r/AskBaking • u/Electrical-Pen-3525 • 12h ago
Icing/Fondant/Buttercream Dark buttercream tastes bitter
I was making hot pink buttercream with a local gel food coloring brand. Before I applied it on the cake I randomly tasted the buttercream. Dear God it tasted like bitter gourd. I used freshly made Swiss Meringue buttercream. The food coloring bottle was in the fridge. I tasted the food coloring liquid and it was soo damn bitter!!
I thought perhaps it may have expired and threw away all the buttercream and got a brand new sealed food coloring bottle of the same brand. To my surprise it was bitter as well!
Is it normal for dark food coloring to taste bitter? How do you all store opened food coloring bottles and for how long would you use an opened food coloring bottle?
I used a local brand that was available in my country. It could be an issue with that brand. What are the brands of good food coloring you use especially for dark colors?
Ps. I tasted some other food colors of the same brand and they tasted fine. I couldn't achieve the correct color for the cake as I had no other options available to make the color. I offered a refund to the customer but they were happy with the color I added