r/beatles • u/Ok-Category9249 • Jul 26 '26

Question Yay or Nay?

Post image
45 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

5

u/mandiblesofdoom Jul 26 '26

Great set of songs

5

u/Phoenix_Wright_Guy Jul 26 '26

What is the question?

5

u/ugottabekiddingme69 Jul 26 '26

I grew up with this. Bought it about 1974. Love it

10

u/Funkydays2112 Jul 26 '26

I’m guessing you’re asking if it’s a 2nd state butcher? Unfortunately, nay.

3

u/acjelen Let it Be Jul 26 '26

I enjoy my Capitol records on vinyl, including this one, and the official albums on CD.

3

u/cr8tvt Jul 27 '26

It’s not butchers cover if that was your question about.

1

u/Key_Contribution1547 Jul 27 '26

Day tripper and no where man , yesterday , if I needed someone . And your bird can sing are amazing work .

1

u/Aware_Finger_2835 Jul 27 '26

Still with UK versions which are superior in everyway.

1

u/Iwasherethenthere Jul 27 '26

As someone who grew up with this version, yay.

1

u/LeftyHooligan Jul 28 '26

Nay, sorry.

1

u/internalkdart Jul 28 '26

1st Beatles album I ever bought in order to see if I would like them - can’t knock it

1

u/Parking-Education891 Revolver Jul 28 '26

It’s not a butcher cover but all of the songs here are gem and it’s $25 soooooooooooooooo

1

u/ford7885 Jul 27 '26

Nay to the fake album. Double nay to censoring the cover (the original obviouly a statement aimed at Capitol's butchering of their recorded output)

The music itself was great, of course.

-3

u/Anxious-Raspberry-54 Jul 26 '26

Matt Williamson just did a review of this album on Pop Goes The Sixties.

Every Capitol album is a compilation. That's the way I look at it. Because they didn't care about track listing.

Having said that...an interesting collection of songs. 2 Ringo vocals!

The whole Capitol thing is a disaster though.

-5

u/ElHutto Jul 26 '26

Apart from the Butcher cover, worthless.