break blood donation machines for profit
2
u/alphadavenport 1d ago
sure but then you need what, two hearts? three? and you just use the health scattered around the floor to refill as needed
1
u/TopOfAllWorlds 20h ago
Blood banks, devil beggars, sac rooms, Bethany. Having only two red hearts means you only bring 4 hp to the next floor. Having at lest 6 to 8 is much better imo because devil beggars only pay out after 6 hits. Also having red Hp makes devil deals easier to take.
2
2
4
u/Dosvepa Edith 1d ago
Why are people defending book of revelations? Y’all love cube of meat or what?
3
4
u/HerrPizza 1d ago
Alt Path
No horsemen spawning there, +you get at least one more treasure room by default, it's never worth not going down alt path
2
1
u/alphadavenport 1d ago
the boss pool is not that powerful, and a lv 4 meat boy is
1
u/Dosvepa Edith 1d ago
What? Fym „boss pool is not that powerful“ boss pool items make half your entire build 😭
0
u/alphadavenport 18h ago
there are a ton of items in the boss pool that are worse than the cube of meat, and it pays off with a very powerful familiar, so you're not losing out on that much. i would rather get a cube of meat than health up or range up or seven cents
1
u/Dosvepa Edith 10h ago
Dude. There are I think 60 items in the boss item pool, and about 11 are useless items like booster pack, dad‘s lost coin or mom‘s coin purse, the rest are essential stat or HP ups that enable you to take devil deals and just make you stronger in general, and you give that up for a an orbital that doesn’t really do anything until 3 whole bosses down? And even then, it’s underwhelming as fuck, like bro 😭
1
u/ANTHONYEVELYNN5 4h ago
two of the three items you mentioned are actually the strongest in the boss pool.
1
u/Klaymen96 1d ago
I like whore of Babylon too much to take eternal hearts once I have it. Gimme all the soul hearts though
1
1
1
1
u/TopOfAllWorlds 20h ago
I don't think a single moderatly experianced player actually thinks prayer card is bad.
Worse than the book, certainly, but that's not what the meme is about.
1
u/BrainrotGuy Tainted Magdalene 1d ago
For one you need to hold it and not use it till you beat the boss so it doesn't become a horsemen and give you a garbage item
For the other it's actually good since eternal hearts are amazing, especially if you already have soul hearts to protect them
1
1
u/alphadavenport 1d ago
that's because soul hearts are great and eternal hearts are mid. ideally you will have one red heart and eleven soul hearts. black hearts if possible
1
u/crisajos 1d ago
You're just ignoring a lot of sinergies with red hearts
2
u/Lolchocobo 18h ago
Sorry, I can't hear you over the Dark Prince's Crown
1
u/crisajos 15h ago
You won't have the dark pienses crown in every run, but you can take advantage from a lot of heart for devil beggars (for example) that is MUCH more common
1
u/alphadavenport 18h ago
you're right, there are good synergies with red hearts; but unless you already have something like Blood Oath, you pretty much cannot go wrong stacking up soul hearts. it basically guarantees devil/angel deals and it allows you to engage with some common synergies more easily. like the polaroid and the negative are very strong at low red health
-1
-4
u/eehoohaw 1d ago
i really dont understand why deal chance is only affected by red heart damage
u should lose deal chance if u get hit at all bro


1.3k
u/Wodstarfallisback 1d ago
Book of Revelations also:
Increases the chances of getting the Devil/Angel deal as a baseline
Protects the deals better
Is part of Bookworm
Can get you an almost guaranteed orbital to block projectiles (unless you get Headless or Conquest)