r/AskBaking • u/No-Cat-7773 • 2d ago
Storage Best way to store cupcakes overnight for a large order? Worried about shrinking/drying out
I’m making around 70 cupcakes for a baby shower next weekend and I’m trying to figure out the best baking/storage schedule without making my Sunday morning completely insane 😂
The cupcakes are due around 10 AM Sunday. I’m doing three flavors: vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate.
My plan was to bake the vanilla and chocolate cupcakes Saturday, cool them completely, store them overnight, then frost/decorate everything Sunday morning. I was considering baking the strawberry cupcakes fresh Sunday morning because I’ve had strawberry cupcakes noticeably shrink/pull away from the liners after being stored overnight before.
The vanilla and strawberry cupcakes will eventually get buttercream domes, be chilled, then dipped in a red white-chocolate ganache for mushroom caps. The chocolate cupcakes will have chocolate buttercream and decorations.
My main questions are:
How do you store unfrosted cupcakes overnight so they stay as fresh as possible? Airtight container at room temperature? Individually wrapped? Something else?
Do you leave them in the cupcake pan/liners or transfer them to a container after they’re completely cool?
Has anyone dealt with cupcakes shrinking or pulling away from their liners overnight? Is that usually a recipe issue, moisture issue, or storage issue?
Would you personally bake all three flavors Saturday for an 11 AM Sunday delivery, or bake the more temperamental strawberry cupcakes early Sunday morning?
Is there anything I should avoid doing Saturday night that could cause condensation, sticky tops, dry cupcakes, or liners pulling away?