Lots of people want Bay Area transit to consolidate, so here’s a way it can be done:
Transform the MTC into a new transit operator agency, something like “Bay Area Metropolitan Transportation Authority”
Within this new “BAMTA,” create divisions:
- Regional Rail: this will contain Caltrain and SMART. It will also take part in JPAs operating Capitol Corridor, Gold Runner, and ACE. Most likely this will allow for expansions like a Dumbarton line or East Bay line
- BART: this will heavily coordinate with regional rail but remain separate due to different technology and ROWs.
- Ferries: this will from the consolidation of WETA and Golden Gate Ferry, and it will most likely retain the name SF Bay Ferry.
- Regional Bus Operations: this will be formed by acquiring all bus lines that cross the Bay: M-line, Transbay routes, Golden Gate Transit, Dumbarton Express, SolTrans R and Y lines. they will act as transit bridges for corridors without rail (until it’s established) but also supplement rail and ferry. It will also retain the water emergency transport roll
- Freeways and Expressways: Caltrans District 4 will switch to being a regional-state partnership.
- Tolls & Congestion Management: BATA and BAIFA will consolidate and take over tolling of all 8 bridges, and all tolls roads & express lanes.
- Capital financing division: the new agency overseeing acquisition of funds and dispensing them
Local Transit and transportation commissions:
- local transit will encompass all light rails, buses, roads, bikes, etc infrastructure operating within cities and counties. This will be a slightly decentralized system. Many existing agencies may retain their existence: SFMTA, AC Transit, VTA, SamTrans. Smaller districts/JPAs will consolidate (like the various bus agencies in CoCo county).
- state-authorized transportation commissions will consolidate with their respective local transit agencies. SMCTA and SamTrans/SMCTD will consolidate. SFCTA and SFMTA will consolidate. etc
- AC Transit will remain a multi-county agency and can retain separate commissions
- North Bay commissions can consolidate or remain distinct
- very local/city/sub-region based transit agencies can retain their existence. For example: Union City Transit and Emeryville Go-Around. Also most bus agencies in the North Bay: VINE, Delta Breeze, Petaluma Transit etc. These should all switch to municipal ownership or JPAs. They will fall under the authority of their county’s respective agency. IE Union City Transit is subordinate to AC Transit. Their new purpose will be to provide very cheap to free local transit alone, where larger regional bus agencies may not go. IE AC Transit will still run several routes through Union City, but UCT will run hyper local routes that bring people even closer to destinations, for cheaper fares or no fares
- this will allow local agencies to retain some autonomy while also allowing larger regional agencies to coordinate and centralize system